Kori Unit Research Articles

Proposal of database of radiological characterization for decommissioning nuclear power plants

AbstractIn Korea, Kori Unit 1 was permanently closed in 2017 and scheduled for decommissioning. Kori Unit 1 is currently scheduled to undergo system decontamination and to be decommissioned by December 2038. Measures to properly control and remove radiological hazards must be established to go through decommissioning a nuclear power plant (NPP). Radiological characterization must precede NPP decommissioning. Radiological characterization generates a lot of data during this process. The consistency of radiological characterization data is important for systematically decommissioning NPPs. However, the data generated from radiological characterization may not be systematically managed because a database of radiological characterizations for Kori Unit 1 has not been properly established. Therefore, this study has proposed a database to be filled during radiological characterization in terms of occupational radiation exposure of personnel and decommissioning waste safety using key performance indicators presented by the International Atomic Energy Agency. From the perspective of occupational exposure, databases have been proposed for operational history investigations, decommissioning source term calculations, and investigation of the level of radiological contamination. From the perspective of the safety of decommissioning waste, databases were proposed for operational history investigation, decommissioning source term calculation, investigation of the level of radiological contamination, and investigation of radiological characteristics of decommissioning waste.

A study on the dose evaluation of critical groups for unrestricted reuse of the site after the decommissioning of Kori Unit 1

In the calculation of DCGLs using RESRAD code, the selection of input parameter values is paramount, which is basically possible when specific measures for selecting reuse scenarios and probabilistic evaluation methods are established. When referring to the impact of the age group considered in the environmental impact assessment among the existing operations of the plant, it may also need to be applied in the decommissioning project, and there will be considerations along with site reuse scenarios and probabilistic evaluations. Therefore, the main purpose of this study is to distinguish the types of exposure affected by residual radioactivity contamination during the process of deriving DCGL to be used in the final site release stage of NPPs and to evaluate them by reasonably assigning age group parameter values. In addition, the case of entering a single value for parameter values by age group and the case of entering probabilistic distributions were compared and analyzed.

Evaluation of Worker Radiation Exposure during the Kori Unit 1 Steam Generator Dismantling Process

Kori Unit 1 was permanently shut down on June 18, 2017. Since then, Korea is actively preparing for the decommissioning of the nuclear power plant. Because decommissioning work is performed in a radioactive environment, worker radiation exposure is a significant consideration. In this study, worker radiation exposure is evaluated during the steam generator, one of the heavy components of nuclear power plant, dismantling process. A radiation evaluation for the dismantling process is performed using the code RESRAD-BUILD. A steam generator dismantling scenario and optimal cutting method are designed to evaluate worker radiation exposure, considering pipe dimensions, cutting tool speed, and experience in steam generator replacement. The evaluation results are derived for each work type and year. As a result of the evaluation, worker radiation exposure is 7.5 man-mSv at the year of planned decommissioning.

A Study on the Construction of Cutting Scenario for Kori Unit 1 Bio-shield considering ALARA

Nuclear power plants are subjected to various processes during decommissioning, including cutting, decontamination, disposal, and treatment. The cutting of massive bio-shields is a significant step in the decommissioning process. Cutting is performed near the target structure, and during this process, workers are exposed to potential radioactive elements. However, studies considering worker exposure management during such cutting operations are limited. Furthermore, dismantling a nuclear power plant under certain circumstances may result in the unnecessary radiation exposure of workers and an increase in secondary waste generation. In this study, a cutting scenario was formulated considering the bio-shield as a representative structure. The specifications of a standard South Korean radioactive waste disposal drum were used as the basic conditions. Additionally, we explored the hot-to-cold and cold-to-hot methods, with and without the application of polishing during decontamination. For evaluating various scenarios, different cutting time points up to 30 years after permanent shutdown were considered, and cutting speeds of 1–10nullm2/h were applied to account for the variability and uncertainty attributable to the design output and specifications. The obtained results provide fundamental guidelines for establishing cutting methods suitable for large structures.

