We evaluated the effect of light intensity and substratum complexity on habitat preference and displacement speed of the ophiuroid Ophiopholis aculeata. The ophiuroid strongly preferred reduced light and to a lesser extent complex substrata. Further, displacement speed increased with light intensity and decreased with substratum complexity (ophiuroids were virtually immobile on darkened complex substrata). In the field, the density of exposed ophiuroids, with the disk out of a crevice, was always low, irrespective of the intensity of solar radiation. However, the extent to which they extended their arms (to feed) was inversely related to light intensity, as the number of suspension-feeding arms was low under direct sunlight, intermediate under indirect light and high at night. Field observations showed that the response to light was not modified when UV radiation was eliminated with a filter, and a laboratory experiment showed that white light intensity alone produced patterns similar to those observed in the field. O. aculeata may reduce arm extension with increasing light intensity to reduce the threat of visual predators, whose foraging efficiency increases with light intensity. However, visual predators are rare in our study site. We hypothesize that the large-scale larval dispersion of O. aculeata (due to the long pelagic phase) prevents ophiuroids from adapting to local conditions so that its response to light reflects adaptation to visual predators in other locations.