Hard Agar Surface Research Articles

Spatial biology of Ising-like synthetic genetic networks

BackgroundUnderstanding how spatial patterns of gene expression emerge from the interaction of individual gene networks is a fundamental challenge in biology. Developing a synthetic experimental system with a common theoretical framework that captures the emergence of short- and long-range spatial correlations (and anti-correlations) from interacting gene networks could serve to uncover generic scaling properties of these ubiquitous phenomena.ResultsHere, we combine synthetic biology, statistical mechanics models, and computational simulations to study the spatial behavior of synthetic gene networks (SGNs) in Escherichia coli quasi-2D colonies growing on hard agar surfaces. Guided by the combined mechanisms of the contact process lattice simulation and two-dimensional Ising model (CPIM), we describe the spatial behavior of bi-stable and chemically coupled SGNs that self-organize into patterns of long-range correlations with power-law scaling or short-range anti-correlations. These patterns, resembling ferromagnetic and anti-ferromagnetic configurations of the Ising model near critical points, maintain their scaling properties upon changes in growth rate and cell shape.ConclusionsOur findings shed light on the spatial biology of coupled and bistable gene networks in growing cell populations. This emergent spatial behavior could provide insights into the study and engineering of self-organizing gene patterns in eukaryotic tissues and bacterial consortia.

Exploration of Social Spreading Reveals That This Behavior Is Prevalent among Pedobacter and Pseudomonas fluorescens Isolates and That There Are Variations in the Induction of the Phenotype.

Within soil, bacteria are found in multispecies communities, where interactions can lead to emergent community properties. Studying bacteria in a social context is critical for investigating community-level functions. We previously showed that cocultured Pseudomonas fluorescens Pf0-1 and Pedobacter sp. V48 engage in interspecies social spreading (ISS) on a hard agar surface, a behavior which required close contact and depended on the nutritional environment. Here, we investigate whether social spreading is widespread among P. fluorescens and Pedobacter isolates and whether the requirements for interaction vary. We find that this phenotype is not restricted to the interaction between P. fluorescens Pf0-1 and Pedobacter sp. V48 but is a prevalent behavior found in one clade in the P. fluorescens group and two clades in the Pedobacter genus. We show that the interaction with certain Pedobacter isolates occurred without close contact, indicating induction of spreading by a putative diffusible signal. As with ISS by Pf0-1+V48, the motility of interacting pairs is influenced by the environment, with no spreading behaviors (or induction of motility) observed under high nutrient conditions. While Pf0-1+V48 require low nutrient but high NaCl conditions, in the broader range of interacting pairs, the high salt influence was variable. The prevalence of motility phenotypes observed here and found within the literature indicates that community-induced locomotion in general, and social spreading in particular, is likely important within the environment. It is crucial that we continue to study microbial interactions and their emergent properties to gain a fuller understanding of the functions of microbial communities. IMPORTANCE Interspecies social spreading (ISS) is an emergent behavior observed when Pseudomonas fluorescens Pf0-1 and Pedobacter sp. V48 interact, during which both species move together across a surface. Importantly, this environment does not permit the movement of either individual species. This group behavior suggests that communities of microbes can function in ways not predictable by knowledge of the individual members. Here, we have asked whether ISS is widespread and thus potentially of importance in soil microbial communities. The significance of this research is the demonstration that surface spreading behaviors are not unique to the Pf0-1-V48 interaction but rather is a more widespread phenomenon observed among members of distinct clades of both P. fluorescens and Pedobacter isolates. Furthermore, we identify differences in mechanisms of signaling and nutritional requirements for ISS. Emergent traits resulting from bacterial interactions are widespread, and their characterization is necessary for a complete understanding of microbial community function.

