Groundwater, a vital freshwater resource catering to agricultural, domestic, and industrial needs, faces a pressing challenge of contamination due to escalating human activities. This study focuses on the Ayad River Basin in the Udaipur district of Rajasthan, employing the FEFLOW simulation code for the first time. A steady-state numerical model and a groundwater contaminant prediction model for total dissolved solids (TDS), nitrate, and fluoride were developed, simulating trends over the next five years with an accuracy exceeding 95%. The results reveal an eastward increase in TDS, nitrate, and fluoride concentrations, attributed to contamination from two waste disposal sites-Titadi and Baleecha. Titadi, operational for four decades until closure in 2010, retains residual waste over 32 thousand m2. The initiation of a new dumping ground at Baleecha by the Udaipur Municipal Corporation post-2010 exacerbates regional contamination. Nitrate contamination is particularly high in agricultural zones with excessive chemical fertilizer usage. Of the 27 scenarios tested, 23 support using the water for irrigation but would require treatment before using it for drinking. Recommendations include deploying a chemical sensor network for real-time data input into the web enabled FEFLOW model, real-time monitoring and alerts, and a mobile application providing personalized guidance on water usage and health risks in case of contamination. This study can be beneficial to decision-makers, who work on the policy and groundwater management strategies.