Forensic Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms Research Articles

Forensic identity SNPs: Characterisation of flanking region variation using massively parallel sequencing.

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) can be analysed for identity or kinship applications in forensic genetics to either provide an adjunct to traditional STR typing or as a stand-alone approach. The advent of massively parallel sequencing technology (MPS) has provided a useful opportunity to more easily deploy SNP typing in a forensic context, given the ability to simultaneously amplify a large number of markers. Furthermore, MPS also provides valuable sequence data for the targeted regions, which enables the detection of any additional variation seen in the flanking regions of amplicons. In this study we genotyped 977 samples across five UK-relevant population groups (White British, East Asian, South Asian, North-East African and West African) for 94 identity-informative SNP markers using the ForenSeq DNA Signature Prep Kit. Examination of flanking region variation allowed for the identification of 158 additional alleles across all populations studied. Here we present allele frequencies for all 94 identity-informative SNPs, both including and excluding the flanking region sequence of these markers. We also present information on the configuration of these SNPs in the ForenSeq DNA Signature Prep Kit, including performance metrics for the markers and investigation of bioinformatic and chemistry-based discordances. Overall, the inclusion of flanking region variation in the analysing workflow for these markers reduced the average combined match probability 2175 times across all populations, with a maximum reduction of 675,000-fold in the West African population. The gain due to flanking region-based discrimination increased the heterozygosity of some loci above that of some of the least useful forensic STR loci; thus demonstrating the benefit of enhanced analysis of currently targeted SNP markers for forensic applications.

Human profiling from STR and SNP analysis of tropical bed bug, Cimex hemipterus, for forensic science

Tropical bed bugs, Cimex hemipterus, which commonly feeds on human blood, may be useful in forensic applications. However, unlike the common bed bug, Cimex lectularius, there is no information regarding tropical bed bug, C. hemipterus, being studied for its applications in forensics. Thus, in this study, lab-reared post-feeding tropical bed bugs were subjected to Short Tandem Repeat (STR) and Single Nucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) analyses to establish the usage of tropical bed bugs in forensics. Several post-feeding times (0, 5, 14, 30, and 45 days) were tested to determine when a complete human DNA profile could still be obtained after the bugs had taken the blood meal. The results showed that complete STR and SNP profiles could only be obtained from the D0 sample. The profile completeness decreased over time, and partial STR and SNP profiles could be obtained up to 45 days post-blood meal. The generated SNP profiles, complete or partial, were also viable for HIrisPlex-S phenotype prediction. In addition, field-collected bed bugs were also used to examine the viability of the tested STR markers, and the STR markers detected mixed profiles. The findings of this study established that the post-blood meal of tropical bed bugs is a suitable source of human DNA for forensic STR and SNP profiling. Human DNA recovered from bed bugs can be used to identify spatial and temporal relations of events.

Nanopore sequencing of a forensic combined STR and SNP multiplex

Nanopore sequencing for forensic purposes has gained attention, as it yields added discriminatory power compared to capillary electrophoresis (CE), without the need for a high up-front capital investment. Besides enabling the detection of iso-alleles, Massively Parallel Sequencing (MPS) facilitates the analysis of Short Tandem Repeats (STRs) and Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms (SNPs) in parallel. In this research, six single-contributor samples were amplified by such a combined multiplex of 58 STR and 94 SNP loci, followed by nanopore sequencing using an R10.3 flowcell. Basecalling was performed using two state-of-the-art basecallers, Guppy and Bonito. An advanced alignment-based analysis method was developed, which lowered the noise after alignment of the STR reads to a reference library. Although STR genotyping by nanopore sequencing is more challenging, correct genotyping was obtained for all autosomal and all but two non-autosomal STR loci. Moreover, genotyping of iso-alleles proved to be very accurate. SNP genotyping yielded an accuracy of 99% for both basecallers. The use of novel basecallers, in combination with the newly developed alignment-based analysis method, yields results with a pronouncedly higher STR genotyping accuracy compared to previous studies

Selection and evaluation of bi-allelic autosomal SNP markers for paternity testing in Koreans

