Ductility deficiency in reinforced concrete (RC) piers is a substantial factor contributing to earthquake damage in bridge structures. In this study, the conventional concrete in the potential plastic hinge area was substituted with polypropylene fiber-reinforced engineered cementitious composite (PP-ECC), thereby leveraging its high ductility characteristics to explore the seismic performance of RC piers strengthened by PP-ECC. A finite element model was established to discuss the reinforced height, axial compression ratio, longitudinal reinforcement ratio and stirrup ratio on the hysteresis performance by referring to a published paper with a 1/5 scale test specimen. Based on the results of the parameter analysis, an ideal set of configuration parameters was proposed. Subsequently, a full-size simplified mechanical model was established with ideal reinforcement parameters. Time-history and pushover analysis were utilized to test the seismic response. The study indicates that the two analytical methods were largely consistent. The improvement in the displacement and shear force of the strengthened pier gradually decreased with the increase in acceleration amplitude. Time-history analysis reveals a decrease in the enhancement of displacement from 82.26% to 17.98% and a reduction at the bottom reaction from 12.2% to 1.5%. Under the pushover analysis method, the retrofitting level of the top displacement decreased from 77.22% to 11.53%, whereas the improvement level of the bottom shear decreased from 9.62% to 3.69%. These results provide a theoretical basis and reference standard for the application of PP-ECC.