The Impact of Full-System Decontamination of Kori Unit 1 on the Radioactive Waste Classification of Steam Generator Tubes

Kori Unit 1, which was permanently shut down on 18 June 2017, is planned to undergo full-system decontamination prior to major decommissioning activities. One of the advantages of performing FSD is the downgrading of the classification level of radioactive waste. From this perspective, the impact on the steam generator (SG) tubes, which account for a considerable portion of the total surface area during FSD operation, was examined. Initially, the CRUDTRAN code was used to predict the radioactivity inventory of the Kori Unit 1 SG tubes, which turned out to be approximately 21% more conservative than the measured value. To estimate the radioactivity in the tubes after FSD, decontamination factor values from overseas cases in the SG tubes section were selected and applied. Then, the regulations for radioactive waste in Korea were reviewed, and the specific activity was calculated by predicting the mass of the SG tubes. As a conclusion, it was confirmed that the SG tubes will be classified as low-level radioactive waste, whether FSD is performed or not. Furthermore, it was observed that even if a high efficiency of FSD is achieved, if stored, it would take more than 50 years for clearance.

A methodology to designate radiation‐controlled areas in decommissioning nuclear power plants

AbstractKori Unit 1, which was permanently shut down in 2017, is expected to be the first decommissioned commercial nuclear power plant (NPP) in Korea. Operating NPPs designate radiation‐controlled areas (RCAs) to protect workers from radiological hazards and provide appropriate measures. Decommissioning RCAs (DRCAs) in NPPs being decommissioned should also be designated by considering the radiological characteristics of workplaces and exposure routes of decommissioning workers, such as external and internal exposure. However, the criteria for the DRCAs in decommissioning Kori Unit 1 are presently the same as those during normal operation, according to the public‐hearing material of the final decommissioning plan for Kori Unit 1. This study analyzed criteria for RCAs in all Korean NPPs to propose criteria for DRCAs in decommissioning NPPs. Analysis results show that RCAs are classified into four, five, six, and eight zones in Korean pressurized water reactors with respective external radiation dose rates. The RCAs in Korean pressurized heavy water reactors are classified into six zones with external dose rates and derived air concentrations of tritium. This study proposes three classifications of DRCAs to keep occupational exposure as low as reasonably achievable while considering potential exposure routes, that is, external exposure, airborne contamination, and surface contamination areas. First, the external exposure areas are classified into several zones according to the levels of external radiation dose rates. Second, the airborne contamination areas are designated to prevent internal exposure to workers from the inhalation of radioactive material in the air during cutting and demolition. Last, the surface contamination areas are designated to minimize the skin contamination of workers as radioactive dust in the air is deposited on the surface of facilities and equipment over time.

Transport Risk Assessment for On-Road/Sea Transport of Decommissioning Waste of Kori Unit 1

Transport Risk Assessment for On-Road/Sea Transport of Decommissioning Waste of Kori Unit 1

Study of the radioactivity inventory deposited in the reactor coolant system during the decommissioning of Kori Unit 1

The Kori Unit 1, a first nuclear power plant (NPP) in South Korea stopped operation permanently on June 18, 2017 after 40 years of operation. Before the main decommissioning activities begin, full-system chemical decontamination operation (FSCDO) of the primary systems is planned to secure the safety of workers and minimize the quantity of radioactive waste. In this study, the radioactive inventory at the time of decommissioning of Kori Unit 1 was investigated. The CRUDTRAN code was used to make predictions by using the actual operation and maintenance history and design data of Kori Unit 1. Regarding the steam generator (SG), the prediction results obtained using the CRUDTRAN code were 17–30% higher or more conservative than the direct measurement results obtained using survey meters. By applying the oxide layer removal ratio (OLRR; obtained through a chemical decontamination field test using the contaminated specimen) to the oxidation/deoxidation process during FSCDO, the removal rate of radioactive inventory could be predicted. As an actual decommissioning work proceeds, the detailed data of radioactive elements in RCS systems can be obtained through sampling and chemical analysis. Those data will be much valuable for both the operation and future decommissioning of current NPPs.

