book reviews ISSN 1948-6596 Forgotten grasslands of the South Forgotten Grasslands of the South: Natural History and Conservation. Reed F. Noss, 2012, Island Press. 320 pp. $70 (Hardback), $35 (Paperback) ISBN: 9781610912259 / 9781597264891; http://islandpress.org This book is a major contribution to the argument that open grasslands and savannas, in climates that can support closed forests, are not only of considerable antiquity but are also home to rich floras and faunas of high conservation interest. Reed Noss focuses on the “forgotten” grasslands of the south-eastern USA. With foresters’ bias to trees, the long-leaf pine ecosystems of this area have generally been classified as ‘forests’. Yet it is the understorey that tells the real story—one of shade-intolerant (mostly C4) grasses and other plants and animals living in open, light-rich envi- ronments. The conundrum is that the climate is warm enough and wet enough to support forests dominated by trees that cast dense shade. The same conundrum faces the tropical ecologist con- fronting the vast areas of savannas in seasonally humid climates that also support closed forests. The classic solution, plugged for well over a cen- tury, is that the grasslands are ‘cultural artefacts’, created by felling and burning of the forests. Over the last couple of decades, this idea has been challenged by multiple lines of evidence pointing to ancient origins of grasslands and even more ancient origins of vegetation fires that help create and maintain them. Noss’s book is the best case study I have read on the mis-reading of grassy vegetation and its catastrophic consequences for conservation of these highly threatened ecosys- tems. Noss’s mission is to promote an apprecia- tion for, and understanding of, these neglected systems. Directed at naturalists, conservation bi- ologists and field biologists, much of the book is written as a personal narrative, including memo- rable outings with knowledgeable naturalists, with many descriptions of species and special sites that clearly delight the author. But Noss also writes for a more general readership with informed discus- sion of general ideas of conservation biology, sa- vanna ecology, fire and large-mammal herbivory, patterns of species richness and endemism, geol- ogy as the foundation for community organisation and more. The net effect is a superb case study, rich in detail but broad in intellectual scope, that places North American grassy ecosystems firmly in the burgeoning world literature on savannas and related grasslands. Relative to the savannas of the southern hemisphere the pine savannas of the south- eastern USA are unusual in generally lacking a dis- tinct dry season (typically > 5 months). Just why a long dry season favours savannas is not well un- derstood but a favoured hypothesis is that it pro- vides more time for fires to burn, helping promote savannas at the expense of fire-intolerant forests. In the grasslands of the south, however, the lack of a distinct dry season is offset by the very high frequency of lightning and thunder storms (with some areas receiving > 100 thunderstorms per year!). Thus even small areas of vegetation have a high probability of being hit by lightning strikes. Not all grasslands depend on fire (or large mam- malian herbivores) for their existence. Noss’s dis- cussion of edaphic savannas is the best I have seen anywhere. The origin of C4 grasses, which dominate the southern grasslands, is now thought to be ~ 30 million years ago. Yet their assembly into a major world biome only occurred some 20 million years later. The author’s description of the diverse soils and geologies where grasses persist in this forested landscape provides a detailed view of the edaphic ghettos in which savanna biotas may have developed, free from lethal shading by forest trees, millions of years before the explosive spread of the savanna biome from the Late Mio- cene. Cultural prejudices against grassy ecosys- tems as natural vegetation types have led to their neglect until recent times. Part of that neglect in- cludes the study of biodiversity. Noss’s analysis of the biotic richness of the southern grasslands was quite stunning to me. The Atlantic and Gulf Coastal Plain Floristic Province, which includes frontiers of biogeography 6.2, 2014 — © 2014 the authors; journal compilation © 2014 The International Biogeography Society
Read full abstract