At least two of the six methionine (Met) residues in dehaloperoxidase (DHP) are shown to act as electron donors in both autoreduction and protein-heme crosslinking. Autoreduction observed in the two isozymes, DHP-A and DHP-B, is explained by the high heme reduction potential and an endogenous source of electrons from methionine (Met) or cysteine (Cys). This study provides evidence of a connection to protein-heme crosslinking that occurs when DHP is activated by H2O2 in competition with substrate oxidation and autoreduction. The autoreduction yields of DHP-A and DHP-B are comparable and both are inversely proportional to DHP concentration. Both isoenzymes show an anti-cooperative effect on autoreduction kinetics associated with protein dimerization. Despite the presence of five tyrosine (Tyr) amino acids in DHP-A and four Tyr in DHP-B, the mass spectral evidence does not support a Tyr-heme or interprotein Tyr-Tyr crosslinking event as observed in some mammalian myoglobins. LC-MS and tandem MS/MS studies revealed three amino acids that were involved in the heme-protein crosslink, Cys73, Met63 and Met64. Cys73 facilitates dimer formation in DHP-A which also appears to slow the rate of autoreduction, but is not involved in covalent protein-heme crosslinking. Based on mutational studies, Met63 and 64 are involved in both covalent heme crosslinking and autoreduction. Proton-coupled electron transfer and crosslinking by Met to the heme may serve to regulate DHP function and protect it from uncontrolled oxidative damage.