Foucault's Formative Years Paul Allen Miller (bio) Review of Stuart Elden, The Early Foucault, Cambridge Polity Press 2021. xiv + 280 pp. Stuart Elden has become the definitive chronicler of Foucault's intellectual evolution. The Early Foucault is the third in what will ultimately be a four-volume history. The series began with Foucault's Last Decade (2016). While the first volume was originally intended as a stand-alone work, it immediately became clear to the publisher and the reviewers alike that this approach should be extended to the whole of Foucault's intellectual life. Elden has created what is in effect a kind of Bible for Foucault scholars, a series of works that any serious student of Foucault simply must consult. Elden is careful not to call his work a biography to distinguish it from the admirable work of David Macey and Didier Eribon on the life of Foucault as well as the gossip-filled scandalmongering of the regrettable James Miller. Elden focuses on Foucault's published work, not in terms of a close reading of his texts, although he is a more than competent interpreter, but in terms of how they came to be, on their intellectual genealogy. How did arguments come together? Who were Foucault's interlocutors? What sources did he consult? Elden's work in the Foucault archives housed in the Bibliothèque Nationale as well as those found in the Institut Mémoires de l'Édition Contemporaine is extraordinarily thorough and meticulous. For the present volume he has also consulted archives in Uppsala and Hamburg, where Foucault worked in the 1950s, and the personal archives of such early mentors as Louis Althusser, Georges Canguilhem, Georges Dumézil, and Jean Hyppolite. Elden does not ignore issues in Foucault's personal life, but he explores them only to the extent that they are relevant to his oeuvre. Thus, in the current volume there is a short discussion of Foucault's relationship (1953–55) with the young serialist composer Jean Barraqué, but the focus is on their mutual intellectual influence, with particular regard to Foucault's early interest in Nietzsche. Foucault would later observe that Barraqué's and Boulez's serialist music had an analogous effect on his intellectual formation to that of Nietzsche himself, creating a "rupture in the dialectical universe" (124). [End Page 343] The telos of this volume is the writing of Foucault's major thesis for his doctorat d'État, what would eventually become known as Histoire de la folie or, according to the greatly abridged version that was first translated into English and was long the only version available, Madness and Civilization. The story begins in 1945 when Foucault moved to Paris and matriculated at the Lycée Henri IV, where he enrolled in the preparatory course for the entrance exam for the École normale supérieure (ENS) and first encountered the great Hegel scholar Jean Hyppolite, who was briefly his instructor in philosophy there. At Henri IV, Foucault studied a comprehensive liberal arts curriculum that focused on philosophy, literature, and history in French, German, Latin, and Greek. He entered the ENS in 1946 and was awarded a licence in philosophy in 1948 and a second in psychology in 1949, with an advanced diploma in general psychology from the Paris Institut de Psychologie that same year. This pairing of the disciplines set the intellectual agenda for Foucault for the following decade, as he both deepened and expanded his philosophical knowledge and gained theoretical and practical knowledge of psychology, psychiatry, and psychoanalysis. Elden provides thorough coverage of the scope of Foucault's philosophical education, detailing each of his professors and their respective specialties. In 1949, Foucault submitted the equivalent of an MA thesis on "The Constitution of a Transcendental in Hegel's Phenomenology of the Spirit" under the direction of Hyppolite. He then immediately began studying under the direction of Althusser for the aggrégation, the national exam given each year that qualifies you to teach philosophy, which he passed with high marks on the second attempt, in 1951. He began his teaching career in 1952 with an appointment in Lille, while also lecturing at the ENS. Elden reconstructs the substance of Foucault's...
Read full abstract