The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), fully implemented by 2015, has significantly increased the number of Americans with health insurance. However, its impact on physician reimbursement (PR) is not well studied. Our objective was to determine the ACA's impact on the professional component of PR for selected vascular surgery (VS) procedures and vascular laboratory (VL) studies at our institution. PR for the following five VS procedures and three VL studies were obtained from our billing department: CPT 34803 (endovascular aneurysm repair), 35301 (carotid endarterectomy [CEA]), 35656 (lower extremity bypass [LEB]), 36010 (introduction of catheter into vena cava), 35200 (introduction of catheter into aorta [ICAo]), 93922 (ankle-brachial index), 93925 (lower extremity arterial duplex ultrasound), and 93970 (lower extremity venous [LEV] duplex ultrasound). The data were organized by payer: Medicare, Medicaid, commercial insurers (CIs), and other. PR was studied before the ACA (January 2008-December 2009) and after the ACA (January 2015-December 2016). The post-ACA PR and insurance-adjusted reimbursement (IAR) in 2016 dollars using the Consumer Price Index were calculated and compared using one-sample t-test. The percentage difference between the post-ACA PR and IAR was also compared. PR for 1704 VS procedures and 18,904 VL studies was analyzed. The post-ACA PR was significantly lower than the IAR for most Medicare procedures (CEA, LEB, and ICAo) and Medicaid procedures (CEA, LEB, introduction of catheter into vena cava) and for ICAo for all payers. The post-ACA PR was significantly higher than the IAR for ankle-brachial index for all payers; lower extremity arterial duplex ultrasound for Medicare, other, and CIs; and LEV duplex ultrasound for Medicaid and CIs. Only Medicare LEV duplex ultrasound had post-ACA PR that was significantly lower than IAR (Table). The percentage differences for VS procedures were mostly negative for the Medicaid and Medicare groups but were more varied in the CIs and other payer groups (Fig). In comparing reimbursement before and after ACA implementation, PR for most VS procedures has not kept up with inflation. However, for most VL procedures, PR has exceeded inflation. Further efforts are needed to support VS reimbursement, including higher valuation of the Medicare conversion factor.TableComparison of post-Affordable Care Act (ACA) reimbursement and insurance adjusted reimbursement (IAR)InsurancePost-ACA reimbursement, $IAR, $P valueCPT 34803, EVARMedicare1283.511174.92<.001Medicaid1141.831108.47N/AaOther1687.691126.51.659Private1720.491643.54.927CPT 35301, CEAMedicare1119.721300.93<.001Medicaid1033.181342.13.007Other1337.141315.60.912Private1817.951753.01.423CPT 35656, LEBMedicare947.811257.25<.001Medicaid963.371363.13<.001Other693.361258.27.248Private1713.051792.02.732CPT 36010, ICVCMedicare71.1280.22.444Medicaid67.3193.76.045Other457.03152.81.424Private146.99148.32.945CPT 36200, ICAoMedicare112.01185.09<.001Medicaid84.98172.73<.001Other255.14155.00.022Private208.36268.73<.001CPT 93922, ABIMedicare24.6011.74<.001Medicaid25.0711.10<.001Other31.0416.90<.001Private53.1122.47<.001CPT 93925, LEA duplex ultrasoundMedicare79.1940.43<.001Medicaid54.2336.18.298Other141.9234.24.014Private138.0454.94<.001CPT 93970, LEV duplex ultrasoundMedicare35.8246.41<.001Medicaid47.2830.17<.001Other43.9346.08.386Private93.3466.04<.001ABI, Ankle-brachial index; CEA, carotid endarterectomy; EVAR, endovascular aneurysm repair; ICAo, introduction of catheter into aorta; ICVC, introduction of catheter into vena cava; LEA, lower extremity arterial; LEB, lower extremity bypass; LEV, lower extremity venous; N/A, not applicable.aNumber too low for statistical calculation. Open table in a new tab
Read full abstract