Intraobserver Reliability Research Articles

The validity and reliability of CT scan based tibial plateau mapping for tibial plateau fractures

Introduction The Schatzker and computed tomography (CT)-based three-column classifications are the most used for tibial plateau fractures. The newer “10-segment classification” suggested to have better fracture identification and more accurate planning. This study aimed to assess the interobserver and intraobserver reliability of this new classification and to clarify its validity in clinical practice. Patients and methods A retrospective analysis of 30 patients with tibial plateau fractures who were admitted to a university hospital through the period between January 2020 and December 2022 was done. Patients with complete preoperative imaging, including radiographs, CT scans with three-dimensional reconstruction, and postoperative radiographs were included. Missing imaging, open fractures, pathological fractures, conservative management, or definitive fixation by circular external fixator were excluded. Data were reviewed independently by three expert trauma surgeons twice with 2-week intervals with randomization of case sequencing to evaluate their interobserver and intraobserver reliability for the Schatzker, CT-based three-column, and the new 10-segment classifications. The validity of the 10-segment classification was assessed by the agreement on the approach and implant position suggested by the observers. Results Good interobserver and intraobserver reliability was found as regards the Schatzker and CT-based three-column classifications on both intervals. Moderate and poor interobserver reliability “on both intervals respectively” and poor intraobserver reliability was found for the 10-segment classification. As regards the agreement on surgical approach on both time intervals, moderate and good interobserver agreements were found. For the implant position, poor interobserver agreement on both intervals was found. Intraobserver agreement for the surgical approach was good, while the intraobserver agreement for the implant position was moderate. Conclusion The Schatzker and CT-based three-column classifications are still more reliable than the newer 10-segment classification. This may be explained as it is still not familiar to surgeons and needs more training to be applied in clinical practice.

Reliability of Angle Measurements Based on the Epiphyseal Scar for Knee Osteotomy: An International Multicenter Radiographic Study.

The proximal tibial epiphyseal inclination can be used as a prognostic factor for good results after knee osteotomy and measured using the tibial bone varus angle (TBVA). This angle depends on the visibility of the epiphyseal plate, which has shown poor reproducibility when measured on standard radiographs by conventional methods. To evaluate the measurement reliability of the TBVA and other angles based on the epiphyseal scar using a digital image display. Cohort study (diagnosis); Level of evidence, 3. A total of 100 whole-leg radiographs were analyzed twice by 3 orthopaedic surgeons from 2 countries in a blinded and randomized manner. Observers measured the hip-knee-ankle angle, mechanical lateral distal femoral angle, medial proximal tibial angle, and TBVA. The growth plate-tibial plateau (GPTP) angle, defined as the angle between the epiphyseal scar and tibial plateau, was measured; this angle has not yet been described for osteotomy. In addition, a modified version of the TBVA (mTBVA), defined as that between the epiphyseal scar, its center, and the center of the talus, was measured. The Ahlbäck score for osteoarthritis and a 3-grade score for epiphyseal scar visibility were also determined. The reliability of the angle measurements and scoring was evaluated using the Fleiss kappa and intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). The scores for epiphyseal scar visibility showed fair interobserver (Fleiss kappa correlation coefficient [κ] = 0.29-0.35) and strong intraobserver (Fleiss κ = 0.62-0.69) reliability. TBVA, GPTP angle, and mTBVA measurements showed good interobserver reliability (ICC, 0.76-0.77), while the GPTP angle achieved excellent intraobserver reliability (ICC, >0.9). Using digital image display, angles that depend on the epiphyseal scar-such as TBVA, GPTP angle, and mTBVA-can achieve acceptable measurement reliability despite the low agreement on the visibility of the epiphyseal scar.

Anterioposterior Views Coupled With Lateral Views Are the Best for the Intraoperative Radiographic Detection of Retained Surgical Sponges.