The role of flagella in Pseudomonas-Pedobacter social motility across a surface

Bacteria often reside in multi-species communities where many behaviors result from interspecies relationships. In a two-species community, we show that co-culture of Pseudomonas fluorescens and Pedobacter sp. permits motility across a hard agar surface where neither species moves alone. Pseudomonas species engage in surface motility, including swimming and swarming, but these require moist environments. We are exploring the role of the Pseudomonas flagella in social motility. We deleted genes related to flagellar structure and function to study the importance of flagellar elements on the social phenotype. Using microscopy and swimming assays, we evaluate the effects of gene deletions on the presence and function of flagella in the resulting mutants, and evaluate the effect on social motility by observing the phenotype on both hard (2% w/v) and soft agar (1% w/v). Removal of the flagellar filament abolishes social motility, indicating a requirement for flagella in social motility. Removal of the flagellar motor also abolishes social motility, demonstrating that flagella must be functional. However, removal of membrane-spanning structural components, or part of the type III secretion system, results in mutants that lack flagella, but participate in a similar motile behavior with Pedobacter. Here we describe a role for flagella in motility of a two-species consortium across a hard agar surface, an environment considered non-permissive for flagellar motility. The requirement for both bacterial species indicates we are observing motility as a social phenotype, with a contribution from Pedobacter that enables the Pseudomonas flagella to function under conditions relevant in the natural soil environment.

A new locus in Cytophaga hutchinsonii involved in colony spreading on agar surfaces and individual cell gliding.

Cytophaga hutchinsonii glides rapidly over surfaces by an unknown mechanism without flagella and type IV pili and it can degrade crystalline cellulose efficiently by a novel mechanism. Tn4351 transposon mutagenesis was used to identify a new gene, CHU_1798, essential for colony spreading on agar surfaces. Further study showed that disruption of CHU_1798 caused non-spreading colonies on both soft and hard agar surfaces and individual cells were partially deficient in gliding on glass surfaces. The CHU_1798 mutant could digest cellulose as long as the cells were in direct contact with the cellulose, but it could not degrade cellulose powder buried in the agar plate. Scanning electron microscopy showed that individual mutant cells arranged irregularly on the cellulose fiber surface at an early stage of incubation, but later showed a regular parallel arrangement when there were plenty of cells and could spread along the cellulose fibers. These results suggest that CHU_1798 plays an important role in the motility of C. hutchinsonii and provide insight into the relation between cell motility and cellulose degradation.

NITRIC OXIDE-ASSOCIATED PROTEIN1 (AtNOA1) is essential for salicylic acid-induced root waving in Arabidopsis thaliana.

Root waving responses have been attributed to both environmental and genetics factors, but the potential inducers and transducers of root waving remain elusive. Thus, the identification of novel signal elements related to root waving is an intriguing field of research. Genetic, physiological, cytological, live cell imaging, and pharmacological approaches provide strong evidence for the involvement of Arabidopsis thaliana NITRIC OXIDE-ASSOCIATED PROTEIN1 (AtNOA1) in salicylic acid (SA)-induced root waving. SA specially induced root waving, with an overall decrease in root elongation in A. thaliana, and this SA-induced response was disrupted in the Atnoa1 mutant, as well as in nonexpresser of pathogenesis-related genes 1 (npr1), which is defective in SA-mediated plant defense signal transduction, but not in npr3/4 single and double mutants. The expression assays revealed that the abundance of AtNOA1 was significantly increased by application of SA. Genetic and pharmacological analyses showed that SA-induced root waving involved an AtNOA1-dependent Ca(2+) signal transduction pathway, and PIN-FORMED2 (PIN2) -based polar auxin transport possibly plays a crucial role in this process. Our work suggests that SA signaling through NPR1 and AtNOA1 is involved in the control of root waving, which provides new insights into the mechanisms that control root growth behavior on a hard agar surface.

The microtubule plus-end tracking proteins SPR1 and EB1b interact to maintain polar cell elongation and directional organ growth in Arabidopsis.

