Induction Of Allograft Tolerance Research Articles

Chimerism-based tolerance in organ transplantation: preclinical and clinical studies.

Induction of allograft tolerance has been considered the ultimate goal in organ transplantation. Although numerous protocols to induce allograft tolerance have been reported in mice, a chimerism-based approach through donor haematopoietic stem cell transplantation has been the only approach to date that induced allograft tolerance reproducibly following kidney transplantation in man. Renal allograft tolerance has been achieved by induction of either transient mixed chimerism or persistent full donor chimerism. Although the risk of rejection may be low in tolerance achieved via durable full donor chimerism, the development of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) has limited the wider clinical application of this approach. In contrast, tolerance induced by transient mixed chimerism has not been associated with GVHD, but the risk of allograft rejection is more difficult to predict after the disappearance of haematopoietic chimerism. Current efforts are directed towards the development of more clinically feasible and reliable approaches to induce more durable mixed chimerism in order to widen the clinical applicability of these treatment regimens.

Transplantation tolerance: don't forget about the B cells.

Establishing a state of transplantation tolerance that leads to indefinite graft survival without the need for lifelong immunosuppression has been achieved successfully in limited numbers of transplant recipients in the clinic. These successes led to studies aimed at identifying potential biomarkers that diagnose allograft tolerance and identify the patients most amenable to drug minimization, and implicated an enriched B cell signature of tolerance. The emergence of a specialized subset of regulatory B cell (Bregs ), that possess immune-modulatory function in inflammation and autoimmune disease, raised the possibility that Bregs play critical roles in the promotion of transplantation tolerance and that Bregs are the underlying explanation for the B cell signature of tolerance. However, B cells are best known to play a key role in humoral immunity, and excessive production of donor specific antibodies has clear deleterious effects in transplantation. Thus, for tolerance to be persistent, alloantibody responses must also be curtailed, either through the suppression of T cell help or the induction of B cell-intrinsic dysfunction. Recent findings indicate a unique subset of follicular regulatory T cells (Tfr) that can suppress B cell function and induce epigenetic modifications that result in sustained defects in B cell differentiation and function. In this review, we summarize studies in animals and humans that suggest roles for Bregs and dysfunctional B cells in transplantation tolerance, and discuss how these insights may provide a roadmap for new approaches to diagnose, and new therapies to induce allograft tolerance.

Disruption of Transplant Tolerance by an "Incognito" Form of CD8 T Cell-Dependent Memory.

Several approaches successfully achieve allograft tolerance in preclinical models but are challenging to translate into clinical practice. Many clinically relevant factors can attenuate allograft tolerance induction, including intrinsic genetic resistance, peritransplant infection, inflammation, and preexisting antidonor immunity. The prevailing view for immune memory as a tolerance barrier is that the host harbors memory cells that spontaneously cross-react to donor MHC antigens. Such preexisting "heterologous" memory cells have direct reactivity to donor cells and resist most tolerance regimens. In this study, we developed a model system to determine if an alternative form of immune memory could also block tolerance. We posited that host memory T cells could potentially respond to donor-derived non-MHC antigens, such as latent viral antigens or autoantigens, to which the host is immune. Results show that immunity to a model nonself antigen, ovalbumin (OVA), can dramatically disrupt tolerance despite undetectable initial reactivity to donor MHC antigens. Importantly, this blockade of tolerance was CD8+ T cell-dependent and required linked antigen presentation of alloantigens with the test OVA antigen. As such, this pathway represents an unapparent, or "incognito," form of immunity that is sufficient to prevent tolerance and that can be an unforeseen additional immune barrier to clinical transplant tolerance.

Preclinical and clinical studies for renal allograft tolerance induction via the mixed chimerism approach

Preclinical and clinical studies for renal allograft tolerance induction via the mixed chimerism approach

A TLR9 agonist promotes IL-22-dependent pancreatic islet allograft survival in type 1 diabetic mice.

