Haptic Actuator Research Articles

Haptic artificial muscle skin for extended reality.

Existing haptic actuators are often rigid and limited in their ability to replicate real-world tactile sensations. We present a wearable haptic artificial muscle skin (HAMS) based on fully soft, millimeter-scale, multilayer dielectric elastomer actuators (DEAs) capable of significant out-of-plane deformation, a capability that typically requires rigid or liquid biasing. The DEAs use a thickness-varying multilayer structure to achieve large out-of-plane displacement and force, maintaining comfort and wearability. Experimental results demonstrate that HAMS can produce complex tactile feedback with high perception accuracy. Moreover, we show that HAMS can be integrated into extended reality (XR) systems, enhancing immersion and offering potential applications in entertainment, education, and assistive technologies.

A Numerical Study of the Vibration Characteristics of a Haptic Actuator for a Dial Gear Shifter

Human–machine interaction (HMI) is becoming increasingly important, especially in the automotive industry, where advancements in automated driving and driver assistance systems are key to enhancing driver safety and convenience. Among the many HMI interfaces, tactile sensing has been widely used in automotive applications as it enables instant and direct interactions with drivers. An area that remains underexplored among the tactile HMI interfaces is the application of haptic feedback to gear shifter modules. Therefore, this study investigates the design optimization of a dial gear shifter by analyzing the vibrations transmitted to the knob surface from an integrated haptic actuator. Specifically, we first tuned the mechanical properties of the haptic actuator (in terms of the resonance frequency and vibration level) in a simulation model by referring to experimental results. Next, a numerical model of a dial gear shifter was constructed, integrated with a haptic actuator, and tuned with the experimental results. The model was further optimized based on the design of the experiment and sensitivity analyses. The optimized design yielded a 24.5% improvement in the vibration level compared with the reference design, exceeding the minimum threshold (>~2.5 m/s2 at 200 Hz) required for tactile sensing. The vibration enhancement (>22.x%) was also confirmed under the simulated hand-grabbing condition. This study is technically significant as it demonstrates that the haptic vibration in a dial gear shifter can be efficiently optimized through numerical analyses. This research will be used for the actual prototyping of a dial gear shifter to provide a safe driving experience for drivers.

Wireless programmable patterns of electro-hydraulic haptic electronic skins able to create surface morphology

Haptic feedback technology represents a frontier with revolutionary potential, particularly in virtual and augmented reality. Skin, as an underexplored sensory interface, holds tremendous potential to significantly enrich our perceptual experiences while directly impacting the fields of communication, entertainment, and medicine. This article presents a programmable, ultra-lightweight, and ultra-thin wireless wearable haptic electronic skin that achieves rapid response and large mechanical feedback force and deformation displacement output. The electronic skin comprises a series of haptic electro-hydraulic actuators, each with the weight of 0.023 g and the thickness of 199 μm. Each actuator can be independently regulated and produce a maximum normal force of 150 mN and a normal displacement of 0.58 mm, simultaneously achieving the haptic presentation of textures. Relying on a portable multi-channel control circuit system designed, each electro-hydraulic actuator of the haptic electronic skin can be precisely control to achieve various haptic patterns. Showcasing its potentials, the haptic technology aids visual-impaired individuals in reading books, provides ground navigation instructions, and enhances gaming experiences, contributing to a more immersive and authentic artificial intelligence environment.

AI-Enhanced Edge Device for Real-Time Snoring Detection

This paper presents the development of a cutting-edge, non-invasive edge device designed to monitor snoring and provide timely, moderate haptic feedback to users. Utilizing the Qualcomm Snapdragon 8cx Gen 3 processor, the device offers robust computing power and AI capabilities for real-time processing, making it a versatile tool for health monitoring applications. The system integrates a high-fidelity MEMS microphone array capable of capturing nuanced audio signals and a TDK piezoelectric haptic actuator, which delivers precise alerts through customized vibrations. The research explores the potential of this advanced hardware in detecting and managing obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), a condition often underdiagnosed due to a lack of patient awareness. By leveraging state-of-the-art digital signal processing and deep learning techniques, the device aims to enhance user awareness and intervention in sleep-related disorders, offering a promising new avenue for improving patient outcomes and quality of life.