The microtubule plus-end tracking proteins (+TIPs) END BINDING1b (EB1b) and SPIRAL1 (SPR1) are required for normal cell expansion and organ growth. EB proteins are viewed as central regulators of +TIPs and cell polarity in animals; SPR1 homologs are specific to plants. To explore if EB1b and SPR1 fundamentally function together, we combined genetic, biochemical, and cell imaging approaches in Arabidopsis thaliana. We found that eb1b-2 spr1-6 double mutant roots exhibit substantially more severe polar expansion defects than either single mutant, undergoing right-looping growth and severe axial twisting instead of waving on tilted hard-agar surfaces. Protein interaction assays revealed that EB1b and SPR1 bind each other and tubulin heterodimers, which is suggestive of a microtubule loading mechanism. EB1b and SPR1 show antagonistic association with microtubules in vitro. Surprisingly, our combined analyses revealed that SPR1 can load onto microtubules and function independently of EB1 proteins, setting SPR1 apart from most studied +TIPs in animals and fungi. Moreover, we found that the severity of defects in microtubule dynamics in spr1 eb1b mutant hypocotyl cells correlated well with the severity of growth defects. These data indicate that SPR1 and EB1b have complex interactions as they load onto microtubule plus ends and direct polar cell expansion and organ growth in response to directional cues.

From organized internal traffic to collective navigation of bacterial swarms

Bacterial swarming resulting in collective navigation over surfaces provides a valuable example of cooperative colonization of new territories. The social bacterium Paenibacillus vortex exhibits successful and diverse swarming strategies. When grown on hard agar surfaces with peptone, P. vortex develops complex colonies of vortices (rotating bacterial aggregates). In contrast, during growth on Mueller–Hinton broth gelled into a soft agar surface, a new strategy of multi-level organization is revealed: the colonies are organized into a special network of swarms (or ‘snakes’ of a fraction of millimeter in width) with intricate internal traffic. More specifically, cell movement is organized in two or three lanes of bacteria traveling between the back and the front of the swarm. This special form of cellular logistics suggests new methods in which bacteria can share resources and risk while searching for food or migrating into new territories. While the vortices-based organization on hard agar surfaces has been modeled before, here, we introduce a new multi-agent bacterial swarming model devised to capture the swarms-based organization on soft surfaces. We test two putative generic mechanisms that may underlie the observed swarming logistics: (i) chemo-activated taxis in response to chemical cues and (ii) special align-and-push interactions between the bacteria and the boundary of the layer of lubricant collectively generated by the swarming bacteria. Using realistic parameters, the model captures the observed phenomena with semi-quantitative agreement in terms of the velocity as well as the dynamics of the swarm and its envelope. This agreement implies that the bacteria interactions with the swarm boundary play a crucial role in mediating the interplay between the collective movement of the swarm and the internal traffic dynamics.

A novel locus essential for spreading of Cytophaga hutchinsonii colonies on agar

Cytophaga hutchinsonii is an aerobic cellulolytic gliding bacterium. The mechanism of its cell motility over surfaces without flagella and type IV pili is not known. In this study, mariner-based transposon mutagenesis was used to identify a new locus CHU_1797 essential for colony spreading on both hard and soft agar surfaces through gliding. CHU_1797 encodes a putative outer membrane protein of 348 amino acids with unknown function, and proteins which have high sequence similarity to CHU_1797 were widespread in the members of the phylum Bacteroidetes. The disruption of CHU_1797 suppressed spreading toward glucose on an agar surface, but had no significant effect on cellulose degradation for cells already in contact with cellulose. SEM observation showed that the mutant cells also regularly arranged on the surface of cellulose fiber similar with that of the wild type strain. These results indicated that the colony spreading ability on agar surfaces was not required for cellulose degradation by C. hutchinsonii. This was the first study focused on the relationship between cell motility and cellulose degradation of C. hutchinsonii.

Atomic force microscopy: A powerful tool for studying bacterial swarming motility

Swarming motility is a fascinating phenomenon by which some bacteria use flagella to move over solid surfaces. Understanding the molecular mechanisms underlying swarming motility requires studying the factors that induce and control flagella expression in swarming cells. Traditionally, flagella are observed by optical or electron microscopy, but none of these techniques combine versatility and easiness, with quantitative and high-resolution information. We report an atomic force microscopy (AFM)-based approach for the fast imaging of bacterial phenotypes (cell shape, flagella expression) in swarming motility studies. Cells from the Gram-positive bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis sv. israelensis were inoculated on energy-rich media containing increasing agar concentrations. Following swarming assays (2 days), the cell morphology and the amount of flagella were directly observed by AFM imaging in air. Consistent with the macroscopic swarming behavior, cells harvested from the rim of colonies spreading on soft agar were hyperflagellated, elongated and arranged in chains. Increasing the agar concentration led to much lower amounts of flagella and to shorter rod-shaped cells, a finding consistent with the slower swarming motility of the cells. Cells taken from colony centers on soft and hard agar surfaces were generally non-flagellated, rod-shaped, rarely arranged in chains, and exhibited lysis and sporulation. This study shows that AFM imaging can readily discriminate between swarming and non-swarming cells, and quantify their morphological details, thus offering an important tool to study the dynamics of bacterial populations.

