PROF. F. A. FOREL writes me concerning my letter in vol. lxviii. p. 623, that although he did not himself observe the coloured ring around the sun prior to the first of last August, yet he has been informed that it was seen in Europe much earlier. The observers and dates quoted by M. Forel, arranged by localities from north to south, are as follows:—Director Rykatcheff, of the Central Physical Observatory at St. Petersburg, noted an opalescent veil surrounding the sun on October 5 and November 9, 1902, January 21, February 10, 18 and 23, March 17, April 5, May 29, and July 26, 1903. Dr. Busch, at Arnsberg, Westphalia, saw the same thing on November 19, 1902, March 21 and 22, 1903, and Prof. Wolf, at Heidelberg, during January, 1903. Dr. Maurer, at Zurich, observed the ring also in January, on March 27 and 28, June 7, 8, 9, and at the end of July, 1903. Therefore, M. Forel says, very properly, that since the phenomenon was observed practically simultaneously in Europe and America, no hypothesis as to why it appeared first in the last named country is needed. While admitting the truth of the statement, I would remark that a faint whitish ring around the sun was recorded by me here as early as June 26, 1902, although it was not noticed again until the close of the year. The equally early appearance over southern England of a large brownish corona, which became smaller but more conspicuous during the summer and autumn of 1902, is described by Mr. T. W. Backhouse in NATURE (vol. lxvii. p. 174).