UltLever: Ultrasound-Driven Passive Haptic Actuator Based on Amplifying Radiation Force Using a Simple Lever Mechanism.

A lightweight haptic display that does not interfere with the user's natural movement is required for an immersive haptic experience. This study proposes a lightweight, powerful, and responsive passive haptic actuator driven by airborne focused ultrasound. This 6.2 g completely plastic passive device amplifies an applied ultrasound radiation force by a factor of 35 using a simple lever mechanism, presenting an amplified force of 0.7 N to the user's finger pad. 2-30 Hz vibration can also be presented. Since the radiation force is presented at the speed of sound, the amplified force is presented at high speed even with the high amplification rate of a lever, achieving such strong force and vibration presentation. Physical measurements showed that the amplified force was 0.7 N for the 20.48 mN input radiation force, and the amplitude of the presented vibration was over 0.1 N at 2-30 Hz. A psychophysical experiment showed that the vibration and force were perceivable with a device output level of -7.7 dB. In the future, we will explore methodologies around device design to present desired tactile sensations.

Soft Pneumatic Haptic Wearable to Create the Illusion of Human Touch.

The ability to deliver sensations of human-like touch within virtual reality remains an important challenge to immersive, realistic experiences. Since conventional haptic actuators impart distinctively unnatural effects, we instead tackle this challenge through the design of a rendering mechanism using soft pneumatic actuators (SPA), embedded within a wearable jacket. The resulting system is then evaluated for its ability to mimic realistic touch gesture sensations of grab, touch, tap, and tickle as performed by human fingertips. The results of our experiments indicate that the stimuli produced by our design were reasonably effective in presenting realistic human-generated sensations.

Head-Up Haptic Display Using Dual-Mode Haptic Actuator for Vehicles

Driving assistance modules are important components to improving driver safety in driving environments, which can create overloaded multisensory information. This paper introduces the concept of a head-up haptic display that assists drivers in keeping their visual attention focused, and then offers a haptic actuator that may be used as the main component in the head-up haptic display. We selected magneto-rheological elastomer (MRE) as the base material and adopted a porous structure to reduce its initial stiffness. Furthermore, we fabricate a haptic actuator based on an MRE having a porous structure (pMRE) and a solenoid. The current to the solenoid generates a magnetic field that causes the pMRE to stiffen, thereby increasing the resistive force. As soon as the current input is removed, the pMRE becomes soft again. We simulated the solenoid coil and the magnetic path to further maximize the magneto-motive force generated by the solenoid coil and experimentally optimized the pMRE. We showed that the proposed haptic actuator creates not only a sufficient resistive force but also vibration to generate various haptic sensations. Moreover, we constructed a head-up haptic display using four haptic actuators and demonstrated the possibility of utilizing a new user interface to increase driving safety.

Improved tactile speech perception using audio-to-tactile sensory substitution with formant frequency focusing

Haptic hearing aids, which provide speech information through tactile stimulation, could substantially improve outcomes for both cochlear implant users and for those unable to access cochlear implants. Recent advances in wide-band haptic actuator technology have made new audio-to-tactile conversion strategies viable for wearable devices. One such strategy filters the audio into eight frequency bands, which are evenly distributed across the speech frequency range. The amplitude envelopes from the eight bands modulate the amplitudes of eight low-frequency tones, which are delivered through vibration to a single site on the wrist. This tactile vocoder strategy effectively transfers some phonemic information, but vowels and obstruent consonants are poorly portrayed. In 20 participants with normal touch perception, we tested (1) whether focusing the audio filters of the tactile vocoder more densely around the first and second formant frequencies improved tactile vowel discrimination, and (2) whether focusing filters at mid-to-high frequencies improved obstruent consonant discrimination. The obstruent-focused approach was found to be ineffective. However, the formant-focused approach improved vowel discrimination by 8%, without changing overall consonant discrimination. The formant-focused tactile vocoder strategy, which can readily be implemented in real time on a compact device, could substantially improve speech perception for haptic hearing aid users.

