Male mating behaviour affects growth of secondary sexual traits: a mechanism for rapid phenotypic change

Abstract

Intra- and intersexual selection drives the evolution of secondary sexual traits, leading to increased body size, trait size and generally increased reproductive success in bearers with the largest, most attractive traits. Evolutionary change through natural selection is often thought of primarily in terms of genetic changes through mutations and adaptive selection. However, this view ignores the role of the plasticity in phenotypes and behaviour and its impact on accelerating or decelerating the expression of sexually selected traits. Here, we argue that sudden changes in selection pressures (e.g. predation pressure) may cause a cascade of behavioural responses, leading to a rapid change in the size of such traits. We propose that selective removal of individuals with the most prominent traits (such as large antlers or horns in male ungulates) induces behavioural changes in the surviving males, leading to a reduction in the growth of these traits (phenotypic expression). To test this idea, we used an individual-based simulation, parametrized with empirical data of male bighorn sheep, Ovis candensis. Our model shows that the expression (phenotype, not genotype) of the trait under selection (here horn size) can be negatively impacted, if the biggest, most dominant males in the population are removed. While the selective removal of prime males opens breeding opportunities for younger, smaller males, we predicted that it would come at the expense of growth and maintenance. As predicted, we observed a rapid decline in average male horn length in our model. We argue that this decline happens because smaller males, instead of allocating energy into growth, divert this energy towards participation in mating activities that are typically exclusively available to prime males. While our model deals with ecological life-history trade-offs, it cannot predict evolutionary outcomes. However, this nongenetic mechanism is important for the understanding of evolutionary processes because it describes how heritable traits can rapidly change because of behavioural plasticity, long before any genetic changes might be detectable.