Purpose One common complaint with natural opacified lenses is the deleterious effects of higher-order ocular aberrations and intraocular scatter, such as halos and starbursts, which are not always remedied with surgery and intraocular lens (IOL) implantation. Blue-light filtering (BLF) IOL filter scatter-prone short-wave light. Here, we determine whether BLF IOL reduce halo and starburst size. Methods This study was a case-control design, between- and within-subjects (contralateral implantation). Sixty-nine participants with either the BLF IOL (n = 25; AlconSN60AT), clear IOL (n = 24; AlconSA60AT or WF), or both (n = 20) IOL participated. Participants were exposed to a point source of broadband simulated sunlight, which created the appearance of halos/starbursts. Dysphotopsia was measured as the diameter of broadband light-induced halos and starbursts. Results A case-control analysis. Halo size was significantly larger (t[35.05] = 2.98, p = 0.005) in participants with the clear control lens (M = 3°55′ ± 2°48′), compared to the BLF IOL (M = 1°84′ ± 1°34′). Starburst size was not significantly different between groups. Contralateral analysis. Halo size was significantly smaller (t = −3.89, p = .001) in test eyes with the BLF (M = 3°16′ ± 2°35′) compared to the fellow control eyes (M = 5°42′ ± 3°17′). Starburst size was also significantly smaller (t = −2.60, p < 0.018) in BLF test eyes (M = 9°57′ ± 4°25′) than the fellow eye with the clear IOL (M = 12°33′ ± 5°25′). Conclusions BLF IOL filter short-wave light and mimic retinal screening by the young, natural crystalline lens. Such filtering can reduce some deleterious effects of bright light by decreasing ocular diffusion/halos and starbursts.