Adaptive tactile interaction transfer via digitally embroidered smart gloves

Human-machine interfaces for capturing, conveying, and sharing tactile information across time and space hold immense potential for healthcare, augmented and virtual reality, human-robot collaboration, and skill development. To realize this potential, such interfaces should be wearable, unobtrusive, and scalable regarding both resolution and body coverage. Taking a step towards this vision, we present a textile-based wearable human-machine interface with integrated tactile sensors and vibrotactile haptic actuators that are digitally designed and rapidly fabricated. We leverage a digital embroidery machine to seamlessly embed piezoresistive force sensors and arrays of vibrotactile actuators into textiles in a customizable, scalable, and modular manner. We use this process to create gloves that can record, reproduce, and transfer tactile interactions. User studies investigate how people perceive the sensations reproduced by our gloves with integrated vibrotactile haptic actuators. To improve the effectiveness of tactile interaction transfer, we develop a machine-learning pipeline that adaptively models how each individual user reacts to haptic sensations and then optimizes haptic feedback parameters. Our interface showcases adaptive tactile interaction transfer through the implementation of three end-to-end systems: alleviating tactile occlusion, guiding people to perform physical skills, and enabling responsive robot teleoperation.

A Hydraulic Haptic Actuator for Simulation of Cardiac Catheters.

This article presents a haptic actuator made of silicone rubber to provide both passive and active haptic forces for catheter simulations. The haptic actuator has a torus outer shape with an ellipse-shaped inside chamber which is actuated by hydraulic pressure. Expansion of the chamber by providing positive pressure can squeeze the inside passage to resist the catheter traveling through. Further expansion can hold and push back the catheter in the axial direction to render active haptic forces. The size of the catheter passage is increased by providing negative pressure to the chamber, allowing various diameters of the actual medical catheters to be used and exchanged during the simulation. The diameter of the catheter passage can be enlarged up to 1.6 times to allow 5 to 7 Fr (1 Fr = 1/3 mm) medical catheters to pass through. Experiment results show that the proposed haptic actuator can render 0 to 2.0 N passive feedback force, and a maximum of 2.0 N active feedback force, sufficient for the cardiac catheter simulation. The haptic actuator can render the commanded force profile with 0.10 N RMS (root-mean-squares) and 10.51% L2-norm relative errors.

A Universal Volumetric Haptic Actuation Platform

In this paper, we report a method of implementing a universal volumetric haptic actuation platform which can be adapted to fit a wide variety of visual displays with flat surfaces. This platform aims to enable the simulation of the 3D features of input interfaces. This goal is achieved using four readily available stepper motors in a diagonal cross configuration with which we can quickly change the position of a surface in a manner that can render these volumetric features. In our research, we use a Microsoft Surface Go tablet placed on the haptic enhancement actuation platform to replicate the exploratory features of virtual keyboard keycaps displayed on the touchscreen. We ask seven participants to explore the surface of a virtual keypad comprised of 12 keycaps. As a second task, random key positions are announced one at a time, which the participant is expected to locate. These experiments are used to understand how and with what fidelity the volumetric feedback could improve performance (detection time, track length, and error rate) of detecting the specific keycaps location with haptic feedback and in the absence of visual feedback. Participants complete the tasks with great success (p < 0.05). In addition, their ability to feel convex keycaps is confirmed within the subjective comments.

The Effect of Actuation Speed on the Perception Threshold of a Squeezing Soft Actuator.

The actuation speed of a pressure stimulus may influence its perception threshold. This is relevant for the design of haptic actuators and haptic interaction. We ran a study using a motorized ribbon to apply pressure stimuli (squeezes) to the arm at three different actuation speeds and used the PSI method to find the perception threshold for 21 participants. We found a significant effect of actuation speed on the perception threshold. Namely, a lower speed seems to increase the thresholds of normal force, pressure and indentation. This could be due to multiple factors like temporal summation, stimulating a larger population of mechanoreceptors for faster stimuli, and different responses of SA and RA receptors to stimuli of varying speeds. Our results show that actuation speed is an important parameter for the design of new haptic actuators and the design of haptic interaction for pressure.

