Subterranean estuaries form the land-sea transition zone in coastal aquifers and are relevant for coastal freshwater management and coastal ecology. Tidal fluctuations typically lead to the formation of upper saline plumes, where denser saltwater circulates on top of the discharging, less dense freshwater. Extensive numerical simulations and only a few experimental trials previously demonstrated that these saline plumes may become unstable and exhibit salt fingering flow. This work used laboratory sand tank experiments to study the formation and evolution of tide induced flow instabilities in homogenous, unconfined coastal aquifers in a systematic manner, addressing the combined effects of relevant parameters such as sediment type, beach slope, fresh groundwater inflow, tidal amplitude, and tidal period variation. Some of these parameters have never been targeted in laboratory-based studies before and a comparable systematic and comprehensive approach has so far not been conducted. The resulting flow patterns were studied visually through the application of a colour tracer to the saltwater. The results show that the upper saline plume may be stable, unstable, or transitional, whereby the beach slope predominantly defines its state. When salt fingers form, they amplify the mixing zone between ground- and saltwater and force the freshwater to discharge at multiple locations along the beach. The processes were best visible in the coarsest sediment (1.02 × 10-2 m s−1). The finer grained the sediment was, the smaller the upper saline plume that formed. The present study further reveals the possibility of three-dimensional fingering flow, even though the physical model was intended to represent a two-dimensional cross-section. The application of a previously proposed non-dimensional stability diagram yielded reasonably accurate predictions of stability behaviour in coastal unconfined aquifers under laboratory settings. This further supports the plausibility of flow instabilities in subterranean estuaries within specific ranges of influencing hydrogeological factors.