AbstractMussel‐inspired polycatecholamine coatings and films have proven to be versatile materials for surface modification. However, the progress of chemically modified coatings with tailored properties has been slow due to the lack of definitive evidence of their polymeric structure. Polycatecholamines form aggregates during polymerization, and their formation mechanism has been a subject of debate owing to their insolubility in traditional molecular solvents. Exploiting the capability of ionic liquids (ILs) to exhibit strong electrostatic interactions, herein, the first solution‐phase polymerization approach is reported to achieve polymerization of four catecholamines – dopamine (DA), norepinephrine (NE), L‐3,4‐dihydroxyphenylalanine (L‐DOPA), and adrenaline (AD). Kinetic control over the polymerization process in the solution phase enabled it to follow the process with 1H NMR spectroscopy, revealing the formation of structural features of resulting complex heterogeneous and soluble polymers. The polymers are both covalent and associative in nature. Solution phase polymerization prevented the formation of large aggregates in the solution, thus facilitating the formation of coatings that are ultra‐smooth and have root mean square roughness of the order of sub‐nm to nm scale.