Cyperus esculentus seeds are often considered irrelevant for C. esculentus spread as their fragile seedlings would not establish or survive in agricultural soils. However, the ever-increasing spread and upsurge of genetically different clonal populations in NW-Europe raises questions about the establishment of C. esculentus seeds and the reproductive performance of seedlings. Indeed, little is known about the potential of C. esculentus seedlings to grow and propagate under outdoor conditions relative to plants grown from tubers. Seeds from different clonal populations were sown outdoors in various soil types and under different irrigation levels (rainfed, irrigated) to assess seed germination and seedling establishment. Additionally, two pot experiments were conducted with three different plant types (plants originating from mother tubers and from seeds harvested on open- or self-pollinated plants) obtained from eight clonal populations. Plant performance was investigated by measuring vegetative and generative parameters. Germination under outdoor conditions was significantly affected by clonal population and was highest in irrigated sand (5.3%). Germination in sand was 4.1 times higher in irrigated plots than in rainfed plots. In irrigated plots, germination was 3.8 and 4.7 times higher in sand than in sandy loam and clay, respectively. Depending on the year, three out of five to five out of six clonal populations produced more tubers when grown from mother tubers than from seeds. Maximal tuber reproduction factors of 1:965, 1:752, and 1:618 were achieved for plants from mother tubers and seeds from open- and self-pollinated flowers, respectively. Plants originating from open-pollinated seedlings have the potential to equal or exceed the vegetative reproductive capacity of plants originating from mother tubers. As a result of their ability to establish in situ and their substantial vegetative reproductive capacity, C. esculentus seedlings are highly relevant for agriculture and merit appropriate attention in any integrated weed management system targeting C. esculentus.