Global Radioactive Waste Disposal Trends and Prospects

Nuclear power generation, which began in the Soviet Union in June 1954, has now become a main source of electrical energy in 33 countries around the world. However, radioactive waste and its safety have always been at the center of controversy, and even after 70 years, there is no official regulation on the disposal of radioactive waste under international law. In this review, the policies and current status of radioactive waste disposal in major countries around the world, including Korea, are investigated. Based on this, the direction for radioactive waste management in Korea was presented. Currently, radioactive waste is disposed of in two ways. Finland, Sweden, and France are conducting deep permanent disposal according to the recommendation of the International Atomic Energy Agency, and Japan, the United Kingdom, and India are promoting reprocessing of spent nuclear fuel to reduce waste and the volume of the repository. Korea has been temporarily storing radioactive waste at the site of the power plant since the completion of Kori Unit 1 in 1978, but it is expected that the capacity of the temporary storage facility will reach its limit in 2031. Accordingly, the securing of a permanent disposal site and the development of reprocessing technology are being studied together, but no tangible results have been achieved so far. Korea's radioactive waste disposal has problems such as a small land area, institutional difficulties in developing reprocessing technology, frequent policy changes, ignorance and indifference, and lack of smooth communication. Although public concern about nuclear power generation has increased due to the Fukushima disaster, not many people are interested in spent nuclear fuel. Within the framework of reprocessing and permanent disposal, Korea should refrain from frequent policy changes that can confuse public opinion and research and development, and come up with a long-term realistic policy.

Classification and consideration for the risk management in the planning phase of NPP decommissioning project

The decommissioning project of a nuclear facility is a large-scale process that is expected to take about 15 years or longer. The range of risks to be considered is large and complex, then, it is expected that various risks will arise in decision-making by area during the project. Therefore, in this study, the risk family derived from the Decommissioning Risk Management (DRiMa) project was reconstructed into a decommissioning project risk profile suitable for the Kori Unit 1. Two criteria of uncertainty and importance are considered in order to prioritize the selected 26 risks of decommissioning project. The uncertainty is scored according to the relevant laws and decommissioning plan preparation guidelines, and the project importance is scored according to the degree to which it primarily affects the triple constraints of the project. The results of risks are divided into high, medium, and low. Among them, 10 risks are identified as medium level and 16 risks are identified as low level. 10 risks, which are medium levels, are classified in five categories: End state of decommissioning project, Management of waste and materials, Decommissioning strategy and technology, Legal and regulatory framework, and Safety. This study is a preliminary assessment of the risk of the decommissioning project that could be considered in the preparation stage. Therefore, we expect that the project risks considered in this study can be used as an initial data for reevaluation by reflecting the detail project progress in future studies.

Prioritization of radiological accident scenarios during decommissioning of nuclear power plants by risk matrix and AHP method

As part of the safety evaluation during the decommissioning process of Kori Unit 1, candidate scenarios were selected using the risk matrix method. Since Korea has no experience in dismantling commercial nuclear power plants, systematic research on how to select accident scenarios in risk assessment is performed. In this paper, the priority of 11 candidate scenarios selected by the risk matrix method is determined using the AHP method to facilitate the selection of additional scenarios.

Evaluation of system design modifications for full system decontamination of Kori Unit 1

Kori Unit 1 is planning a system decontamination project to reduce radiation exposure of decommissioning workers, prevent the spread of contamination and down-grade the level of classification of radioactive waste. The system decontamination range for Kori Unit 1 will be the entire primary system, including RCS, CVCS and RHRS. Some system design modifications are required for the system decontamination operation. In this paper, major system design modifications were evaluated based on the conditions that system restoration is needed after completion of system decontamination. The major system design modifications are CIDF connection location to system, system decontamination operating pressure control, RCP seal water injection and formation of letdown flow. It was evaluated that there was no negative effect on the system due to the system design modifications. However, as the RCP seal water is injected into the system in the oxidation process, the concentration of the oxidizing agent is diluted. Therefore, the oxidizing agent injection and system decontamination operation procedures should be developed to address the dilution effect of the oxidizing agent. The system design modifications dealt in this paper will be finally confirmed through on-site investigation in the future, and if necessary, the system design modifications will be re-evaluated.