Due to the advantages of single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in forensic science, many forensic SNP panels have been developed. However, the existing SNP panels have a problem that they do not reflect allele frequencies in Koreans or the number of markers is not sufficient to perform paternity testing. Here, we filtered candidate SNPs from the Ansan-Ansung cohort data and selected 200 SNPs with high allele frequencies. To reduce the risk of false inclusion and false exclusion, we calculated likelihood ratios of alleged father-child pairs from simulated families when the alleged father is the true father, the close relative of the true father, and the random man. As a result, we estimated that 160 SNPs were needed to perform paternity testing. Furthermore, we performed validation using Twin-Family cohort data. When 160 selected SNPs were used to calculate the likelihood ratio, paternity and non-paternity were accurately distinguished. Our set of 160 SNPs could be useful for paternity testing in Koreans.

A compilation of tri-allelic SNPs from 1000 Genomes and use of the most polymorphic loci for a large-scale human identification panel

In a directed search of 1000 Genomes Phase III variation data, 271,934 tri-allelic single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were identified amongst the genotypes of 2,504 individuals from 26 populations. The majority of tri-allelic SNPs have three nucleotide substitution-based alleles at the same position, while a much smaller proportion, which we did not compile, have a nucleotide insertion/deletion plus substitution alleles. SNPs with three alleles have higher discrimination power than binary loci but keep the same characteristic of optimum amplification of the fragmented DNA found in highly degraded forensic samples. Although most of the tri-allelic SNPs identified had one or two alleles at low frequencies, often single observations, we present a full compilation of the genome positions, rs-numbers and genotypes of all tri-allelic SNPs detected by the 1000 Genomes project from the more detailed analyses it applied to Phase III sequence data. A total of 8,705 tri-allelic SNPs had overall heterozygosities (averaged across all 1000 Genomes populations) higher than the binary SNP maximum value of 0.5. Of these, 1,637 displayed the highest average heterozygosity values of 0.6-0.666. The most informative tri-allelic SNPs we identified were used to construct a large-scale human identification panel for massively parallel sequencing, designed for the identification of missing persons. The large-scale MPS identification panel comprised: 1,241 autosomal tri-allelic SNPs and 29 X tri-allelic SNPs (plus 46 microhaplotypes adapted for genotyping from reduced length sequences). Allele frequency estimates are detailed for African, European, South Asian and East Asian population groups plus the Peruvian population sampled by 1000 Genomes for the 1,270 tri-allelic SNPs of the final MPS panel. We describe the selection criteria, kinship simulation experiments and genomic analyses used to select the tri-allelic SNP components of the panel. Approximately 5 % of the tri-allelic SNPs selected for the large-scale MPS identification panel gave three-genotype patterns in single individual samples or discordant genotypes for genomic control DNAs. A likely explanation for some of these unreliably genotyped loci is that they map to multiple sites in the genome - highlighting the need for caution and detailed scrutiny of multiple-allele variant data when designing future forensic SNP panels, as such patterns can arise from common structural variation in the genome, such as segmental duplications.

Biyocoğrafik Soy Tahmini ve Adli Bilimlerde Kullanımı

Adli bilimlerde SNP (Single nucleotide polymorphism, tek nükleotid polimorfizm) markırları kimliklendirmede, fenotip belirlemede, nesep ve soy tayininde kullanılmaktadır. Biyocoğrafik soy tahmininde farklı coğrafik bölgelerde bulunan popülasyonlar arasındaki farklılıkları gösteren soy SNP markırları (AISNPs, Ancestry Informative SNP Markers) kullanılmaktadır. AISNP markırları ile bir kişinin biyocoğrafik orijini ve her biyocoğrafik bölgeden alınan genetik soy yüzdesi tespit edilebilir. Bu bilgiler adli bilimlerde bilinmeyen bir şüphelinin, felaket kurbanlarının veya kayıp kişilerin kimliklendirilmesinde kullanılabilir. Bu makalede biyocoğrafik soy kavramı, biyocoğrafik soy tahmininde kullanılan AISNPs panelleri, uygulama yöntemleri, kullanılan istatistiksel yöntemler ve güncel adli uygulamalar tartışılmıştır.

