The tendency for patients with severe liver disease to develop an umbilical hernia has been known for some time.1,2 The denominator is hard to determine, but review of patients referred for consideration of liver transplantation shows that approximately 20% have an umbilical hernia.3 Unlike the general population, in which female sex and obesity are risk factors for umbilical hernia, patients with liver disease who form umbilical hernias are more likely to be men with muscle wasting and ascites. Although the sex difference probably reflects the incidence of cirrhosis, men with liver disease are more likely to develop hernia at the umbilicus than the inguinal canal, unlike the general population, in which the opposite is true. The reason for this is not clear because the contributory factors, abdominal distension and abdominal wall weakness, are as likely to promote an inguinal hernia as an umbilical hernia. A personal hypothesis is that portosystemic venous communication at the umbilicus transmits the additional pressure required to favor herniation to the umbilicus rather than the groin. An umbilical hernia often is accompanied by marked thrombocytopenia, even before ascites is evident. If true, it has important implications in planning the repair of an umbilical hernia in cirrhotic patients. Traditional repairs made before transplantation usually fail. Although ascites and muscle wasting are thought to contribute to the development of umbilical hernias, one third of patients will present with an umbilical hernia before the diagnosis of liver disease.2,3 In a review by the author’s group,3 several patients underwent three or four repairs before referral for transplantation. The skin over a large hernia thins and becomes prone to necrosis. Spontaneous leakage of ascites, bleeding from umbilical varices, and bacterial or fungal peritonitis may ensue. Umbilical hernias rarely incarcerate in the presence of ascites. Conversely, successful treatment of ascites may become a prelude to incarceration.3,4 The best time for umbilical hernia repair has not been considered in the literature; however, control of ascites is believed to be essential to success.1,5,6 Taking these factors into consideration, an algorithm for the management of umbilical hernias in patients with severe liver disease is suggested (Fig. 1). Liver transplantation candidates with an uncomplicated umbilical hernia usually postpone repair until transplantation unless there is rapid resolution of ascites. Urgent repair of a complicated hernia requires a strategy to control ascites, if present. Ultra–low-salt diet, diuretics, abdominal drainage, transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt, and peritoneovenous shunt have each been used.1,5,6 The high rate of recurrence of umbilical hernias in cirrhotic patients is from the era of suture repair. A trial of prosthetic mesh repair in the general population shows a lower hernia recurrence rate, but a greater wound complication rate, than suture repair.7 The latter problem may be addressed using the laparoscopic approach.8 In this issue of Liver Transplantation, Sarit, Eliezer, and Mizrahi describe laparoscopic reduction of an incarcerated bowel and placement of a mesh prosthesis to repair a recurrent hernia in a patient with cirrhosis.9 Certain risks specific to cirrhotic patients inherent in this surgical approach were not encountered. Trocar placement in the left subcostal region must be careful to avoid an enlarged spleen. Reduction of incarcerated hernia contents may be hampered by the proximity and adherence of umbilical varices. This also will make it hazardous to dissect the hernia sac and create a preperitoneal space for the mesh. Intraperitoneal placement of mesh will be prone to displacement by ascites or the formation of adhesions to intestine. Multiple trocar sites increase the potential for an ascitic leak. The surgical strategy should account for these risks. A preoperative duplex ultrasound examination will confirm the position of the spleen, determine if there is flow in the umbilical vein, and, possibly, outline the
Read full abstract