Packing placement method using hybrid genetic algorithm for segments of waste components in nuclear reactor decommissioning

As Kori unit 1 is undergoing the decommissioning process, estimating the disposal amount of waste from the decommissioned nuclear reactor has become one of the challenging issues. Since the waste disposal amount estimation depends on the packing of the waste, it is highly desirable to optimize the waste packing plan. In this study, we developed an efficient scheme for packing waste component segments. The scheme consists of 1) preparing three-dimensional models of segments, 2) orienting each segment in such a way to minimize the bounding box volume, and 3) applying hybrid genetic algorithm to pack the segments in the disposal containers. When the packing solution converges in the algorithm, it comes up with the number of containers used and the placement of segments in each container. The scheme was applied to Kori-1 reactor pressure vessel. The required number of containers calculated by the developed scheme was 24 compared to 42 that was the estimation of the prior packing plan, resulting in disposal volume savings by more than 40%. The developed method is flexible for applications to various packing problems with waste segments from different cutting options and different sizes of containers.

External exposure specific analysis for radiation worker in reuse of containment building for Kori Unit 1

The containment building Kori Unit 1 may require sequential steps for full decommissioning. This study assumes that the containment building is to be used as an auxiliary building that handles nuclear power systems and materials during decommissioning before conversion into a greenfield. Through the derivation of guidelines and dose evaluation, it was confirmed whether the radiation workers were satisfied with the ALARA decision. The specific modeling of the external radiation exposure was performed based on the facility investigation procedures. The external radiation specific derived concentration guideline levels (DCGLs) for radiation workers in containment building were obtained using the RESRAD-BUILD code and were applied to the VISIPLAN 3D ALARA Planning Tool code to calculate the working dose and check worker safety. The derivation of site-specific and realistic DCGLs and dose evaluation via 3D modeling can contribute to the scenario development for the decommission and remediation of containment building.

Estimation of radiation dose resulting from the recycling of large metal wastes from decommissioning nuclear power plants in Korea

AbstractFollowing the permanent shutdown of Kori Unit 1 in June 2017, the Republic of Korea has been preparing for full‐scale decommissioning work. In addition, the design life of 12 units will expire by 2030. If decommissioning begins without initially extending the lifespan of nuclear reactors, massive amounts of decommissioning wastes will be generated in a short period. The total amount of radioactive wastes generated during the dismantling of a pressurized water reactor is estimated as 6200 tons, and approximately 70% of the total radioactive wastes are classified as metal wastes. Self‐disposal through the decontamination of contaminated metals can contribute to the economic feasibility of decommissioning nuclear power plants because it can reduce the disposal cost of medium‐ and low‐level radioactive wastes. Therefore, this study evaluated the possibility of self‐disposal of steam generators that may occur during future decommissioning. The radioactivity analysis data on transferring the replaced steam generator of Hanul Unit 1 were used as the source term. The decontamination factor was calculated by applying 200 units from 1200 to 2000, and the radiation dose was evaluated using the RESRAD‐RECYCLE code. Consequently, the single‐nuclide concentration and sum of the allowable concentration fraction for mixed radionuclides at a decontamination factor of 1400 were below the regulatory requirements; however, the dose evaluation results exceeded the allowable dose in some scenarios. The decontamination factor was 2000, when the dose evaluation results for all scenarios met the regulatory requirements.

A Study on Annual Atmospheric Dispersion Factors Between Continuous and Purge Releases of Gaseous Radioactive Effluents

Radioactive materials from nuclear power facilities can be released into the atmosphere through various channels. Recently, the dispersion of radioactive materials has become critical issue in Korea after Kori Unit 1 and Wolsong Unit 1 were permanently shut down. In this study, annual atmospheric dispersion factors were compared based on the continuous release and purge release using the XOQDOQ computer program, a method for calculating atmospheric dispersion factors at commercial nuclear power stations. The meteorological data analyzed in this study was based on the Shin Kori nuclear power meteorological tower which has the largest operating nuclear power plants in Korea, for three years (from 2008 to 2010). The analysis results of the dispersion factor of the radioactive material release obtained using the XOQDOQ program showed that the difference between the continuous release and purge release was within two times. This study will be valuable helpful for revealing the uncertainty of the predictive atmospheric dispersion factor to achieve regulation.