Exploring the applicability of haptic actuators in aquatic environments

The use of high-tech wearable devices and real-time biomechanical feedback (RTBF) is widespread in modern sports and physical rehabilitation. While the use of kinematic sensors for RTBF is well established, the question of the most efficient and appropriate way to present feedback information to the user remains largely unanswered. The haptic modality has only been used in a limited number of relatively simple studies and applications, and it has never been studied in an aquatic environment. In this study, the main motivation was to design, develop, implement, and test an RTBF system for sports and physical rehabilitation with haptic actuators suitable for use in aquatic environments. The developed miniature remote-controlled device with vibration motors as actuators was tested to determine how people perceive the haptic modality in and out of water. The results of the exploratory study with 34 participants suggest that the feedback device can be further developed for future studies. The results show that both simple and complex haptic stimuli can be understood by athletes both outdoors and in water, as well as while standing and performing simple physical activities. This study tested the use of both head and waist mounted haptic actuators, with both showing similar and promising results. The results of this study provide evidence that haptic feedback can be perceived in water, highlighting the potential for real-time haptic interventions in aquatic environments. In summary, this study represents a significant contribution to the evolving field of RTBF in modern sport training and physical rehabilitation. The development of a haptic feedback device that can be worn during aquatic and other activities is a significant advance in the field of feedback actuators. This study provides a foundation for future usability studies and the development of haptic RTBF applications in both aquatic and outdoor environments.

Improving speech perception for hearing-impaired listeners using audio-to-tactile sensory substitution with multiple frequency channels

Cochlear implants (CIs) have revolutionised treatment of hearing loss, but large populations globally cannot access them either because of disorders that prevent implantation or because they are expensive and require specialist surgery. Recent technology developments mean that haptic aids, which transmit speech through vibration, could offer a viable low-cost, non-invasive alternative. One important development is that compact haptic actuators can now deliver intense stimulation across multiple frequencies. We explored whether these multiple frequency channels can transfer spectral information to improve tactile phoneme discrimination. To convert audio to vibration, the speech amplitude envelope was extracted from one or more audio frequency bands and used to amplitude modulate one or more vibro-tactile tones delivered to a single-site on the wrist. In 26 participants with normal touch sensitivity, tactile-only phoneme discrimination was assessed with one, four, or eight frequency bands. Compared to one frequency band, performance improved by 5.9% with four frequency bands and by 8.4% with eight frequency bands. The multi-band signal-processing approach can be implemented in real-time on a compact device, and the vibro-tactile tones can be reproduced by the latest compact, low-powered actuators. This approach could therefore readily be implemented in a low-cost haptic hearing aid to deliver real-world benefits.

Macro-fiber composite-based tactors for haptic applications.

Haptic technology is a critical component of human-computer interfaces. Traditional haptic actuators are often unable to provide the broad frequency range and latency that is required in many advanced applications. To address this problem, we propose a new type of tactor based on macro-fiber composites (MFCs), composites of piezoelectric fibers. We propose a physics-based model for the actuation of the tactors, calibrated and validated through experiments. As our tactors are intended for haptic applications, we consider the role of skin on their response, an aspect seldom analyzed in the literature. In our experiments, we simulate the presence of the skin with a rubber membrane in contact with the tactor, with varying pre-stretch, mimicking different indentations of the tactor on the skin. The MFC-based tactor can always generate vibration amplitudes higher than skin discrimination thresholds, over the range of frequencies of interest for haptics, with a latency much smaller than traditional actuators. We theoretically investigate the effect of the skin on tactor vibrations, highlighting the individual roles of skin stiffness and damping and their combined effect across a series of pre-stretches. Our tactor shows promise in haptic applications, including assistive technologies and real-time feedback systems for training, safety, and monitoring.

Soft Electromagnetic Vibrotactile Actuators with Integrated Vibration Amplitude Sensing.

