Struggle for the Heartland and Banners to the Breeze are two new titles in the University of Nebraska Press's Great Campaigns of the Civil War series. In book length and general subject matter, the series recalls the Scribner's Campaigns of the Civil War volumes of the 1880s. The similarities end there, however. The Scribner's series focused almost solely on the battlefield and boasted authors who had played prominent command roles in the campaigns they wrote about (an approach that worked with varying degrees of success, depending on the author's skill and veracity). On the other hand, the University of Nebraska series features professional historians who eschew the traditional narrow tactical study, and instead examine the military operations within a wider political and social context. The books are synthetic works that use the most recent scholarship in providing a comprehensive overview of the campaigns."The most pressing challenge facing Civil War scholarship today," argue series co-editors Anne J. Bailey and Brooks D. Simpson, "is the integration of various perspectives and emphases into a new narrative that explains not only what happened, why, and how, but also why it mattered." The authors of Struggle and Banners, Stephen D. Engle and Earl J. Hess, meet this formidable challenge. Their two studies form a continuous narrative delineating the crucial military operations of 1862 in the war's Western theater—roughly the area between the Appalachian Mountains to the east, the Mississippi River to the west, the Ohio River to the north, and the Gulf of Mexico to the south. The first half of 1862 saw an almost unbroken string of Federal successes in the west. As its subtitle indicates, Struggle traces the Union invasion of the Confederate heartland, beginning with the captures of Forts Henry and Donelson, continuing with the Battle of Shiloh, and concluding with the siege of Corinth, Mississippi. By mid-1862, the momentum appeared to shift, as the Federals consolidated their gains and the Confederates attempted to seize much of the territory they had lost. Banners traces the Confederate counteroffensive that culminated in the Battle of Perryville, Kentucky, followed by the Southerners' retreat into central Tennessee and the Battle of Stones River. The book also recounts the unsuccessful Confederate effort to recapture Corinth.
Read full abstract