Pancreatic islet transplantation is a promising potential cure for type 1 diabetes (T1D). Islet allografts can survive long term in the liver parenchyma. Here we show that liver NK1.1+ cells induce allograft tolerance in a T1D mouse model. The tolerogenic effects of NK1.1+ cells are mediated through IL-22 production, which enhances allograft survival and increases insulin secretion. Increased expression of NKG2A by liver NK1.1+ cells in islet allograft-transplanted mice is involved in the production of IL-22 and in the reduced inflammatory response to allografts. Vaccination of T1D mice with a CpG oligonucleotide TLR9 agonist (ODN 1585) enhances expansion of IL-22-producing CD3-NK1.1+ cells in the liver and prolongs allograft survival. Our study identifies a role for liver NK1.1+ cells, IL-22 and CpG oligonucleotides in the induction of tolerance to islet allografts in the liver parenchyma.

Immunosuppressive Properties of Mesenchymal Stem Cells

The properties of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have become better known over the past decade and show potentially attractive new capabilities in solid-organ transplantation. After systemic administration, MSCs migrate to the damaged tissues, engraft, and then display potent anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory properties through cell-to-cell interactions and secretion of soluble factors. They are weakly immunogenic and influence the differentiation and function of both innate and adaptive immune cells, thus promoting a tolerogenic response. Moreover, the results of the preclinical studies and the initial clinical trials support the evidence that MSCs can, at least partially, induce allograft tolerance. This review describes the immunosuppressive properties of MSCs on cells involved in alloimmune response and the current understanding of their underlying mechanisms, which is a prerequisite for an optimal clinical use.

Induction of Major Histocompatibility Complex-mismatched Mouse Lung Allograft Acceptance With Combined Donor Bone Marrow: Lung Transplant Using a 12-Hour Nonmyeloablative Conditioning Regimen.

Despite broad and intense conventional immunosuppression, long-term survival after lung transplantation lags behind that for other solid organ transplants, primarily because of allograft rejection. Therefore, new strategies to promote lung allograft acceptance are urgently needed. The purpose of the present study was to induce allograft tolerance with a protocol compatible with deceased donor organ utilization. Using the major histocompatibility complex-mismatched mouse orthotopic lung transplant model, we investigated a conditioning regimen consisting of pretransplant T cell depletion, low-dose total body irradiation and posttransplant (donor) bone marrow, and splenocyte infusion followed by posttransplantation cyclophosphamide. Our results show that C57BL/6 recipients of BALB/c lung allografts undergoing this complete short-duration nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen had durable lung allograft acceptance. Mice that lacked 1 or more components of this regimen exhibited significant graft loss. Mechanistically, animals with lung allograft acceptance had established higher levels of donor chimerism, lymphocyte responses which were attenuated to donor antigens but maintained to third-party antigens, and clonal deletion of donor-reactive host Vβ T cells. Frequencies of Foxp3 T regulatory cells were comparable in both surviving and rejected allografts implying that their perturbation was not a dominant cell-regulatory mechanism. Donor chimerism was indispensable for sustained tolerance, as evidenced by acute rejection of allografts in established chimeric recipients of posttransplantation cyclophosphamide after a chimerism-ablating secondary recipient lymphocyte infusion. Together, these data provide proof-of-concept for establishing lung allograft tolerance with tandem donor bone marrow transplantation using a short-duration nonmyeloablative conditioning regimen and posttransplant cyclophosphamide.

