198LANGUAGE, VOLUME 62, NUMBER 1 (1986) phonology, lexicon, and syntax, T discusses lexical patterning with reference to metaphorical language (119-31), and shows how the lexicon of each language reflects cultural items adopted from the indigenous mother tongues. Some of her data recapitulate material already described elsewhere (e.g. Hancock 1977, 1980); but she makes her point clearly. Peter Mühlhäusler, 'Synonymy and communication across lectal boundaries in Tok Pisin' (134-53), is a self-contained discussion of one aspect of TP, but one which fits into a tradition of research on on-going changes in this language (e.g. Mühlhäusler 1980). TP uses a technique of pairing synonyms such that an old and a new expression appear together linked by o 'or, that is': hospitel o haus sik. Such pairings are discussed from several viewpoints: the status of synonymity in TP, the function of synonym pairs, their grammatical properties, their role in linguistic change, and the implications for language planning. The functions are varied: the introduction ofnew lexical items for new concepts, communication across regional boundaries, the elimination of clumsy paraphrases and low prestige non-English forms, and the replacement of referentially wide items by more specialized terms. This is one of M's shorter papers, but it displays his usual thoughtful and thorough work. It is, indeed, the most workmanlike contribution to the collection. The volume concludes with a 'Bibliography' (155-68) containing—in principle —all works referred to in the various papers (in fact there are a couple of minor errors/omissions). This practice of integrating references, favored by Karoma, has much to recommend it. REFERENCES Andreski, S. 1972. Social sciences as sorcery. London: Deutsch. Baker, Philip, and Chris Corne. 1982. Isle de France Creole: Affinities and origins. Ann Arbor: Karoma. Bickerton, Derek. 1981. Roots of language. Ann Arbor: Karoma. ------. 1984. The Language Bioprogram Hypothesis. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 7:2.173-221. Hancock, Ian F. 1969. A provisional comparison of the English-based Atlantic creóles. African Language Review 7.7-71. ------. 1972. A domestic origin for the English-derived Atlantic creóles. Florida FL Reporter 10.7-8, 52. ------. 1977. Lexical expansion within a closed system. Sociocultural dimensions of language change, ed. by Ben G. Blount & Mary Sanches, 161-71. New York: Academic Press. ------. 1980. Lexical expansion in creóle languages. Theoretical orientations in creóle studies, ed. by Albert Valdman & Arnold Highfield, 63-88. New York: Academic Press. -----. 1985. The domestic hypothesis, diffusion and componentiality: An account of Atlantic Anglophone Creole origins. Paper presented at the Workshop on Universals vs. Substrata in Creole Genesis, University of Amsterdam. Mühlhäusler, Peter. 1980. Structural expansion and the process of creolization. Theoretical orientations in creóle studies, ed. by Albert Valdman & Arnold Highfield, 19-55. New York: Academic Press. [Received 11 July 1985.] With a daughter's eye: A memoir of Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson. By Mary Catherine Bateson. New York: William Morrow, 1984. Pp. 242. $15.95. [Paperback edition, New York: Pocket Books, 1985. $4.95.] Reviewed by Deborah Tannen, Georgetown University Why review here a book that has been widely discussed in the popular press? Reviews of this book have focused primarily on the private life and personality of Margaret Mead (hereafter MM). One would hardly know, reading them, that REVIEWS199 the book is also about Gregory Bateson (GB), let alone suspect how much of it is devoted to summary and discussion of their scholarly work. There is also little in those reviews to indicate that the book is important for linguists, or that it could be used as a text in courses on anthropological linguistics and discourse analysis. For this is a biography and a memoir which demonstrates as it advocates—and shows to have been demonstrated, in the lives and work of MM, GB, and Mary Catherine Bateson (MCB)—the inseparability of the intellectual and the personal, of observer and observed, of ideas and their contexts, of the public and the private, of knowing and feeling. By describing her experience of her parents' lives and work and how they shaped her own, MCB has written a book that can be read in several ways— as a novel, for its...
Read full abstract