A retained sponge after spine surgery can cause serious medical complications and medicolegal problems. Intraoperative radiographs are commonly used to detect it. This study evaluated intraoperative radiographs under routine clinical conditions that most spine surgeons experience to detect retained sponges. In this prospective randomized clinical trial, two patient groups undergoing open posterior lumbar surgery were studied. In one, a sponge was intentionally present; in the other, none was present. Standard intraoperative lateral (LAT) and anteroposterior (AP) radiographs were acquired before closing. Radiographs were analyzed for sensitivity, specificity, inter- and intraobserver reliability for three viewing conditions: one LAT radiograph versus one AP radiograph versus one LAT and one AP X-ray (LAT+AP). A total of 111 patients were included. Accuracy, interobserver reliability, and intraobserver reliability were best for LAT+AP (80%, 96%, and 96%, respectively). Sensitivity was best for LAT+AP (87%) and specificity was best for LAT (95%). Positive predictive value was best for LAT (94%); negative predictive value was best for LAT+AP (88%). The probability of being right is better for female sex (odds ratio 1.6), younger age (odds ratio 1.02), and higher BMI (odds ratio 1.06). We recommend AP with LAT images rather than either an AP or a LAT image alone.

Diagnosing popliteofibular ligament injuries in anterior cruciate ligament-injured knees: A prospective magnetic resonance imaging study investigating the inter- and intraobserver reliability of identification of the popliteofibular ligament.

The aim of our study was to investigate the intra- and interobserver reliability for the identification of the popliteofibular ligament (PFL) in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans in patients with an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury and ascertain the prevalence of PFL tears in ACL-injured knees without clinically high-grade posterolateral corner injury. MRI readings were performed retrospectively by two surgeons on 84 patients who underwent ACL reconstruction in our department. The presence of the PFL on both sagittal and coronal images as well as the presence of PFL tears was noted. Readings were repeated 6 weeks later for one observer. The κ value was calculated to determine the intra- and interobserver reliability for identification of the PFL and the prevalence of PFL tears was ascertained. The PFL was visualized in 90.5%-91.7% of MRI scans. The intra- and interobserver reliability of visualizing the PFL on MRI had an κ value of 0.63 and 0.66 (substantially reliable), respectively. The intraobserver reliability for identification of PFL tears had an κ value of 0.26 (fair reliability). We found a 4.8% prevalence of PFL tears in ACL-injured knees. There is substantially reliable intra- and interobserver reliability for the identification of the PFL on MRI scans but only fair reliability for the identification of PFL tears. A 4.8% prevalence of PFL tears in ACL-injured knees without clinically confirmed high-grade posterolateral corner injury can be observed in our series. Level IV.

Evaluating inter- and intraobserver reliability in radiographic determination of wrist alignment following scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis

BackgroundFour-corner arthrodesis is commonly performed for advanced collapse patterns of wrist arthritis. Reduction of the capitolunate (CL) angle during four-corner fusion is crucial to allow for the greatest radiocarpal joint arc of motion. Previous studies demonstrate variable inter- and intraobserver reliability of measuring the CL angle. However, in a four-corner fusion, hardware implementation and scaphoid excision can complicate carpal alignment measurements. The purpose of this study is to investigate inter- and intraobserver reliability of measuring carpal alignment parameters following scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis. MethodsThree fellowship-trained orthopaedic hand surgeons evaluated 30 posteroanterior and lateral radiographs of wrists after scaphoid excision and four-corner fusion. Radiographic evaluation included analysis of the radiolunate angle (RL), CL angle, lunate posture, carpal height, carpal height ratio, hardware impingement, and arthrodesis technique. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) and kappa values were used to evaluate reliability of radiographic measurements. ResultsRL and CL angles demonstrated very good inter- (ICCs: 0.657 and 0.693, respectively) and intraobserver agreement (ICCs: 0.576 to 0.924 and 0.596 to 0.811, respectively). Hardware impingement metrics by dorsal prominence and radiocarpal prominence had excellent interobserver reliability of 0.821 and 0.803, respectively. ICC values for arthrodesis technique were equal to 1.00. The inter- and intraobserver ICC values for the number of screws/staples used were in excellent agreement ranging from 0.910 to 1.000. ConclusionsOur study demonstrated favorable intra- and interobserver reliability at assessing carpal alignment following scaphoid excision and four-corner arthrodesis and these metrics potentially could be used in future research to evaluate long-term surgical outcomes. Level of evidenceLevel III, retrospective cohort study.

Tibiofibular Relationships of the Normal Syndesmosis on Axial Computed Tomography in the Turkish Population.

