Biochar can both adsorb and degrade p-nitrophenol (PNP); however, the PNP degradation mechanism has not been well investigated. We prepared two biochars at pyrolysis temperatures of 500 °C (B500) and 700 °C (B700). Although B500 showed much stronger free radical signals (which are associated with organic degradation, according to previous studies), the apparent PNP degradation was approximately 3 times higher in the B700 system. The degradation increased significantly after the biochars were washed with water. According to a quantitative analysis of the sorption and degradation and two-compartment first-order kinetics modeling of the apparent removal kinetics, sorption occurred mainly in the initial period, whereas degradation continued throughout the removal process. The PNP degradation rate constant depended mainly on the external surface area at a relatively low concentration (200 mg/L) and was controlled by the microporous surface area at a relatively high concentration (800 mg/L). In addition, the apparent degradation did not depend on the biochar particle size. Therefore, PNP degradation may be related to the three-dimensional structure of the biochar in addition to the exposed external surface. The well-developed pore structure, more accessible surface, and larger electron exchange capacity of B700 may promote electron transfer between the biochar and PNP, and thus accelerate PNP degradation. This study demonstrates that various properties of the biochar may contribute to PNP degradation.