This study delves into whether factors influencing credit spreads differ between sukuk and bonds within the vibrant Indonesian secondary market. The research leverages unbalanced panel data encompassing 2017-2023, meticulously obtained from Thomson Reuters Eikon and CEIC. To extract meaningful insights, a Fixed-Effect Model analysis is employed, a robust technique for handling this type of data. The study further conducts a partial analysis to recognize the potential heterogeneity within the sukuk market. This analysis explores explicitly whether the factors driving yield spread exhibit variations between sukuk structured under the ijarah and mudharabah principles. The study's core finding challenges the notion that investors perceive sukuk as a perfect substitute for conventional bonds in terms of the risk-return profile. This is evidenced by the high degree of similarity in the factors that influence the credit spreads of both instruments. However, a fascinating discovery emerges from the partial analysis. It reveals that mudharabah sukuk stands out as a distinct product within the Indonesian secondary debt market compared to its ijarah counterpart. This finding warrants further investigation into the specific characteristics of mudarabah sukuk that contribute to its distinctiveness.
Read full abstract