Forensic tri-allelic SNP genotyping using nanopore sequencing

The potential and current state-of-the-art of forensic SNP genotyping using nanopore sequencing was investigated with a panel of 16 tri-allelic single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), multiplexing five samples per sequencing run. The sample set consisted of three single-source human genomic reference control DNA samples and two GEDNAP samples, simulating casework samples. The primers for the multiplex SNP-loci PCR were taken from a study which researched their value in a forensic setting using conventional single-base extension technology. Workflows for multiplexed Oxford Nanopore Technologies' 1D and 1D2 sequencing were developed that provide correct genotyping of most SNP loci. Loci that are problematic for nanopore sequencing were characterized. When such loci are avoided, nanopore sequencing of forensic tri-allelic SNPs is technically feasible.

An automated independent workflow for the analysis of massively parallel sequence data from forensic SNP assays.

Illumina and Thermo Fisher Scientific have developed assays that permit the sequencing of forensically relevant single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), along with software to determine the associated genotypes. Currently there is no method to either independently confirm the genotypes determined using the manufacturer's software, or to compare genotypes and quality metrics among samples processed using both platforms. This paper outlines an automated workflow developed in CLC Genomics Workbench that permits accurate, fast and independent analysis of SNP sequence data from either platform. To facilitate the straightforward comparison of genotypes generated from both the manufacturer's software and the independent CLC analysis, a Python script was written. Data for a total of 323 forensically relevant ancestry, identity and phenotypic SNPs can be analyzed, and the resulting genotypes, coverage, quality flags and major allele frequencies are easily compared across samples and platforms.

HRM and SNaPshot as alternative forensic SNP genotyping methods

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) have been widely used in forensics for prediction of identity, biogeographical ancestry (BGA) and externally visible characteristics (EVCs). Single base extension (SBE) assays, most notably SNaPshot® (Thermo Fisher Scientific), are commonly used for forensic SNP genotyping as they can be employed on standard instrumentation in forensic laboratories (e.g. capillary electrophoresis). High resolution melt (HRM) analysis is an alternative method and is a simple, fast, single tube assay for low throughput SNP typing. This study compares HRM and SNaPshot®. HRM produced reproducible and concordant genotypes at 500 pg, however, difficulties were encountered when genotyping SNPs with high GC content in flanking regions and differentiating variants of symmetrical SNPs. SNaPshot® was reproducible at 100 pg and is less dependent on SNP choice. HRM has a shorter processing time in comparison to SNaPshot®, avoids post PCR contamination risk and has potential as a screening tool for many forensic applications.

Developmental validation of the MiSeq FGx Forensic Genomics System for Targeted Next Generation Sequencing in Forensic DNA Casework and Database Laboratories

Human DNA profiling using PCR at polymorphic short tandem repeat (STR) loci followed by capillary electrophoresis (CE) size separation and length-based allele typing has been the standard in the forensic community for over 20 years. Over the last decade, Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) matured rapidly, bringing modern advantages to forensic DNA analysis. The MiSeq FGx™ Forensic Genomics System, comprised of the ForenSeq™ DNA Signature Prep Kit, MiSeq FGx™ Reagent Kit, MiSeq FGx™ instrument and ForenSeq™ Universal Analysis Software, uses PCR to simultaneously amplify up to 231 forensic loci in a single multiplex reaction. Targeted loci include Amelogenin, 27 common, forensic autosomal STRs, 24 Y-STRs, 7 X-STRs and three classes of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The ForenSeq™ kit includes two primer sets: Amelogenin, 58 STRs and 94 identity informative SNPs (iiSNPs) are amplified using DNA Primer Set A (DPMA; 153 loci); if a laboratory chooses to generate investigative leads using DNA Primer Set B, amplification is targeted to the 153 loci in DPMA plus 22 phenotypic informative (piSNPs) and 56 biogeographical ancestry SNPs (aiSNPs). High-resolution genotypes, including detection of intra-STR sequence variants, are semi-automatically generated with the ForenSeq™ software. This system was subjected to developmental validation studies according to the 2012 Revised SWGDAM Validation Guidelines.A two-step PCR first amplifies the target forensic STR and SNP loci (PCR1); unique, sample-specific indexed adapters or “barcodes” are attached in PCR2. Approximately 1736 ForenSeq™ reactions were analyzed. Studies include DNA substrate testing (cotton swabs, FTA cards, filter paper), species studies from a range of nonhuman organisms, DNA input sensitivity studies from 1ng down to 7.8pg, two-person human DNA mixture testing with three genotype combinations, stability analysis of partially degraded DNA, and effects of five commonly encountered PCR inhibitors. Calculations from ForenSeq™ STR and SNP repeatability and reproducibility studies (1ng template) indicate 100.0% accuracy of the MiSeq FGx™ System in allele calling relative to CE for STRs (1260 samples), and >99.1% accuracy relative to bead array typing for SNPs (1260 samples for iiSNPs, 310 samples for aiSNPs and piSNPs), with >99.0% and >97.8% precision, respectively. Call rates of >99.0% were observed for all STRs and SNPs amplified with both ForenSeq™ primer mixes. Limitations of the MiSeq FGx™ System are discussed. Results described here demonstrate that the MiSeq FGx™ System meets forensic DNA quality assurance guidelines with robust, reliable, and reproducible performance on samples of various quantities and qualities.

