Feminists have long been interested in how men and women's uneven reproductive roles have influenced their relative status in society. Women's place in the home, workforce and civil society has been directly traced to the biological fact that it is women and not men that have babies.1 I cannot improve upon the description given by Hale L.J., as she then was, in Parkinson v. St James and Seacroft University Hospital NHS Trust,2 of the sheer hard work involved in pregnancy, childbirth and in being a mother: From the moment a woman conceives, profound physical changes take place in her body and continue to take place not only for the duration of the pregnancy but for some time thereafter. Those physical changes bring with them a risk to life and health greater than in her non-pregnant state … along with those physical changes go psychological changes … some may amount to a recognised psychiatric disorder, while others may be regarded as beneficial, and many are somewhere in between. … Along with these physical and psychological consequences goes a severe curtailment of personal autonomy. Literally, one's life is no longer just one's own but also someone else's … continuing the pregnancy brings a host of lesser infringements of autonomy related to the physical changes in the body or responsibility towards the growing child. The process of giving birth is rightly termed ‘labour’. It is hard work, often painful and sometimes dangerous. It brings the pregnancy to an end but it does not bring to an end the changes brought about by the pregnancy. It takes some time for the body to return to its pre-pregnancy state, if it ever does, especially if the child is breast fed. There are well known psychiatric illnesses associated with childbirth and the baby blues are very common … Quite clearly, however, the invasion of the mother's personal autonomy does not stop once her body and mind have returned to their pre-pregnancy state … Parental responsibility is not simply or even primarily a financial responsibility … The primary responsibility is to care for the child. The labour does not stop when the child is born. Bringing up children is hard work … The obligation to provide or make acceptable and safe arrangements for the child's care and supervision lasts for 24 hours a day, seven days a week, all year round, until the child becomes old enough to take care of himself.
Read full abstract