Purpose; to investigate if tibial sided anterolateral ligament (ALL) injuries are associated with poor healing and residual pivot shift. Methods; Patients who underwent anterior cruciate ligament reconstructions within postinjury 6 weeks from January 2008 to March 2021 were included. They had concomitant ALL injury confirmed by preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and were followed minimum 20 months. Preoperative ALL injury was graded by the Muramatsu classification and postoperative ALL healing were graded by a modification of the Lee classification (good, partial, and non-visualized). The patients were allocated to an improved group (IG) and an unimproved group (UG) based on a comparison of pre- and postoperative MRI. ALL tear site, postoperative knee stability, Lysholm score, and Tegner activity scale (PROs) were compared between the two groups. Results; 128 patients were enrolled. 94.5 % patients achieved the minimal clinically important difference (MCID) for PROs, respectively. The ALL was torn at the femoral side in 46.9% patients, at mid-substance in 31.2.%, and at tibial side in 21.9%, Preoperatively, 86 (67.2%) patients had a partial tear and 42 (32.8%) patients had a complete tear. Based on the postoperative MRI appearances, 38 (29.7%) and 90 (70.3%) patients were allocated to the IG and UG, respectively. The tibial side tears were significantly frequent in UG (p= .032). Pivot shift showed a significantly higher incidence in UG than IG (p=.004). Lachman test and PROs did not differ between the two groups. Conclusions; Tibial-sided ALL tears occurred in 18.7% of the UG compared to 3.2% of the IG, and 45.6% of the UG had a postoperative grade 1 or 2 pivot shift, compared to 15.8% of the IG. Percentages of patients with the MCID for PROs did not differ between the two groups. However, the clinical relevance is limited by a high transfer bias.