Computed tomography (CT) is superior to plain radiography for evaluating ankle syndesmosis, but anatomical variations can affect the measurements. This study aimed to assess the radiologic parameters of the incisura fibularis and the factors that could affect these parameters. Lower-extremity CT angiography images were used to evaluate the morphology of the incisura fibularis, anterior and posterior tibiofibular distance, longitudinal and transverse length of the distal fibula, length and depth of the incisura fibularis notch, tibiofibular clear space, tibiofibular overlap, and fibular rotation. Each measured parameter was compared based on sex and body side. Also, the effect of age, height, weight, and body mass index (BMI) on parameters was evaluated. A total of 123 patients (83 men and 40 women) were included, and 246 ankles were measured. The CT measurements demonstrated excellent intraobserver and interobserver reliability. No statistically significant sex or side differences were found in tibiofibular overlap (TFO) and tibiofibular clear space, the most-used parameters in radiographs. Age, weight, and BMI were found to be correlated with TFO. The present study provides CT measurements of the normal tibiofibular syndesmosis in the Turkish population. Also, the correlations of the parameters with age, height, weight, and BMI are presented. Therefore, TFO and tibiofibular clear space of the uninjured side can be used to plan the treatment of ankle injuries.

Poster 174: Is Articular Width or Epicondylar Width Superior to Age to Optimize Radius of Curvature Matching in Capitellar Osteochondral Allografts?

Objectives: There is growing interest to use matched distal humeral osteochondral allograft (OCA) for treatment of osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the capitellum due to concerns of donor site morbidity in osteochondral autograft transplantation surgery. Current graft match processes utilize the epicondylar width (EW) of the distal humerus, though little information is available regarding the correlation of this measurement to the radius of curvature (ROC) of the capitellum. The purpose of this study was to characterize the correlation between the EW and ROC as well as to evaluate two additional candidate parameters including patient age and the distal humeral articular width (AW). Methods: Forty patients (age ≤18) were identified for analysis. The capitellar cartilage ROC was measured on the sagittal plane of each magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study at the level where the corresponding radial head was greatest in diameter (fig. 1). The EW (fig. 2) and the AW (fig. 3), which is bordered by the medial articular border of the trochlea and the lateral articular border of the capitellum, were also measured on the axial plane of each MRI study at maximal width. R2 correlation coefficients were calculated for ROC to EW, AW, and patient age (fig. 4). Intra-observer and inter-observer reliability measurements were performed to assess precision and validity of method. Results: The mean sagittal cartilage ROC, EW, and AW were 11.05 mm, 60.79 mm, and 44.31 mm. When measured against ROC, patient age had poor correlation with a R2 value of 0.46 whereas EW and AW demonstrated strong correlation with R2 values of 0.68 and 0.76 respectively. Intra-observer correlation coefficients were 0.93, 0.96, and 0.95 for ROC, EW, and AW respectively. Inter-observer correlation coefficients were 0.79, 0.94, and 0.94 for ROC, EW, and AW, respectively. Conclusions: Our results suggest that both AW and EW demonstrate superior correlation to capitellar ROC in comparison to age, and AW may be superior to EW. AW may be considered for utilization as a distal humeral allograft matching parameter particularly in patients that may have altered epicondylar morphology such as in the throwing athlete. [Figure: see text][Figure: see text][Figure: see text][Figure: see text]

Reliability of a Modified Watson-Jones Classification for Tibial Tubercle Fractures in Children.

The first case report describing a pediatric fracture of the tibial tubercle was published in 1852 in the Medical Times and Gazette, a Journal of Medical Science, literature, criticism, and news. A century later, in 1955, Sir Watson-Jones introduced the first classification system for this fracture. Despite the existence of several classification systems for pediatric tibial tubercle fractures in the medical literature, a crucial aspect of their validation-reliability and reproducibility-has not yet been systematically evaluated. In this study, a modified Watson-Jones (mWJ) classification system of tibial tubercle fractures in children was assessed for intraobserver and interobserver variability. Using the mWJ classification, 3 board-certified pediatric orthopaedic surgeons and 3 orthopaedic surgery residents, classified thirty tibial tubercle fractures based on anteroposterior and lateral radiographs on 2 separate occasions in a 2-week duration. Further comparison was made to evaluate the impact of advanced imaging, specifically computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging, on diagnostic reliability and reproducibility. The study found substantial intraobserver reliability of the mWJ classification based on radiographs alone, with a Cohen weighted kappa (κ w ) coefficient of 0.733. When advanced imaging was utilized, the reliability of the classification improved to κ w = 0.783. Similarly, interobserver reliability demonstrated substantial consistency among observers when using radiographs alone (κ w = 0.69) and improved agreement with advanced imaging (κ w = 0.75). Notably, there was no significant difference in reliability scores between senior-level attendings and residents when analyzed as separate groups. Fracture classification systems are clinically relevant tools that help organize and transfer knowledge efficiently, provide treatment guidance, propose prognostic expectations, and improve communication in academic literature. The present study demonstrated substantial reproducibility of an mWJ fracture classification system both between and within individual surgeon raters. Level III-diagnostic.