Soft vibrotactile devices have the potential to expand the functionality of emerging electronic skin technologies. However, those devices often lack the necessary overall performance, sensing-actuation feedback and control, and mechanical compliance for seamless integration on the skin. Here, we present soft haptic electromagnetic actuators that consist of intrinsically stretchable conductors, pressure-sensitive conductive foams, and soft magnetic composites. To minimize joule heating, high-performance stretchable composite conductors are developed based on in situ-grown silver nanoparticles formed within the silver flake framework. The conductors are laser-patterned to form soft and densely packed coils to further minimize heating. Soft pressure-sensitive conducting polymer-cellulose foams are developed and integrated to tune the resonance frequency and to provide internal resonator amplitude sensing in the resonators. The above components together with a soft magnet are assembled into soft vibrotactile devices providing high-performance actuation combined with amplitude sensing. We believe that soft haptic devices will be an essential component in future developments of multifunctional electronic skin for future human-computer and human-robotic interfaces.

Perceptual Substitution Based Haptic Texture Rendering for Narrow-Band Reproduction.

Recorded high-resolution texture vibration contains perceptually redundant spectral information due to tactile limitations of human skin. Also, accurate reproduction of recorded texture vibration is often infeasible for widely available haptic reproduction systems at mobile devices. Usually, haptic actuators can only reproduce narrow-bandwidth vibration. With the exception of research setups, rendering strategies need to be developed, that utilize the limited capabilities of various actuator systems and tactile receptors while minimizing a negative impact on perceived quality of reproduction. Therefore, the aim of this study is to substitute recorded texture vibrations with perceptually sufficient simple vibrations. Accordingly, similarity of band-limited noise, single sinusoid and amplitude-modulated signals on display are rated compared to real textures. Considering that low and high frequency bands of noise signals might be implausible and redundant, different combinations of cut-off frequencies are applied to noise vibrations. Moreover, suitability of amplitude-modulation signals are tested for coarse textures in addition to single sinusoids because of their capability of creating pulse-like roughness sensation without too low frequencies. With the set of experiments, narrowest band noise vibration with frequencies between 90 Hz to 400 Hz is determined according to the fine textures. Furthermore, AM vibrations are found to be more congruent than single sinusoids to reproduce too coarse textures.

Electromechanical Actuators for Haptic Feedback with Fingertip Contact

Haptic technology that provides tactile sensation feedback by utilizing actuators to achieve the purpose of human–computer interaction is obtaining increasing applications in electronic devices. This review covers four kinds of electromechanical actuators useful for achieving haptic feedback: electromagnetic, electrostatic, piezoelectric, and electrostrictive actuators. The driving principles, working conditions, applicable scopes, and characteristics of the different actuators are fully compared. The designs and values of piezoelectric actuators to achieve sophisticated and high-definition haptic effect sensations are particularly highlighted. The current status and directions for future development of the different types of haptic actuators are discussed.

Verification Experiments of a Flat-Type Three-Degree-of-Freedom Haptic Actuator

Verification Experiments of a Flat-Type Three-Degree-of-Freedom Haptic Actuator

Skin-Integrated Haptic Interfaces Enabled by Scalable Mechanical Actuators for Virtual Reality

The very recent concept of metaverse highlights the importance of virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR), which associates with a wide variety of applications in entertainment, medical treatment, and human–machine interfaces. The current VR/AR technologies mainly rely on visual interaction, while immersive experience in VR and AR highly demands sensational feedback, such as haptic and temperature with noticeable quality in wearable or even skin-integrated formarts. In this article, we report a wearable and flexible haptic interface based on electromagnetic vibrotactile actuators with high wearability and stability. By adopting double layers of copper (Cu) coils at the top and bottom of the magnetic disc, an enhanced electromagnetic field can be generated. Additionally, the intensity of the haptic feedback can be modulated according to sensed pressure in the virtual world by adjusting the value of power input and frequency. The actuator exhibits high stability and tolerance upon environmental, cyclic, and impact resistance tests. Finally, the actuators are developed into the soft VR interfaces for mounting on forearms, fingers, and hands to verify their superiority over conventional haptic actuators in the aspects of performance and applications.