PurposeTo determine if laterally selective graded vertical rectus tenotomy (GVRT) of the inferior rectus (IR) can correct the lateral incomitance of hypertropia (HT) commonly encountered in sagging eye syndrome (SES), comparing it with inferior oblique (IO) recession. DesignRetrospective comparative interventional clinical study. MethodsWe reviewed 73 consecutive patients undergoing GVRT of the IR for correction of horizontally incomitant HT due to SES from July 2012 to October 2023. Confounding diagnoses were excluded. Using topical anesthesia, GVRT was initiated from the nasal versus temporal side corresponding to greater HT, with dosing adjusted intraoperatively until cover testing in central gaze indicated orthotropia. We compared 8 cases of IO recession to 4mm posterior and 3mm lateral to the IR insertion. ResultsNasal GVRT was performed in 41 patients (standard deviation), and temporal GVRT on 32 patients. Mean nasal GVRT was 69±15% and mean temporal GVRT was 62±17%. Mean HT in central gaze was reduced by nasal GVRT from 3.9±1.7Δ to 0.3±1.4Δ, and from 4.0±1.6Δ to 0.2±1.1Δ by temporal GVRT. Nasal GVRT corresponding to the side of the tenotomy had greater effect in contralateral gaze at 3.2±2.2Δ than ipsilateral gaze at 2.1±2.0Δ (p=0.0250), whereas temporal GVRT had greater effect in ipsilateral gaze at 4.9±2.7D than contralateral gaze at 2.9±2.9D (p=0.0002). Inferior oblique recession in 8 patients reduced lateral incomitance from 13±5.0Δ to 0.5±1.4Δ (p<0.0001). ConclusionNasal GVRT corrects about 1Δ and temporal GVRT 2Δ horizontal incomitance of HT, while IO recession corrects about 12.5Δ. Selection of GVRT laterality improves outcomes without additional risk or operating time.
Read full abstract