B10 cells play a role in the immune modulation of pro- and anti-inflammatory immune responses in mouse islet allograft rejection

Recently, pancreatic islet transplantation has been shown to be a viable option for the treatment of type 1 diabetes mellitus. However, immune destruction becomes the major impediment to the clinical application of islet transplantation. Here, we evaluated changes affecting multiple types of immune cells and cytokines in allogeneic islet transplantation immunity after the administration of B10 cells alone and explored the regulatory mechanisms of B10 cells in T cell-mediated allograft rejection. In vitro assays, B10 cells significantly decreased the proliferative capacity of CD4+CD25− T cells (13.75%±0.96% vs. 32.76%±0.81%) while enhancing the proliferation of regulatory T cells (Tregs) (26.60%±1.14% vs. 21.52%±0.81%). Furthermore, after the administration of B10 cells in vivo, the frequencies of IL-10+ B cells and Tregs of islet transplant recipients were increased by the CD19+CD5+CD1dhi B cells, and the CD4+/CD8+ and IFN-γ+/IL-17+ ratios were decreased. Serum IL-10 levels were up-regulated, while IFN-γ levels were down-regulated. Grafts from 1 to 5×106 B10 cell-treated recipients exhibited a reduced level of insulitis compared with the untreated controls, although the differences of graft survival times were not statistically significant. In general, in mouse islet allograft rejection, B10 cells may alleviate T cell-mediated immune responses by promoting Treg-cell development and inhibiting Th1 cells activation, via an IL-10-dependent pathway. Development of B10 cell-targeted therapy may be benefit for modulating immune response and provide insight into the signals involved the induction of islet allograft tolerance.

Induced regulatory T cells in allograft tolerance via transient mixed chimerism.

Successful induction of allograft tolerance has been achieved in nonhuman primates (NHPs) and humans via induction of transient hematopoietic chimerism. Since allograft tolerance was achieved in these recipients without durable chimerism, peripheral mechanisms are postulated to play a major role. Here, we report our studies of T cell immunity in NHP recipients that achieved long-term tolerance versus those that rejected the allograft (AR). All kidney, heart, and lung transplant recipients underwent simultaneous or delayed donor bone marrow transplantation (DBMT) following conditioning with a nonmyeloablative regimen. After DBMT, mixed lymphocyte culture with CFSE consistently revealed donor-specific loss of CD8+ T cell responses in tolerant (TOL) recipients, while marked CD4+ T cell proliferation in response to donor antigens was found to persist. Interestingly, a significant proportion of the proliferated CD4+ cells were FOXP3+ in TOL recipients, but not in AR or naive NHPs. In TOL recipients, CD4+FOXP3+ cell proliferation against donor antigens was greater than that observed against third-party antigens. Finally, the expanded Tregs appeared to be induced Tregs (iTregs) that were converted from non-Tregs. These data provide support for the hypothesis that specific induction of iTregs by donor antigens is key to long-term allograft tolerance induced by transient mixed chimerism.

A new method for skin grafting in murine model.

Skin transplantation provides an excellent potential model to investigate the immunology of allograft rejection and tolerance induction. Despite the theoretical ease of performing skin transplantation, as well as the potential of directly observing the reaction to the transplanted tissue, the poor reliability of skin transplantation in the mouse has largely precluded the use of this model. Furthermore, there is controversy regarding the most appropriate skin graft donor site due to poor success of back skin transplantation, as compared with the thinner ear or tail skin. This study demonstrates a reliable method to successfully perform skin grafts in a mouse model, as well as the clinical and histologic outcome of syngeneic grafts. A total of 287 grafts were performed (in 126 mice) utilizing donor skin from the ear, tail or back. No graft failure or postoperative mortality was observed. Comparison of this technique with two previously established protocols of skin transplantation (5.0 absorbable Suture + tissue glue technique and no-suture technique) demonstrates the significant improvement in the engraftment success of the new technique. In summary, a new technique for murine skin grafting demonstrates improved reliability across donor site locations and strains, increasing the potential for investigating interventions to alter the rejection process.

Donor CD47 controls T cell alloresponses and is required for tolerance induction following hepatocyte allotransplantation.

