Caprocks play a pivotal role in petroleum systems for the accumulation of oil and gas, as well as in processes such as steam injection for heavy oil recovery and geological storage of CO2. In this study, the geological and geochemical characteristics of the caprock from the Cretaceous Wabiskaw Member (Mbr.) and overlying Clearwater Formation (Fm.), situated above the Athabasca oil sand region, were thoroughly examined using core samples obtained from well 1-22-90-14W4. Through HAWK programmed pyrolysis and solvent extraction, the caprock succession was revealed to exhibit limited organic content with total organic carbon content < 2.0 wt% and extractable organic matter (EOM) < 200 ppm. Further analysis using gas chromatography-flame ionization detector and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry on EOM unveiled insights into the mixing dynamics between the underlying oil reservoir and the caprock indigenous materials. Distinct trends in the ratios of low molecular weight (LMW) aromatic hydrocarbons, N-shielded carbazole, benzo[c]carbazole, and concentrations of carbazoles and benzocarbazoles were evident within a 5-m distance from the caprock-reservoir contact, indicating significant fractionation among compounds. Enrichment of these compounds was observed in the shale of the Wabiskaw Mbr., with a reversal of trends occurring within the initial 5 m into the overlying shale of the Clearwater Fm., suggesting limited oil penetration into the shale. The main Clearwater Fm. caprock succession was characterized by a dominance of immature, indigenous terrigenous organic matter, along with background concentrations of carbazole and benzocarbazole and an absence of N-shielded and/or LMW compound preferences. This composition starkly differed from the oil found in the underlying reservoir. The presence of calcareous cements in the Clearwater Fm. shale, approximately 5 m above the base, characterized by high bulk density (with 62% siderite), low porosity, and matrix permeability, contributed significantly to enhancing the sealing capacity of the caprock. The overall results provide compelling evidence that vertical oil leakage from the McMurray Fm. reservoir through the overlying shale of the Clearwater Fm. has not occurred during the post-lithification history with exception of the lower-most 5 m. The clay-rich argillaceous units identified in this study emerge as potential candidates for serving as effective caprock seals for steam injection and CO2 storage.