The cathodic catalytic activity for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) plays a critical role in determining the performance of proton-conducting solid oxide fuel cells (P-SOFCs). BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.2O3-δ (BCFZ) has emerged as a promising cathode for P-SOFCs due to its triple-phase conductivity. Nevertheless, its suboptimal proton conductivity and hydration ability at intermediate temperatures prevent it from achieving the anticipated ORR catalytic activity. To address these limitations, this study explores the enhancement of electrocatalytic activity in BCFZ through alkali metal doping and A-site defect construction. The effects of such modifications on oxygen surface exchange kinetics and ORR catalytic activity are systematically investigated. The findings reveal that BCFZ exhibits relatively low parameters in terms of electronic conductivity, oxygen ion conductivity, oxygen vacancy concentration, kchem, and Dchem. Conversely, these parameters are markedly improved in A-site deficient BCFZ (D-BCFZ) and Na/K-doped BCFZ. Consequently, the enhancement of these properties yields a significant increase in ORR catalytic activity, with D-BCFZ demonstrating the best electrochemical performance. Specifically, P-SOFC with D-BCFZ cathode achieves an Rp value of just 0.073 Ω cm2 and a Pmax value of 0.928 W cm-2 at 650 °C. This study provides theoretical insight into the mechanisms by how alkali metal doping and defect construction enhance the ORR catalytic activity of BCFZ. These findings offer valuable guidance for the development and optimization of high-performance P-SOFC cathodes.