A QTL Study for Regions Contributing toArabidopsis thalianaRoot Skewing on Tilted Surfaces

Plant root systems must grow in a manner that is dictated by endogenous genetic pathways, yet sensitive to environmental input. This allows them to provide the plant with water and nutrients while navigating a heterogeneous soil environment filled with obstacles, toxins, and pests. Gravity and touch, which constitute important cues for roots growing in soil, have been shown to modulate root architecture by altering growth patterns. This is illustrated by Arabidopsis thaliana roots growing on tilted hard agar surfaces. Under these conditions, the roots are exposed to both gravity and touch stimulation. Consequently, they tend to skew their growth away from the vertical and wave along the surface. This complex growth behavior is believed to help roots avoid obstacles in nature. Interestingly, A. thaliana accessions display distinct growth patterns under these conditions, suggesting the possibility of using this variation as a tool to identify the molecular mechanisms that modulate root behavior in response to their mechanical environment. We have used the Cvi/Ler recombinant inbred line population to identify quantitative trait loci that contribute to root skewing on tilted hard agar surfaces. A combination of fine mapping for one of these QTL and microarray analysis of expression differences between Cvi and Ler root tips identifies a region on chromosome 2 as contributing to root skewing on tilted surfaces, potentially by modulating cell wall composition.

CML24 is Involved in Root Mechanoresponses and Cortical Microtubule Orientation in Arabidopsis

Mechanostimuli can influence plant root system architecture by causing alterations in the root tip growth direction and triggering lateral root initiation. However, how a plant root senses and translates mechanostimulation into appropriate growth and/or developmental responses remains largely unclear. The fast expression induction and transcript turnover of the Arabidopsis TCH genes by touch stimulation suggest that the TCH genes may function in mechano-related events. However, the physiological functions of the TCH genes in Arabidopsis mechanoresponses remain undetermined. Here we screened a suite of tch mutants by characterizing their root growth behaviors on hard-agar surfaces. Two calmodulin-like 24 (CML24 or TCH2) mutants, cml24-2 and cml24-4, exhibited reduced root length, biased skewing, and altered epidermal cell file rotation (CFR) phenotypes compared with wild type (Col-0). The mutant phenotypes were dependent on hard-agar surface contact and disappeared when seedlings were grown in liquid medium. Abnormal glass barrier responses of cml24 mutants further indicate touch response defects. Pharmacological tests revealed differential sensitivity of cml24 mutants to microtubule-targeted agents. Nonadditive effects of mutations in CML24 and transgenic expression of a functional microtubule label, MBD-GFP, on root skewing and CFR phenotypes suggest a potential microtubule-related role of CML24. In vivo visualization of microtubule structures with the MBD-GFP reporter revealed altered cortical microtubule orientation in the epidermal cells in cml24-4. Our observations indicate that CML24 has a role in Arabidopsis root mechanoresponses, possibly through the regulation of cortical microtubule orientation.

Territoriality in Proteus: advertisement and aggression.