A Study on the Evaluation of Surface Dose Rate of New Disposal Containers Though the Activation Evaluation of Bio-Shield Concrete Waste From Kori Unit 1

This study evaluates the radioactivity of concrete waste that occurs due to large amounts of decommissioned nuclear wastes and then determines the surface dose rate when the waste is packaged in a disposal container. The radiation assessment was conducted under the presumption that impurities included in the bio-shielded concrete contain the highest amount of radioactivity among all the concrete wastes. Neutron flux was applied using the simplified model approach in a sample containing the most Co and Eu impurities, and a maximum of 9.8×104 Bq·g−1 60Co and 2.63×105 Bq·g−1 152Eu was determined. Subsequently, the surface dose rate of the container was measured assuming that the bio-shield concrete waste would be packaged in a newly developed disposal container. Results showed that most of the concrete wastes with a depth of 20 cm or higher from the concrete surface was found to have less than 1.8 mSv·hr−1 in the surface dose of the new-type disposal container. Hence, when bio-shielded concrete wastes, having the highest radioactivity, is disposed in the new disposal container, it satisfies the limit of the surface dose rate (i.e., 2 mSv·hr−1) as per global standards.

Preliminary Evaluation of Radiological Impact for Domestic On-road Transportation of Decommissioning Waste of Kori Unit 1

Currently, radioactive waste for disposal has been restricted to low and intermediate level radioactive waste generated during operation of nuclear power plants, and these radioactive wastes were managed and disposed of the 200 L and 320 L of steel drums. However, it is expected that it will be difficult to manage a large amount of decommissioning waste of the Kori unit 1 with the existing drums and transportation containers. Accordingly, the KORAD is currently developing various and largesized containers for packaging, transportation, and disposal of decommissioning waste. In this study, the radiation exposure doses of workers and the public were evaluated using RADTRAN computational analysis code in case of the domestic onroad transportation of new package and transportation containers under development. The results were compared with the domestic annual dose limit. In addition, the sensitivity of the expected exposure dose according to the change in the leakage rate of radionuclides in the waste packaging was evaluated. As a result of the evaluation, it was confirmed that the exposure dose under normal and accident condition was less than the domestic annual exposure dose limit. However, in the case of a number of loading and unloading operations, working systems should be prepared to reduce the exposure of workers.

Radiological safety evaluation of dismantled radioactive concrete from Kori Unit 1 in the disposal and recycling process

For evaluating the radiological safety of dismantled concrete, the process of disposal and recycling of the radioactive concrete generated during the dismantling of Kori Unit 1 is analyzed. Four scenarios are derived based on the analysis of the concrete recycling and disposal process, and the potential exposure to the workers and public during this process are calculated. VISIPLAN and RESRAD code are used for evaluating the dosages received by the workers and public in the following four scenarios: concrete inspection, transport of concrete by the truck driver, driving on a recycled concrete road, and public living near the landfilled concrete waste. Two worker exposure scenarios in the processing of concrete and two public exposure scenarios in recycling and disposal are considered; in all the scenarios, the exposure dose does not exceed the annual dose limit for each representative.

Calculation approach to building DCGLs of waste treatment facilility for Kori unit 1 decommissioning and comparative analysis of the results

The Derived Concentration Guideline Levels (DCGLs) of remaining buildings in decommissioning site realistically need to be considered because all nuclear power plants in Korea are operated with the adjacent plant in multi-unit site. In addition, a few buildings are expected to be utilized for the decommissioning such as waste treatment facility to reduce the final disposal volume of radioactive waste. Therefore, DCGLs of buildings postulated for the decommissioning of Kori site have been assessed by using RESRAD-BUILD code. As a result, DCGLs were derived, reflecting the site reuse criteria and input prameters based on site conditions and assumptions, and compared and analyzed how they differ from DCGLs of other nuclear plants depending on radionuclides. The occupancy and renovation scenarios were applied and more than half of the target radionuclides were conservatilvely evaluated in the occupancy scenarion, while some were evaluated in the renovation scenario. The approach and methodology presented in this paper, which can be considered at the level of the transition phase, can be utilized for deriving results that reflect reality at the time of license termination.