The Investigator Ridge, located along the prominent Investigator Fracture Zone in the Wharton Basin, northeast Indian Ocean, was chosen to investigate the temporal and geochemical evolution of the Indian upper mantle. We present new 40Ar/39Ar age, as well as major and trace element and Sr-Nd-Pb-Hf isotope data, from a large part of this so far scarcely sampled ridge. The 40Ar/39Ar ages range from 100.0 Ma to 64.1 Ma, and except for the two youngest samples (65.5 and 64.1 Ma) of likely Christmas Island Seamount Province (CHRISP) origin, display decreasing ages along the ridge from south to north. This pattern is consistent with the ages derived from paleomagnetic anomalies on the local oceanic crust that also decrease in age northwards and suggests an origin of the studied rocks at or near the now extinct Wharton spreading center. These ages also provide information about the displacements along the multiple Investigator Fracture Zones indicating large left-lateral as well as right-lateral offsets of the paleo spreading axis. The fracture zone also shows signs of recent tectonic reactivation. The Investigator Ridge samples are derived from a DUPAL-like mantle source similar to present-day Indian MORB. This source contains a depleted mantle type component, an enriched, moderately HIMU-like, component such as common “C” or “FOZO”, and an additional enriched component of recycled subcontinental lithospheric mantle material. In both the Investigator Ridge and CHRISP samples, the trace element and isotope compositions systematically change with age implying a temporal geochemical evolution of the Indian Mantle Domain in this region. It contained higher proportions of subcontinental lithospheric material delaminated during breakup of Gondwana and mixed with depleted upper mantle material in its early phase. With time, the source evolved in the direction of “C” or “FOZO”, which then became the dominant enriched component and is observed in the youngest samples.