Genetic markers for massively parallel sequencing in forensics

Massively parallel sequencing (MPS, aka NGS) is revolutionizing the field of forensics. Existing forensic short tandem repeat polymorphisms (STRPs) are more informative when typed by MPS. MPS also allows STRPs and forensic SNP panels to be multiplexed to add information, on ancestry and phenotype, to the identification information from STRPs. MPS also makes possible microhaplotypes: small segments of DNA (<300bp) with two or more single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) unambiguously defining three or more haplotypes. Because a single sequence read can cover the expanse of the microhaplotype, these loci become phase-known codominant systems. The multiple alleles (haplotypes) provide much more information than a single SNP for the same effort. Data now available on 129 loci characterized on 55 populations from around the globe demonstrate that the majority of these microhaplotypes appear to be useful in forensics for individual identification, ancestry inference, estimating relationships, and especially deconvoluting mixtures.

Pacifiplex: an ancestry-informative SNP panel centred on Australia and the Pacific region

The analysis of human population variation is an area of considerable interest in the forensic, medical genetics and anthropological fields. Several forensic single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) assays provide ancestry-informative genotypes in sensitive tests designed to work with limited DNA samples, including a 34-SNP multiplex differentiating African, European and East Asian ancestries. Although assays capable of differentiating Oceanian ancestry at a global scale have become available, this study describes markers compiled specifically for differentiation of Oceanian populations. A sensitive multiplex assay, termed Pacifiplex, was developed and optimized in a small-scale test applicable to forensic analyses. The Pacifiplex assay comprises 29 ancestry-informative marker SNPs (AIM-SNPs) selected to complement the 34-plex test, that in a combined set distinguish Africans, Europeans, East Asians and Oceanians. Nine Pacific region study populations were genotyped with both SNP assays, then compared to four reference population groups from the HGDP-CEPH human diversity panel. STRUCTURE analyses estimated population cluster membership proportions that aligned with the patterns of variation suggested for each study population’s currently inferred demographic histories. Aboriginal Taiwanese and Philippine samples indicated high East Asian ancestry components, Papua New Guinean and Aboriginal Australians samples were predominantly Oceanian, while other populations displayed cluster patterns explained by the distribution of divergence amongst Melanesians, Polynesians and Micronesians. Genotype data from Pacifiplex and 34-plex tests is particularly well suited to analysis of Australian Aboriginal populations and when combined with Y and mitochondrial DNA variation will provide a powerful set of markers for ancestry inference applied to modern Australian demographic profiles. On a broader geographic scale, Pacifiplex adds highly informative data for inferring the ancestry of individuals from Oceanian populations. The sensitivity of Pacifiplex enabled successful genotyping of population samples from 50-year-old serum samples obtained from several Oceanian regions that would otherwise be unlikely to produce useful population data. This indicates tests primarily developed for forensic ancestry analysis also provide an important contribution to studies of populations where useful samples are in limited supply.