“Thus, principles of evolution are dramatically exhibited by studying strains of Proteus on a solid medium, which contains a source of nutrients and oxidizable organic compounds. If the descendants of an individual are to compete successfully in this defined habitat, they must have evolved: (i) highly efficient enzyme catalysts to release and trap free energy, (ii) mobile mechanisms to access the site where more free energy is available, and (iii) mechanisms to stake out a claim on free energy—territoriality, one of the fundamental principles of ecology. Microbes did it first.” ---Ralph S. Wolfe1 Members of the bacterial species Proteus mirabilis are capable of rapid swarming over a hard agar surface. Swarming colonies display a striking phenotype in which a visible boundary forms between swarms of different strains. In contrast, boundaries do not arise between two swarms of a single strain (Figure 1). This behavior is a demonstration that P. mirabilis swarms are capable of territoriality and self versus non-self recognition. Though first described over 70 years ago, the molecular mechanisms underlying boundary formation in P. mirabilis have remained stubbornly elusive despite the combined efforts of several research groups. In this article we attempt to give a concise review of the historical and current models for Proteus boundary formation. We begin with a brief background on the genus Proteus and specifically the species Proteus mirabilis, followed by a review of swarm boundary formation. We then analyze the two prominent models for boundary formation: (1) preemptive antagonism and (2) recognition. We conclude with the broader implications of P. mirabilis territoriality and self vs non-self recognition. Figure 1 Boundary between P. mirabilis strains 2. The genus Proteus 2.1 General information about the ecology of Proteus The genus Proteus is a member of the Enterobacteriaceae family. Proteus can be found in soil and contaminated water, and for some Proteus species, in the intestinal tract of animals. In soil and water, and perhaps healthy animals, Proteus species are likely involved in the degradation of organic material. These bacteria are noted for their ability to utilize urea as a source of nitrogen and energy2. The two Proteus species most commonly found in humans are P. mirabilis and to a lesser extent P. vulgaris3. Jacobsen et al. and Manos et al. recently reviewed Proteus pathogenesis in detail2,3. In brief, P. mirabilis is an opportunistic pathogen that causes complicated urinary tract infections, especially in people requiring long-term indwelling catheterization4. In hospital and nursing home settings, Proteus species can also cause infections in the ear, nose, throat, and skin, among others, especially immunocompromised individuals. Infections at multiple sites in a single patient are caused by single P. mirabilis strains; P. mirabilis strains isolated from the catheter, urine, feces and kidney stones of a single patient are often the same strain, suggesting that P. mirabilis infections are clonal5–7.

Ecological Variables Affecting Predatory Success in Myxococcus xanthus

The feeding efficiency of microbial predators depends on both the availability of various prey species and abiotic variables. Myxococcus xanthus is a bacterial predator that searches for microbial prey by gliding motility, and then kills and lyses its prey with secreted compounds. We manipulated three ecological variables to examine their effects on the predatory performance of M. xanthus to better understand its behavior and how it affects prey populations. Experiments were designed to determine how surface solidity (hard vs soft agar), density of prey patches (1 vs 2 cm grids), and type of prey (Gram-positive Micrococcus luteus vs Gram-negative Escherichia coli) affect predatory swarming and prey killing by M. xanthus. The prey were dispersed in patches on a buffered agar surface. M. xanthus swarms attacked a greater proportion of prey patches when patches were densely arranged on a hard-agar surface, compared with either soft-agar surfaces or low-patch-density arrangements. These ecological variables did not significantly influence the rate of killing of individual prey within a patch, although a few surviving prey were more likely to be recovered on soft agar than on hard agar. These results indicate that M. xanthus quickly kills most nearby E. coli or M. luteus regardless of the surface. However, the ability of M. xanthus to search out patches of these prey is affected by surface hardness, the density of prey patches, and the prey species.

Loss-of-Function Mutations of ROOT HAIR DEFECTIVE3 Suppress Root Waving, Skewing, and Epidermal Cell File Rotation in Arabidopsis