CD47-deficient hepatocyte transplantation induces rapid innate immune cell activation and subsequent associated graft loss in syngeneic recipients. However, the role of donor CD47 in regulation of T-cell alloresponses is poorly understood. We addressed this question by assessing OVA-specific immune responses in mice following hepatocyte transplantation from CD47-competent or -deficient OVA-transgenic donors. Compared to sham-operated controls, intrasplenic transplantation of CD47-deficient OVA+ hepatocytes significantly accelerated rejection of OVA+ skin grafted 7 days after hepatocyte transplantation. In contrast, mice receiving CD47-competent OVA+ hepatocytes showed prolonged and even indefinite survival of OVA+ skin allografts. T cells from mice receiving CD47-deficient, but not CD47-competent, OVA+ hepatocytes showed significantly enhanced responses to OVA+ stimulators compared to sham-operated controls. In contrast to the production of tolerogenic cytokines (IL-4 and IL-10) in the recipients of CD47-competent hepatocytes, mice receiving CD47-deficient hepatocytes showed elevated production of IFN-γ and IL-1α. Moreover, significant expansion of myeloid-derived suppressor cells was detected in the recipients of CD47-competent hepatocytes, which was required for tolerance induction in these mice. Thus, donor CD47 plays an important role in the control of T-cell alloresponses and tolerance induction following hepatocyte transplantation. Our data also suggest that intrasplenic hepatocyte transplantation may provide a means to induce allograft tolerance.

Liver microRNA Profile of Induced Allograft Tolerance.

Although the liver is less immunogenic than other solid organs, most liver transplant recipients receive lifelong immunosuppression. In both experimental models and clinical transplantation, total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) has been shown to induce allograft tolerance. Our goal was to identify the microRNAs (miRNAs) expressed in tolerant liver allograft recipients in an experimental model of TLI-induced tolerance. To identify the miRNAs associated with TLI-induced tolerance, we examined syngeneic recipients (Lewis→Lewis) and allogeneic recipients (Dark Agouti→Lewis) of orthotropic liver transplants that received posttransplant TLI, allogeneic recipients that were not treated posttransplantation and experienced acute rejection, and native Dark Agouti livers. Quantitative-polymerase chain reaction miRNA array cards were used to profile liver grafts. We identified 12 miRNAs that were specifically and significantly increased during acute rejection. In early tolerance, 33 miRNAs were altered compared with syngeneic livers, with 80% of the miRNAs increased. In established tolerance, 42 miRNAs were altered. In addition, miR-142-5p and miR-181a demonstrated increased expression in tolerant livers (both early and established tolerance) as compared with syngeneic livers. A principal component analysis of all miRNAs assayed demonstrated a profile in established tolerance that was closely related to that seen in syngeneic livers. The miRNA profile of established tolerant allografts is very similar to syngeneic grafts, suggesting tolerance may be a return to an immunological state of quiescence.

Different Effects of Tacrolimus on Innate and Adaptive Immune Cells in the Allograft Transplantation.

While tacrolimus (FK506) is currently used as immunosuppression therapy in transplant recipient, the immunological mechanism remains unknown. Herein, the immunoregulatory effects of FK506 were investigated in the physiological status and allogeneic skin transplantation. FK506 cannot significantly alter the functions of innate immune cells (macrophages and neutrophils) and adaptive immune cells (T cells) in the physiological status. However, it can effectively delay allogeneic skin-graft rejection through ameliorating the T cell responses, but not myeloid-derived innate immune cell responses. Importantly, it did not affect the allograft recipient macrophage innate immune defence capacity to bacteria. In clinics, FK506 treatment can significantly control the cytokine production in T cells, but not non-T cells. This study shows targeting calcineurin signalling, FK506, to be essential in inducing allograft tolerance, but not to damage the innate defence capacity, validating the immune cell phenotypes as a potential marker in transplantation following FK506 treatment.

Editorial: Memory T Cells: Effectors, Regulators, and Implications for Transplant Tolerance.

Editorial: Memory T Cells: Effectors, Regulators, and Implications for Transplant Tolerance.

