Reviewed by: The Tennessee Williams Encyclopedia Mark Zelinsky The Tennessee Williams Encyclopedia. Edited by Philip C. Kolin. Westport: Greenwood Press, 2004; pp. xxix + 350. $89.95 cloth. This collection of some 150 entries includes four general areas of focus: individuals, places, works, and concepts that relate to Tennessee Williams's life and texts. The book fills a critical niche in scholarship and research. Its very existence attests to the growing appreciation and influence of Williams's expansive canon, which includes approximately seventy plays, two novels, dozens of short stories, five screenplays, two volumes of poetry, a collection of essays, a memoir, and thousands of letters and journal entries. While "the largest number of entries" concern Williams's works, "perhaps the heart" of the volume is devoted to concepts; these, in turn, are among the most helpful offerings in the encyclopedia (xii and xiii). Although even a casual acquaintance with Williams's dramas reveals his focus on religion, Thomas P. Adler's essay on the topic provides a thoughtful analysis of the motif. Adler astutely notes, "[f]or Williams, it might be said that hell is the self, while God is the other, and so to deny the other is to deny God" (214). Penny Farfan's article on music helps one reconsider a recurring element frequently overlooked in Williams's plays. Among the best contributions in the encyclopedia are John M. Clum on gender and sexuality and Brenda Murphy on politics. Both provide comprehensive and well-organized discussions that inspire the reader to further investigation. To my mind that is precisely what a superior encyclopedia article should do—promote additional research. Of the many entries on Williams's works, those offering new insights and fresh analysis are represented by the following: George W. Crandell's [End Page 162] piece on Cat on a Hot Tin Roof; Allean Hale's articles on Fugitive Kind, Not About Nightingales, and Stairs to the Roof; Thomas Keith's entry on A House Not Meant to Stand; Brian Parker's discussion of The Rose Tattoo; and Robert Bray's offerings on the Collected Stories, The Night of the Iguana, and Vieux Carré. Annette J. Saddik argues that I Can't Imagine Tomorrow (published 1970) "is a pivotal work in Williams's movement from realism to a minimalist, antirealistic exploration of a private world of fear, panic, alienation, and death" (97). The encyclopedia is the only source I know of that discusses Williams's journals in a unique entry by Margaret Bradham Thornton. According to Sarah Miller at Yale University Press, Williams's journals are now due to be published in fall 2006. Cathy Henderson's work on manuscript collections offers website addresses by which to access the various archives, a great help to the serious researcher (139). The entry on the playwright's poems by Nicholas R. Moschovakis serves as a valuable discussion of works too commonly ignored. Generally, the entries on people and places are less helpful; nevertheless, many offer valuable insights and tidbits of interesting facts. For example, Richard E. Kramer persuasively argues that Clifford Odets "paved the road from Eugene O'Neill to Tennessee Williams" (181). Sidney Berger offers some delightful anecdotes about Edward Albee and Williams, and Hale provides a wonderfully compact retelling of the importance of St. Louis in the playwright's life, noting that "Before [Williams] died, he confessed that the St. Louis years were 'like the irritant in the oyster shell.' They had made him a writer" (241). Despite many fine essays, The Tennessee Williams Encyclopedia suffers from serious typographical and factual errors (I counted twenty-six) and self-contradiction. The chronology that precedes the main text incorrectly states the number of performances enjoyed by Sweet Bird of Youth in its initial run, an error corrected later in John Rindo's excellent discussion of the play (xxvii and 265). A more serious factual error includes the twice-repeated claim that Elia Kazan directed the 1957 production of Orpheus Descending and the 1960 production of Period of Adjustment (88 and 108). Both errors are corrected later in entries noting that Harold Clurman directed the former and George Roy Hill the latter (183 and 191). Other mistakes: The Night of...
Read full abstract