LYMPHOSCORE (Lymphoscintigraphy Scoring Reliability) Reliability of a New Qualitative and Semiquantitative Lymphoscintigraphy Scoring System for Primary Lymphedema.

Primary lymphedema (PLE) is a rare chronic disorder. Extremity lymphoscintigraphy offers access for dynamic and functional information on peripheral lymphatics and lymph nodes. We aimed to assess intraobserver and interobserver reliability of a new lymphoscintigraphy quantitative and qualitative scoring system in a homogeneous population of adult patients followed for PLE of the lower limb(s). This is a monocentric retrospective study. Clinical files of patients who underwent a lymphoscintigraphy were reviewed for inclusion. Lymphoscintigraphies were interpreted twice by 2 observers with a washout period. To assess intraobserver and interobserver reliability for both lower limbs, Cohen κ and Gwet's AC1 reliability coefficients were calculated with 95% confidence interval and P value of the zero-reliability comparison test. To interpret reliability coefficients, we used the orders of magnitude reported by Landis and Koch. One hundred forty-four patients (288 limbs) with PLE were included. For intraobserver reliability, agreement range was 0.87-1 with an almost perfect agreement in all staging items of the score for both limbs with the lower limit of the 95% confidence interval ≥80%. Interobserver reliability was overall strong or almost perfect, ranging from 0.67 to 0.97. This new scoring system demonstrated excellent intraobserver reliability and a very good interobserver reliability. Lymphoscintigraphy, when performed in a referral center and interpreted by trained nuclear medicine physicians, is a reliable means of investigation in patients with PLE of the lower limbs. This reproducibility advocates for further use of lymphoscintigraphy in multicentric cohorts of PLE patients.

Craniocervical Morphometry in Pomeranians-Part I: Intra-Observer, Interobserver, and Intermodality (CT vs. MRI) Agreement.

Currently, there are no diagnostic imaging-based studies that have focused specifically on the craniocervical morphology of Pomeranian dogs in relation to Chiari-like malformation and syringomyelia (CM/SM). The aims of Part I of this two-part study are to assess the intra-observer, interobserver, and intermodality reliability and agreement for various aspects of the craniocervical morphology of Pomeranians with and without CM/SM. Prospectively, Pomeranians were included that underwent both CT and MRI studies of the head and cervicothoracic vertebral column. Two observers (experienced and novice) independently performed CM and SM classifications, qualitative assessments, and quantitative measurements. The experienced observer performed these assessments twice. A third observer (experienced) performed CM and SM normal or abnormal classifications. Ninety-nine (99) dogs were included. Interobserver reliability was influenced by observer experience level. For the experienced versus novice observers, substantial interobserver agreement was found for classification of SM as normal or abnormal (Cohen's kappa = 0.63), while interobserver agreement was fair for classification of SM as normal or abnormal (Cohen's kappa = 0.31). Interobserver, intra-observer, and intermodality reliability were variable for different measurements and assessments, and best overall for the CT-based measurements. Interobserver reliability and agreement results should be taken into account in the evaluation of results of future studies as well as the evaluation of imaging studies of Pomeranians presented clinically.

A Novel Ultrasound Method of Evaluating Dynamic Extrusion of Lateral Meniscus in Healthy Population: Different Patterns of Dynamic Extrusion Revealed Between Lateral and Medial Meniscus.

