We report the stress relaxation behavior of arc-evaporated TiC x N 1− x thin films during isothermal annealing between 350 and 900°C. Films with x= 0, 0.15, and 0.45, each having an initial compressive intrinsic stress σ int = −5.4 GPa, were deposited by varying the substrate bias V s and the gas composition. Annealing above the deposition temperature leads to a steep decrease in the magnitude of σ int to a saturation stress value, which is a function of the annealing temperature. The corresponding apparent activation energies for stress relaxation are E a =2.4 , 2.9, and 3.1 eV, for x= 0, 0.15, and 0.45, respectively. TiC 0.45N 0.55 films with a lower initial stress σ int = −3 GPa, obtained using a high substrate bias, show a higher activation energy E a =4.2 eV. In all the films, stress relaxation is accompanied by a decrease in defect density indicated by the decreased width of X-ray diffraction peaks and decreased strain contrast in transmission electron micrographs. Correlation of these results with film hardness and microstructure measurements indicates that the stress relaxation is a result of point-defect annihilation taking place both during short-lived metal-ion surface collision cascades during deposition, and during post-deposition annealing by thermally activated processes. The difference in E a for the films of the same composition deposited at different V s suggests the existence of different types of point-defect configurations and recombination mechanisms.
Read full abstract