A novel system for forensic SNP analysis through PCR–ligase detection reaction

With the advantages of lower mutation rates and improved analysis of the degraded or aged samples, single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers has been considered as supplementary to the STRs. Consequently, a robust, simple and cost effective technique for SNP typing is essential to analyze a large number of SNPs. Ligase detection reaction (LDR) could detect a SNP on CE platform through the ability of DNA ligase which can seal the nick junction formed by oligonucleotides hybridized to the flank region of target SNP. Here we purposed a prestudy to set up a 8 Y-SNPs (M9, M74, M35, M95, M110, M89, M13, M20) multiplex panel for forensic application through PCR–ligase detection reaction (LDR) system. Primers of 8 loci were designed for multiplexed PCR. According to the sequence around the SNP site, three LDR probes were designed for each SNP including one common fluorescent labeled probe and two allele specific probes different in size with mismatching bases at the 3’ end. PCR–LDR products were profiled through ABI3130 Genetic Analyzer. A set of 8 Y-SNP could be profiled through two multiplexed PCR and two multiplexed LDR. Even though the number of markers in the current system is limited, when fully developed, it can easily be multiplied more SNPs and yield a greater power of discrimination. Our study indicated that the PCR-LDR could provide a robust, simple and cost effective multiplexed SNP typing method for forensic cases in the future.

Tetra-allelic SNPs: Informative forensic markers compiled from public whole-genome sequence data

Multiple-allele single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are potentially useful for forensic DNA analysis as they can provide more discrimination power than normal binary SNPs. In addition, the presence in a profile of more than two alleles per marker provides a clearer indication of mixed DNA than assessments of imbalanced signals in the peak pairs of binary SNPs. Using the 1000 Genomes Phase III human variant data release of 2014 as the starting point, this study collated 961 tetra-allelic SNPs that pass minimum sequence quality thresholds and where four separate nucleotide substitution alleles were detected. Although most of these loci had three of the four alleles in combined frequencies of 2% or less, 160 had high heterozygosities with 50 exceeding those of ‘ideal’ 0.5:0.5 binary SNPs. From this set of most polymorphic tetra-allelic SNPs, we identified markers most informative for forensic purposes and explored these loci in detail. Subsets of the most polymorphic tetra-allelic SNPs will make useful additions to current panels of forensic identification SNPs and ancestry-informative SNPs. The 24 most discriminatory tetra-allelic SNPs were estimated to detect more than two alleles in at least one marker per profile in 99.9% of mixtures of African contributors. In European contributor mixtures 99.4% of profiles would show multiple allele patterns, but this drops to 92.6% of East Asian contributor mixtures due to reduced levels of polymorphism for the 24 SNPs in this population group.

A SNaPshot of next generation sequencing for forensic SNP analysis.

Forensic phenotyping can provide useful intelligence regarding the biogeographical ancestry (BGA) and externally visible characteristics (EVCs) of the donor of an evidentiary sample. Currently, single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) based inference of BGA and EVCs is performed most commonly using SNaPshot(®), a single base extension (SBE) assay. However, a single SNaPshot multiplex PCR is limited to 30-40 SNPs. Next generation sequencing (NGS) offers the potential to genotype hundreds to thousands of SNPs from multiple samples in a single experimental run. The PCR multiplexes from five SNaPshot assays (SNPforID 52plex, SNPforID 34plex, Eurasiaplex, IrisPlex and an unpublished BGA assay) were applied to three different DNA template amounts (0.1, 0.2 and 0.3 ng) in three samples (9947A and 007 control DNAs and a male donor). The pooled PCR amplicons containing 136 unique SNPs were sequenced using Life Technologies' Ion Torrent™ PGM system. Approximately 72 Mb of sequence was generated from two 10 Mb Ion 314™ v1 chips. Accurate genotypes were readily obtained from all three template amounts. Of a total of 408 genotypes, 395 (97%) were fully concordant with SNaPshot across all three template amounts. Of those genotypes discordant with SNaPshot, six Ion Torrent sequences (1.5%) were fully concordant with Sanger sequencing across the three template amounts. Seven SNPs (1.7%) were either discordant between template amounts or discordant with Sanger sequencing. Sequence coverage observed in the negative control, and, allele coverage variation for heterozygous genotypes highlights the need to establish a threshold for background levels of sequence output and heterozygous balance. This preliminary study of the Ion Torrent PGM system has demonstrated considerable potential for use in forensic DNA analyses as a low to medium throughput NGS platform using established SNaPshot assays.