To establish a reliable ultrasound (US) method of evaluating dynamic extrusion of lateral meniscus in healthy population, and to investigate the pattern of dynamic meniscus extrusion (ME) in lateral meniscus under loading conditions. The lateral ME was examined via US method in unloaded, double-leg standing, and single-leg standing positions. Two different US measurement methods were compared to the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) results to determine the optimal measurement methods. The US results obtained by different researchers were tested for interobserver consistency and the results obtained by the same researcher on two separate days were tested for intraobserver consistency. The patterns of dynamic extrusion were compared between medial and lateral sides. A total of healthy 44 volunteers were included in the study, with 86 knees assessed by US, and 25 knees evaluated by MRI. The US evaluation of dynamic lateral ME demonstrated excellent interobserver and intraobserver reliability. The US measurements using method A were consistent with the MRI results with no significant difference (P = .861, intraclass correlation coefficient [ICC] = 0.868), while method B underestimated the lateral ME compared to MRI (P = .001, ICC = 0.649). Lateral ME decreased slightly from unloaded (1.0 ± 0.8 mm) to single-leg standing position (0.8 ± 0.8 mm), whereas medial ME increased significantly in both double-leg and single-leg standing positions (2.4 ± 0.7 mm, 2.6 ± 0.7 mm). A novel US evaluation method of lateral ME was established with reliable and accurate results compared to the MRI. Lateral ME in healthy populations decreased slightly as the loadings increased, which was different from the pattern of dynamic extrusion in medial meniscus.

Valgus stress knee radiographs accurately anticipate the bone resection in medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty: Protocol validation using an image-based robotic system.

The objective of this study was to describe a planning method for medial unicompartmental knee arthroplasty (UKA) implantation using preoperative stress radiographs to measure the thickness of tibial and femoral bone resectionsand to validate this method with data from an image-based robotic surgery system. Having such method for preoperative planning would be of interest for surgeons performing UKA in order to anticipate optimal bone resection on both tibia and femoral sides. A new planning method for medial UKA based on valgus stress knee radiographs validated it with an image-based robotic surgery system (Restoris MCK, MAKO®, Stryker Corporation) was proposed. This retrospective study involved radiographic measurements of 76 patients who underwent image-based robotic medial UKA between April 2022 and February 2023. Preoperative anteroposterior stress radiographs of the knee were used to simulate UKA implantation. The UKA technique was based on Cartier's angle and aimed at restoring the joint line. The total dimension measured was 14 mm (8 mm for minimal tibial component and polyethylene insert + 4 mm for femoral component + 2 mm for safety laxity). Bone resections were measured in the preoperative valgus stress radiographs and then against the intraoperative bone resection data provided by the robotic system. Inter- and intra-observer reliability was assessed using 25 measurements. The mean planned tibial resection measured in the radiographs was 4.3 ± 0.4 [2.9-5.8], while the mean robotic resection was 4.2 ± 0.5 [2.7-5.8] (mean difference = 0.15 mm, 95% confidence interval [CI] [-0.27 to 0.57]). There was a strong correlation between these two values (Pearson's rank R = 0.79, p < 0.001). Intra- and inter-observer reliability were also very strong (Pearson's rank R = 0.91, p < 0.001, and Pearson's rank R = 0.82, p < 0.001, respectively). The mean planned femoral bone resection measured in the radiographs was 2.7 ± 0.7 mm [1-4.5], while the mean robotic resection was 2.5 ± 0.9 [1-5] (mean difference = 0.21 mm, 95% CI [-0.66 to 1.08]). There was a strong correlation between these two values (Pearson's rank R = 0.82, p < 0.001). Intra- and inter-observer reliability were also strong (Pearson's rank R = 0.88, p < 0.001, and Pearson's rank R = 0.84, p < 0.001, respectively). This study describes and validates with robotic information a simple and reproducible preoperative planning method to determine femoral and tibial bone resection for medial UKA implantation using antero-posterior valgus stress knee radiographs, leaving a medial safety laxity of 2 mm. It represents a very valuable contribution to the understanding of UKA principles, which can serve to extend its indications and increase reproducibility of the surgical technique. III. Retrospective cohort study.

Sonographic imaging of the stellate ganglion in healthy adults: An observational study.