Fingerprints of transplant tolerance suggest opportunities for immunosuppression minimization

HLA incompatible organ transplant tolerance is the holy grail of transplantation. Stable engraftment of an HLA mismatched allograft and life-long tolerance induction, though feasible in highly selected cohorts with depletional protocols, is not ready for generalized application to the entire transplant recipient pool. It has thus been important to harness biomarkers that can uncover mechanisms and tools for monitoring HLA mismatched recipients that develop a state of operational tolerance, during accidental immunosuppression withdrawal secondary to problems of over-immunosuppression (infection or malignancy) or toxicity (mostly cosmetic or cardiovascular). A restricted and unpredictable group of patients can demonstrate a clinical state of operational tolerance, manifested by state of stable graft function of a graft with HLA mismatches between recipient and donor, intact immune responses to third party antigens and no measurable immunosuppression. These patients have served as the basis for the discovery of clinically correlative biomarkers, in distal biofluids (mainly blood), that can define the existing state of operational clinical tolerance. Operationally tolerant patients are rare, as withdrawal of immunosuppression most often results in rejection and graft loss. Nevertheless, operationally tolerant kidney, liver and heart allograft recipients have been reported. The presence of similar biomarker signature profiles in HLA mismatched transplant recipients on immunosuppression, suggests the feasibility of utilizing these biomarkers for educated immunosuppression minimization with a view to retaining immunological quiescence, while reducing the maintenance immunosuppression burden to a “safe” alloimmune threshold. Though clinical operational tolerance is rare, as immunosuppression cessation most often results in increased alloimmunity and rejection, the biomarker profile studies that have harnessed whole genome profiling suggest that the frequency of this state may be ~8% in kidney allograft recipients, and even more frequent in pediatric recipients and in liver transplantation: 25% in adult liver allograft recipients and ~60% in pediatric liver allograft recipients. In this review we discuss putative molecular mechanisms, cellular players and correlative biomarkers that have been developed through clinically associative studies of tolerant and non-tolerant patients. Through mechanisms of carefully constructed and monitored randomized, prospective clinical trials, the transplant community stands at the cusp of improved quality of recipient life through educated immunosuppression minimization.

Alloreactive Regulatory T Cells Allow the Generation of Mixed Chimerism and Transplant Tolerance.

The induction of donor-specific transplant tolerance is one of the main goals of modern immunology. Establishment of a mixed chimerism state in the transplant recipient has proven to be a suitable strategy for the induction of long-term allograft tolerance; however, current experimental recipient preconditioning protocols have many side effects, and are not feasible for use in future therapies. In order to improve the current mixed chimerism induction protocols, we developed a non-myeloablative bone-marrow transplant (NM-BMT) protocol using retinoic acid (RA)-induced alloantigen-specific Tregs, clinically available immunosuppressive drugs, and lower doses of irradiation. We demonstrate that RA-induced alloantigen-specific Tregs in addition to a NM-BMT protocol generates stable mixed chimerism and induces tolerance to allogeneic secondary skin allografts in mice. Therefore, the establishment of mixed chimerism through the use of donor-specific Tregs rather than non-specific immunosuppression could have a potential use in organ transplantation.

Targeting CD8 T-Cell Metabolism in Transplantation.

Infiltration of effector CD8 T cells plays a major role in allograft rejection, and increases in memory and terminally differentiated effector memory CD8 T cells are associated with long-term allograft dysfunction. Alternatively, CD8 regulatory T cells suppress the inflammatory responses of effector lymphocytes and induce allograft tolerance in animal models. Recently, there has been a renewed interest in the field of immunometabolics and its important role in CD8 function and differentiation. The purpose of this review is to highlight the key metabolic pathways involved in CD8 T cells and to discuss how manipulating these metabolic pathways could lead to new immunosuppressive strategies for the transplantation field.

CD8(low)CD28(-) T Cells: A Human CD8 T-Suppressor Subpopulation With Alloantigen Specificity Induced by Soluble HLA-A2 Dimer In Vitro.

