Recent theoretical advances in food web ecology emphasize the importance of body size disparities among species for the structure, stability and functions of ecosystems. Experimental confirmations of the functional importance of large species, independent of their trophic position, are scarce. We specifically examine the multiple ecological roles of large invertebrates from two distinct trophic levels in headwater streams. We experimentally manipulated the presence of large predatory invertebrates (two Perlid stoneflies) or detritivores (a limnephilid caddisfly and aPteronarcysstonefly) in a two‐by‐two design in stream channels open to immigration/emigration of smaller biota. We assessed treatment effects on the trophic structure of the benthic invertebrate community, dynamics of basal resources (benthic algae and leaf litter of cedar and alder), and stability of litter decomposition rates against an experimental pulse perturbation (fine sediment input). The presence of the large invertebrates was associated with a ten‐fold decrease in the biomass of invertebrate filterers whereas other trophic groups were unaffected by the large species. The biomass of benthic algae was lower and the rate of mass loss of alder litter was higher in channels lacking the large predators, thus revealing trophic cascades operating along both algal‐based and detritus‐based food chains. The large predators had no detectable effect on the decomposition of cedar whereas both cedar and alder disappeared faster in the presence of the large detritivores. Furthermore, the large predators and large detritivores interactively influenced the decomposition of the cedar–alder mixture through a litter diversity effect and the variability of the rate of alder decomposition after a pulse of fine sediment. Because the large invertebrates affected multiple ecosystem properties, and as their absence was not rapidly compensated for by small immigrant species, our findings support the notion that large species could be critically important in controlling ecosystem structure and functioning.
Read full abstract