Fire safety in university hostels is a critical concern, particularly in developing countries where resources and awareness may be limited. This study evaluates the effectiveness of fire safety measures in student hostels at Caleb University, Lagos, highlighting the current state of fire safety protocols and identifying areas for improvement. Employing a descriptive research design, the study gathered data from 329 respondents, including students and hostel staff, through structured questionnaires and semi-structured interviews. The findings reveal that while basic fire safety measures such as fire extinguishers are present, awareness and confidence in fire safety protocols among students are alarmingly low. A significant percentage of respondents (61.8%) expressed doubts about the effectiveness of existing measures, and only 6.7% reported participating in fire drills or training sessions. Furthermore, the study identified critical weaknesses in the current fire safety protocols, with 56.8% of students having experienced fire-related incidents during their residence. The research underscores the necessity for regular fire safety training, improved equipment maintenance, and enhanced communication of emergency procedures to ensure the safety and preparedness of hostel occupants. Recommendations include implementing mandatory fire drills, increasing the number of safety equipment, and collaborating with local fire authorities to develop comprehensive fire safety programs. This study contributes to the existing literature on fire safety in university settings and emphasizes the need for effective strategies tailored to the unique challenges faced by educational institutions.