CD8(+) suppressor T cells have been demonstrated to provide protection of allografts from rejection. We previously reported that soluble peptide/HLA-A2 dimer shows peptide-specific inhibitory effects on alloresponse in a coculture of peptide-pulsed T2 cells with HLA-A2 negative lymphocytes in vitro. Here we found a subset of CD8(low)CD28(-) T cells that was induced in the dimer-treated coculture. Importantly, this population showed hyporesponsiveness to the alloantigen restimulation as well as alloantigen-specific suppression on alloreactive T cells in a cell-cell contact-dependent fashion. The suppressive mechanisms of CD8(low)CD28(-) T cells involved an elevated expression of membrane-bound TGF-β1, but not Foxp3, CTLA-4, or IL-10. Furthermore, an overrepresention of CD8(low)CD28(-) T cells was observed in the patients after allogeneic platelet transfusion and positively correlated with the elevated concentrations of plasma HLA class I antigens. Our findings demonstrated that soluble HLA-A2 dimer could efficiently induce the tolerant CD8(low)CD28(-) T cells with alloantigen-specific suppression on alloreactive T cells. This study might provide a new strategy for preparation of donor-specific suppressor T cells and represent an attractive alternative for induction of allograft tolerance.

Indoleamine 2, 3-Dioxgenase Transfected Mesenchymal Stem Cells Induce Kidney Allograft Tolerance by Increasing the Production and Function of Regulatory T Cells.

The immunoregulatory properties of mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have been well characterized in vitro. However, the role of MSCs in organ transplantation remains unclear. The purpose of this study was to examine the role of indoleamine 2, 3-dioxgenase (IDO)-transfected MSCs in immunoregulation both in vitro and in vivo. Wild-type (WT) MSCs, empty lentivirus-transfected MSCs (Lenti-MSCs) or IDO-lentivirus-transfected MSCs (IDO-MSCs) were cocultured with peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) or CD4CD25 regulatory T (Treg) cells to examine the impact of IDO on the immunoregulatory properties of MSCs in vitro. WT-MSCs, Lenti-MSCs or IDO-MSCs (2 × 10/kg) were intravenously injected into rabbit renal transplant recipients immediately after surgery to examine the role of IDO-MSCs in tolerance induction in vivo. Lentivirus infection of MSCs resulted in stable expression of IDO. The IDO-MSCs inhibited the proliferation of CD4CD25 effector T cells to a greater extent than WT-MSCs. Coculture of PBMCs and IDO-MSCs induced a higher percentage of CD4CD25Foxp3 Treg cells in PBMCs. Additionally, the antigen-specific suppressive function of these CD4CD25 Treg cells was increased. The IDO-MSCs-treated Treg cells showed upregulated expression of cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 and increased secretion of IL-10 and TGF-β. Low doses of IDO-MSCs prolonged graft survival and induced tolerance by inducing antigen-specific CD4CD25 Treg cells, as evidenced by the finding that IDO-MSCs-treated kidney transplant recipients accepted donor-specific skin grafts but rejected third-party grafts. The IDO increased the direct immunoregulatory properties of MSCs. The IDO-MSCs enhanced the expression and function of CD4CD25 Foxp3 Treg cells and induced allograft tolerance.

Clinical trials for induction of renal allograft tolerance.

This review summarizes the current state of clinical trials for tolerance induction of human leukocyte antigen-matched or mismatched renal allografts via peritransplant infusion of donor bone marrow-derived products. Recent efforts to apply infusion of expanded regulatory T-cell preparations to minimize immunosuppressive dosages are also reviewed. Three centers in the United States have reported clinical trials for tolerance induction in recipients of living donor kidney transplants via donor hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. They have observed varying degrees of successful renal allograft tolerance induction following the establishment of either transient or persistent donor chimerism.A more recent clinical trial planned to evaluate administration of regulatory T cells to harness the immune response has recently been initiated in eight centers in Europe and the United States. Tolerance induction in clinical kidney transplantation from live donors has been achieved by donor hematopoietic stem cell transplantation. Improving the consistency and safety of tolerance induction and extending successful protocols to other organs, as well as to organs from deceased donors, are critical next steps to bringing tolerance to a wider range of clinical applications.