Reviewed by: Two Civil Wars: The Curious Shared Journal of a Baton Rouge Schoolgirl and a Union Sailor on the USS Essex ed. by Katherine Bentley Jeffrey Charles Wexler Two Civil Wars: The Curious Shared Journal of a Baton Rouge Schoolgirl and a Union Sailor on the USS Essex. Ed. Katherine Bentley Jeffrey. ISBN 978-0-8071-6224-8, 274 pp., cloth, $38.00 In Two Civil Wars: The Curious Shared Journal of a Baton Rouge Schoolgirl and a Union Sailor on the USS Essex, Katherine Bentley Jeffrey explores the journal of William L. Park, a gunner on board the ironclad USS Essex. Here Jeffrey has not only unearthed this contemporary account, the first published diary from this converted steam ferry, but also why Park penned his memoir in a book originating from an antebellum Louisiana Catholic school. The end result is a well-researched edited work that reveals the journal's original owners. Jeffrey has determined that the journal originated as a French composition book from St. Mary's Female Academy in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. Founded by Ohio-born Matilda Victor in 1855, the school attracted both Catholic and Protestant students, among them the book's original owner, Celeste Repp. Born in 1846, Repp lived with her grandparents before she attended St. Mary's in 1859. Here, she learned from Jesuit Father Darius Hubert, who taught French classes. Jeffrey has analyzed and translated the few French compositions Repp wrote in the book in 1859. Her handwriting analysis suggests that a second student acquired the book before Louisiana's 1861 secession disrupted matters. Hubert joined the 1st Louisiana and spent four years with the Army of Northern Virginia. Victor kept the school open until Union forces occupied Baton Rouge. Then, she shattered any local ties when she openly supported northern soldiers, and the school soon shuttered. Jeffrey argues that while Victor fled northward, her school's teachings lived on through Repp. The young woman joined Sisters of Mercy in 1868, and after taking her vows as Sister Mary Euphresia, she taught black children in Pass Christian, Mississippi. Repp's journal, though, did not remain at St. Mary's. At some point during the 1862 Union occupation, William L. Park, a gunner onboard the ironclad USS Essex, acquired it. Born in Scotland in 1836, Park first joined the Royal Navy during the Crimean War before moving to Canada. He worked as a commercial sailor on the Great Lakes before he arrived in Chicago in September 1861. Then, patriotic fervor swept up Park's friend Andrew Waterman, who convinced him to enlist. On September 25, 1861, the two joined the Western Gunboat Flotilla for a three-year term. While Waterman died at Fort Henry, Park survived and fought on different warships, most notably the Essex. Jeffrey explicitly notes her uncertainty as to whether Park immediately transferred his writings to this journal or did so after his enlistment ended, but she clearly details the differences between this contemporary account and his later, more expansive memoir (236–37). [End Page 323] The Park journal is a straightforward recollection of daily experiences. Park accurately depicted the dangers of naval combat onboard steam powered warships, including boiler explosions, which occurred for example on February 6, 1862, when the Essex helped capture Fort Henry. The released steam scalded many onboard, including Capt. William David Porter, brother of David Dixon Porter. Park participated in most major western naval battles, including Island No. 10, the fight with the Confederate ironclad Arkansas, Port Hudson, and the Red River campaign. Park also highlighted the increasing use of guerilla tactics and torpedo deployments against local Union forces. Jeffrey supplements Park's entries with extensive annotated notes, which while at times distracting provide needed background on key events, ships, and important personnel. The book suffers at times from Jeffrey's ambitious efforts. Her inclusion of both Victor and Hubert makes this a story of four rather than two Civil Wars: a unionist headmaster, an immigrant sailor swept up in patriotic fervor, a Confederate chaplain who served with his charges, and Repp's fragmented life in the Mississippi Valley. Juggling these narratives means she does not fully develop how these four fit within larger...