The aim of this study is to estimate the normal cross-sectional area and diameter of the stellate ganglion (SG) by ultrasound (US) in healthy adults. The study sample included 80 stellate ganglia in 40 participants (15 males, 25 females), mean age 38 years, mean height 162.5 cm, mean weight 67.8 kg, mean body mass index 25.4 kg/m2. Two radiologists separately obtained US images of the bilateral SG. Each participant was scanned 3 times bilaterally to assess for intra-observer reliability. The mean diameter of the SG was 1 mm (range: 0.1-2). The mean CSA of the bilateral SG was 1.3 mm2 (range: 0.6-3.9). The SG diameter positively correlated with age. Our study demonstrates the ability of US to image the SG and estimate its normal diameter and CSA. Knowledge of how to identify and measure the SG during ultrasound-guided procedures would be expected to decrease the risk of associated complications and help establish normal reference values.

Effect of clinician's experience and expertise on the inter- and intra-observer reliability of the computed tomography-based classification systems in posterior malleolus fractures.

Three computed tomography (CT)-based classifications, including Haraguchi, Bartoníček-Rammelt, and Mason-Molloy systems, have been developed to better determine the characteristics of posterior malleolus fractures (PMFs). The aims of this study were (1) to determine the intra- and inter-observer reliability of the computed tomography-based classification systems and (2) to investigate the clinical experience and expertise on their reliabilities. Sixty-seven preoperative ankle CT scans of 67 adult patients with "ankle fracture with the involvement of the posterior malleolus"'' were retrospectively identified. CT images were assessed by 10 observers with different levels of clinical experience from 2 different specialties, including orthopedics and radiology. The observers were asked to classify PMFs according to 3 CT-based classifications on 2 separate occasions with a 4-week interval. Cohen's κ values were measured for 2 raters and Fleiss' κ values were measured for 3 raters and more. Overall, each classification had moderate to very good intraobserver reliability (κ=0.41 to 0.95, P < .01) as well as moderate interobserver reliability for each of the 2 separate assessments (κ=0.41 to 0.60, P < .01 for the first occasion; κ=0.44 to 0.59, P < .01 for the second occasion). Interobserver agreement among the foot and ankle surgeons regarding the Haraguchi and Bartoníček classifications was substantial for both assessment periods, whereas there was a moderate agreement for the Mason classification. Orthopedic residents showed moderate interobserver agreement in each period for both Bartoníček and Mason classifications. Radiology experts illustrated slight and fair agreements in the 2 assessments for Mason classification, moderate agreement in both assessments for Haraguchi classification, and substantial to moderate agreement in the first and second assessments for Bartoníček classification, respectively. Computed tomography-based classification system for PMFs demonstrated moderate interobserver reliability as well as moderate to very good intraobserver reliability. Moreover, foot and ankle specialists exhibit enhanced K values for both inter and intraobserver reliability for each classification system, consistency seems to increase as the interest in the field condenses.

Analysis of the reliability of KEOPS version 2 for the measurement of coronal and sagittal parameters in spinal deformity.

The purpose of the study is to evaluate the updated version of this software in patients with various spinal deformity. Sixty patients were included in this study and were divided into three categories: 20 patients with AIS, 20 patients with ASD, and 20 patients having undergone corrective surgery for spinal deformity. The measurements were performed by two senior and two junior orthopedic surgery residents, and were done at two points in time separated by a 3-week interval with the cases being randomized every time to reduce the risk of memory bias. Measured parameters included coronal, sagittal, global alignment parameters, andpelvic parameters. When assessing the inter- and intra-observer reliability across all the groups of patients, none of the coefficients was smaller than 0.8 with a very high level of agreement. The standard error ranged from 0.7° to 1.5° demonstrating a high level of accuracy. Fairly similar results were seen when the groups were divided into the three categories except for the post-operative groups where a strong and not perfect level of agreement was reported. This is the first study to assess the reproducibility of the new version of KEOPS, showing a very high agreement in all measurements. In the post-operative group, although it showed a strong agreement, the lower performance can be explained by the presence of surgical material making it harder to identify the anatomical landmarks accurately. Nevertheless, we can recommend the usage of this software in a clinical setting.