Wild-type Arabidopsis (Arabidopsis thaliana L. Heynh.) roots growing on a tilted surface of impenetrable hard-agar media adopt a wave-like pattern and tend to skew to the right of the gravity vector (when viewed from the back of the plate through the medium). Reversible root-tip rotation often accompanies the clockwise and counterclockwise curves that form each wave. These rotations are manifested by epidermal cell file rotation (CFR) along the root. Loss-of-function alleles of ROOT HAIR DEFECTIVE3 (RHD3), a gene previously implicated in the control of vesicle trafficking between the endoplasmic reticulum and the Golgi compartments, resulted in an almost complete suppression of epidermal CFR, root skewing, and waving on hard-agar surfaces. Several other root hair defective mutants (rhd2-1, rhd4-1, and rhd6-1) did not exhibit dramatic alterations in these root growth behaviors, suggesting that a generalized defect in root hair formation is not responsible for the surface-dependent phenotypes of rhd3. However, similar alterations in root growth behavior were observed in a variety of mutants characterized by defects in cell expansion (cob-1, cob-2, eto1-1, eto2-1, erh2-1, and erh3-1). The erh2-1 and rhd3-1 mutants differed from other anisotropic cell expansion mutants, though, by an inability to respond to low doses of the microtubule-binding drug propyzamide, which normally causes enhanced left-handed CFR and right skewing. We hypothesize that RHD3 may control epidermal CFR, root skewing, and waving on hard-agar surfaces by regulating the traffic of wall- or plasma membrane-associated determinants of anisotropic cell expansion.

Ethylene modulates root-wave responses in Arabidopsis.

When stimulated to bend downward by being held at 45 degrees off vertical but unable to penetrate into agar-based media, Arabidopsis roots develop waving and looping growth patterns. Here, we demonstrate that ethylene modulates these responses. We determined that agar-containing plates sealed with low-porosity film generate abiotic ethylene concentrations of 0.1 to 0.3 microL L(-1), whereas in plates wrapped with porous tape, ethylene remains at trace levels. We demonstrate that exogenous ethylene at concentrations as low as a few nanoliters per liter modulates root waving, root growth direction, and looping but through partly different mechanisms. Nutrients and Suc modify the effects of ethylene on root waving. Thus, ethylene had little effect on temporal wave frequency when nutrients were omitted but reduced it significantly on nutrient-supplemented agar. Suc masked the ethylene response. Ethylene consistently suppressed the normal tendency for roots of Landsberg erecta to skew to the right as they grow against hard-agar surfaces and also generated righthanded petiole twisting. Furthermore, ethylene suppressed root looping, a gravity-dependent growth response that was enhanced by high nutrient and Suc availability. Our work demonstrates that cell file twisting is not essential for root waving or skewing to occur. Differential flank growth accounted for both the extreme root waving on zero-nutrient plates and for root skewing. Root twisting was nutrient-dependent and was thus strongly associated with the looping response. The possible role of auxin transport in these responses and the involvement of circadian rhythms are discussed.

A novel extracellular cyclic lipopeptide which promotes flagellum-dependent and -independent spreading growth of Serratia marcescens.

Serrawettin W2, a surface-active exolipid produced by nonpigmented Serratia marcescens NS 25, was examined for its chemical structure and physiological functions. The chemical structure was determined by degradation analyses, infrared spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Serrawettin W2 was shown to be a novel cyclodepsipeptide containing a fatty acid (3-hydroxydecanoic acid) and five amino acids. The peptide was proposed to be D-leucine (N-bonded to the carboxylate of the fatty acid)-L-serine-L-threonine-D-phenylalanine-L-isoleucine (bonded to the 3-hydroxyl group). By examining the effects of isolated serrawettin W2 on serrawettinless mutants, this lipopeptide was shown to be active in the promotion of flagellum-independent spreading growth of the bacteria on a hard agar surface. The parent strain NS 25 formed a giant colony with a self-similar characteristic after incubation for a relatively long time (1 to 2 weeks), similar to other fractal colony-producing strains of S. marcescens (producers of the different serrawettins W1 and W3). On a semisolid medium that permitted flagellum-dependent spreading growth, an external supply of serrawettin W2 accelerated surface translocation of a serrawettinless mutant during a short period (12 h) of observation. In contrast, bacterial translocation in the subsurface space of the semisolid agar was not enhanced by serrawettins. Thus, the extracellular lipids seem to contribute specifically to the surface translocation of the bacteria by exhibiting surfactant activity.

Amphibian cells in vitro: I. Growth of Xenopus cells in a soft agar medium and on an agar surface

Cells of nine amphibian permanent cell lines grew in or on agar with plating efficiencies of 10–85%. Xenopus primary strain normal cells or lymphoid tumour cells usually did not grow in the agar medium, but sometimes formed detached, morula-like balls of cells in liquid medium on a hard agar surface