Development of a forensic identity SNP panel for Indonesia.

Genetic markers included in forensic identity panels must exhibit Hardy-Weinberg and linkage equilibrium (HWE and LE). "Universal" panels designed for global use can fail these tests in regional jurisdictions exhibiting high levels of genetic differentiation such as the Indonesian archipelago. This is especially the case where a single DNA database is required for allele frequency estimates to calculate random match probabilities (RMPs) and associated likelihood ratios (LRs). A panel of 65 single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and a reduced set of 52 SNPs have been selected from 15 Indonesian subpopulations in the HUGO Pan Asian SNP database using a SNP selection strategy that could be applied to any panel of forensic identity markers. The strategy consists of four screening steps: (1) application of a G test for HWE; (2) ranking for high heterozygosity; (3) selection for LE; and (4) selection for low inbreeding depression. SNPs in our Indonesian panel perform well in comparison to some other universal SNP and short tandem repeat (STR) panels as measured by Fisher's exact test for HWE and LE and Wright's F statistics.

Eurasiaplex: A forensic SNP assay for differentiating European and South Asian ancestries

We have selected a set of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with the specific aim of differentiating European and South Asian ancestries. The SNPs were combined into a 23-plex SNaPshot primer extension assay: Eurasiaplex, designed to complement an existing 34-plex forensic ancestry test with both marker sets occupying well-spaced genomic positions, enabling their combination as single profile submissions to the Bayesian Snipper forensic ancestry inference system. We analyzed the ability of Eurasiaplex plus 34plex SNPs to assign ancestry to a total 1648 profiles from 16 European, 7 Middle East, 13 Central-South Asian and 21 East Asian populations. Ancestry assignment likelihoods were estimated from Snipper using training sets of five-group data (three Eurasian groups, East Asian and African genotypes) and four-group data (Middle East genotypes removed). Five-group differentiations gave assignment success of 91% for NW European populations, 72% for Middle East populations and 39% for Central-South Asian populations, indicating Middle East individuals are not reliably differentiated from either Europeans or Central-South Asians. Four-group differentiations provided markedly improved assignment success rates of 97% for most continental Europeans tested (excluding Turkish and Adygei at the far eastern edge of Europe) and 95% for Central-South Asians, despite applying a probability threshold for the highest likelihood ratio above '100 times more likely'. As part of the assessment of the sensitivity of Eurasiaplex to analyze challenging forensic material we detail Eurasiaplex and 34-plex SNP typing to infer ancestry of a cranium recovered from the sea, achieving 82% SNP genotype completeness. Therefore, Eurasiaplex provides an informative and forensically robust approach to the differentiation of European and South Asian ancestries amongst Eurasian populations.

A DNA microarray system for forensic SNP analysis

Forensic DNA analysis is routinely performed using polymorphic short tandem repeat (STR) markers. However, for degraded or minute DNA samples, analysis of autosomal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in short fragments might be more successful. Furthermore, sequencing of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is often performed on highly degraded or scarce samples due to the high copy number of mtDNA in each cell. Due to the increasing number of complete mtDNA genome sequences available, the limited discrimination power of an mtDNA analysis, may be increased by analysis of coding region polymorphisms in addition to the non-coding variation. Since sequence analysis of the coding region would require more material than generally present in forensic samples, an alternative SNP analysis approach is required. We have developed a one-colour microarray-based SNP detection system for limited forensic materials. The method is based on minisequencing in solution prior to hybridisation to universal tag-arrays. In a first outline of a forensic chip, a combination of 12 nuclear and 21 mitochondrial SNP markers are analysed simultaneously. The mitochondrial markers on the chip are polymorphisms within the hypervariable region as well as in the coding region. Even though the number of markers in the current system is limited, it can easily be extended to yield a greater power of discrimination. When fully developed, microarray analysis provides a promising system for efficient sensitive SNP analysis of forensic samples in the future.