Intracapsular neck of femur fractures secondary to civilian gunshot injuries: an inter- and intra-observer agreement study on classification and treatment using the AO/OTA classification

PurposeNumerous classification systems have been developed for neck of femur fractures, but none have been tested for reliability in gunshot injuries. Our primary objective was to assess the inter-observer and intra-observer reliability of the AO/OTA classification system when applied to intracapsular neck of femur fractures secondary to low-velocity civilian gunshots wounds (GSWs). Our secondary objective was to test the reliability of the AO/OTA classification system in guiding surgeon treatment choices for these fractures.Patients and methodsEighteen reviewers (six orthopaedic traumatologists, six general orthopaedic surgeons and six junior orthopaedic fellows) were given a set of 25 plain radiographs and CT scans of femur neck fractures secondary to GSW. For each clinical case, all reviewers selected a classification as well as treatment option from a list of given options. Inter-observer reliability was measured at the initial classification. The exercise was repeated 10–12 weeks later by the same 18 reviewers to test intra-observer reliability.ResultsThe Fleiss kappa values indicate only slight agreement amongst raters, across all experience levels, for both injury classification and treatment. Intra-observer agreement was fair across all experience levels for both injury classification and treatment.ConclusionThe AO/OTA classification showed only slight reliability in classification of gunshot fractures of the femur neck. With only fair reliability, it also failed to guide surgical treatment thus rendering its routine use in daily clinical practice of questionable value.

Reliability of glenoid measurements performed using Multiplanar Reconstruction (MPR) of Magnetic Resonance (MRI) in patients with shoulder instability

PurposeMeasurement of glenoid bone loss in the shoulder instability can be assessed by CT or MRI multiplanar imaging and is crucial for pre-operative planning. The aim of this study is to determine the intra and interobserver reliability of glenoid deficiency measurement using MRI multiplanar reconstruction with 2D assessment in the sagittal plane (MPR MRI).MethodsWe reviewed MRI images of 80 patients with anterior shoulder instability with Osirix software using MPR. Six observers with basic experience measured the glenoid, erosion edge length, and bone loss twice, with at least one-week interval between measurements. We calculated reliability and repeatability using the intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) and minimal detectable change with 95% confidence (MDC95%).ResultsIntra and Inter-observer ICC and MDC95% for glenoid width and height were excellent (ICC 0,89-0,96). For erosion edge length and area of the glenoid were acceptable/good (ICC 0,61-0,89). Bone loss and Pico Index were associated with acceptable/good ICC (0,63 -0,86)) but poor MDC95% (45 - 84 %). Intra-observer reliability improved with time, while inter-observer remained unchanged.ConclusionThe MPR MRI measurement of the anterior glenoid lesion is very good tool for linear parameters. This method is not valid for Pico index measurement, as the area of bone loss is variable. The pace of learning is individual, therefore complex calculations based on MPR MRI are not resistant to low experience as opposed to true 3D CT

Endoscopic scoring indices for assessing disease severity in familial adenomatous polyposis: Systematic review.

Background and study aims There is limited consensus on the optimal method for measuring disease severity in familial adenomatous polyposis (FAP). We aimed to systematically review the operating properties of existing endoscopic severity indices for FAP. Methods We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library from inception to February 2023 to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) that utilized endoscopic outcomes or studies that evaluated the operating properties of endoscopic disease severity indices in FAP. Results A total of 134 studies were included. We evaluated scoring indices and component items of scoring indices, such as polyp count, polyp size, and histology. Partial validation was observed for polyp count and size. The most commonly reported scoring index was the Spigelman classification system, which was used for assessing the severity of duodenal involvement. A single study reported almost perfect interobserver and intra-observer agreement for this system. The InSIGHT polyposis staging system, which was used for assessing colorectal polyp burden, has been partially validated. It showed substantial interobserver reliability; however, the intra-observer reliability was not assessed. Novel criteria for high-risk gastric polyps have been developed and assessed for interobserver reliability. However, these criteria showed a poor level of agreement. Other scoring indices assessing the anal transition zone, duodenal, and colorectal polyps have not undergone validation. Conclusions There are no fully validated endoscopic disease severity indices for FAP. Development and validation of a reliable and responsive endoscopic disease severity instrument will be informative for clinical care and RCTs of pharmacological therapies for FAP.

Variability Between Full-Length Lateral Radiographs and Standard Short Knee Radiographs When Evaluating Posterior Tibial Slope in Revision ACL Patients.

Increased posterior tibial slope (PTS) has been identified as a risk factor for failure after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Correction of PTS may improve outcomes after revision ACL reconstruction. There are conflicting reports demonstrating the measurement of the PTS on standard short knee (SSK) radiographs versus full-length lateral (FLL) radiographs including the entire tibia. To compare PTS measurements between SSK and FLL radiographs in patients who failed primary ACL reconstruction. It was hypothesized that there would be high variability between the SSK and FLL radiographic measurements. Cohort study (diagnosis); Level of evidence, 2. The medial and lateral PTS were measured on the SSK and FLL radiographs of 33 patients with failed primary ACL reconstructions. All measurements were performed by 2 trained independent observers (A.A.M., J.S.), and inter- and intraobserver reliability were calculated using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). Measurements recorded by the observer with the higher intraobserver ICC were used for comparison of the PTS on SSK versus FLL radiographs. Both the inter- and the intraobserver reliability values of the PTS measurements were excellent. There was a significant difference in mean PTS on the medial plateau as measured on the SSK and FLL radiographs (11.2°± 5.3° vs 12.5°± 4.6°; P = .03), with the FLL radiographs demonstrating higher PTS. There was also a significant difference in the mean PTS on the lateral plateau as measured on SSK versus FLL radiographs (10.7°± 4.3° vs 12.2°± 4°, respectively; P = .01), with the FLL radiographs demonstrating higher PTS. Notably, 66.67% of the absolute measurements for PTS on the medial plateau differed by ≥2°, with variability as high as 8.5°. Results indicated that FLL and SSK radiographs are not interchangeable measurements for PTS associated with failed ACL reconstruction. Because FLL radiographs demonstrate less variability than SSK radiographs, we recommend obtaining them to evaluate these complex patients.

Medial scapular body (MSB) Goutallier classification: MRI-based reliability and validity of evaluation of the Goutallier classification for grading fatty infiltration of the rotator cuff

IntroductionThe degree of atrophy and fatty infiltration of rotator cuff muscle belly is a key predictor for cuff repairability. Traditionally, Goutallier grading of fatty infiltration is assessed at sagittal scapular Y-view. Massive rotator cuff tears are associated with tendon retraction and medial retraction of cuff musculature, resulting in medialization of the muscle bulk. Thus, standard Y-view can misrepresent the region of interest and may misguide clinicians when assessing repairability. It is hypothesized that by assessing the muscle belly with multiple medial sagittal MRI sections at medial scapular body, the Medial Scapular Body - Goutallier Classification (MSB-GC) will improve reliability and repeatability giving a more representative approximation to the degree of fatty infiltration, as compared with original Y-view. MethodsFatty infiltration of the rotator cuff muscles were classified based on the Goutallier grade (0 to 4) at three defined sections section 1: original Y-view; section 2: level of suprascapular notch; section 3: three cm medial to suprascapular notch on MRI scans. Six sub-specialist fellowship trained shoulder surgeons, and three musculoskeletal radiologists independently evaluated deidentified MRI scans of included patients. ResultsOut of 80 scans, 78% (n=62) were massive cuff tears involving supraspinatus, infraspinatus and subscapularis tendon. Inter-observer reliability (consistency between observers) for Goutallier grade was excellent for all three predefined sections (range:0.87–0.95). Intra-observer reliability (repeatability) for Goutallier grade was excellent for all three sections and four rotator cuff muscles (range:0.83-0.97). There was a moderate to strong positive correlation of Goutallier grades between sections 1 and 3 and between sections 2 and 3 and these were statistically significant (p<0.001). There was a reduction in the severity of fatty infiltration on the Goutallier classification from sections 1 to 3 across all muscles. 42.5% of both supraspinatus and infraspinatus were downgraded by one, 20% of supraspinatus and 3.8% of infraspinatus were downgraded by 2 and 2.5% of supraspinatus were downgraded by 3. ConclusionThis study found that applying the Goutallier classification to more medial MRI sections (MSB-GC) resulted in assignment of lower grades for all rotator cuff muscles. Additionally, this method demonstrated excellent test-retest reliability and repeatability. Inclusion of a more medial view or whole scapula on MRI, especially in advanced levels of tear retraction, could be more reliable and representative for assessment of the degree of fatty infiltration within the muscle bulk that could help predict tear repairability and therefore improve clinical decision-making which should be studied further in clinical studies.