Teachers and parents are well aware of the benefits of reading out loud to children, especially young children (Allington 2001; Davenport et al. 2004). Our kindergarten and 1st-grade classrooms are filled with the lovely sound of teachers reading books out loud, children reading books to themselves, and guest readers, like the school principal and students' parents, being invited to read to the class. The image of little 5-year-olds snuggled up in the school library on cozy bean bags, listening to favorite stories, is quite familiar to us. But what about those great big, hunkin', 9- and 10-year-olds? You know, the ones who are taller than their teacher. The 4th-grade kids for whom, for many, the early signs of puberty are already beginning. Surely, they're too old to snuggle up and read with an adult? And furthermore, if they aren't fluent readers by 4th grade, don't they need major reading intervention? And if they're adequate readers, shouldn't we just focus on those needing more help? Moreover, shouldn't individual reading with 4th graders take place at a sensible school desk or table with a wide berth between the child and the teacher, or even more comfortably on a computer, where serious intensive instruction can occur? Or should it? Christine Finnan asks educators to consider that elementary age students have needs for nurturing and caring that are unique to their developmental stage. In her book, The Upper Elementary Years: Ensuring Success in Grades 3-6, Finnan notes that many 4th-and 5th-grade classrooms are significantly different from primary-grade classroom environments. More specifically, students typically experience a classroom environment that shifts its focus from nurturing children to teaching content (2009, p. 122). This shift may be in direct conflict with the student's continued developmental needs for nurturing. According to Finnan, upper elementary children have rather basic desires: accomplishment and affirmation, belonging and connection; academic, social and physical engagement (p. 99). One example of how 4th-grade students may benefit from snuggling up with a buddy to read is taking place in a rural South Carolina public school. The Cool Cats reading buddy program is a partnership between the College of Charleston's School of Education, Health, and Human Performance and Cainhoy Elementary School in Huger, South Carolina. Cainhoy is a rural, Title I, public school where 96% of the students are African American and 88% qualify for free and reduced-price lunch. In this pilot program, preservice teachers from the College of Charleston are recruited and earn a stipend to travel to the rural school and read, one on one, with 4th-grade students, most of whom are struggling readers. Over the seven-week sessions, there is no articulated reading program, no prescribed curriculum, not even one uniform book that is used. In addition, all 4th-grade students are invited to participate. Students accompany their buddies to the library, pick a cozy spot, and snuggle up and read. The only instructions are for 4th graders and college-age students to split in half the time spent reading out loud. Sounds easy, right? But does it work? Consistently, after each seven-week reading buddy session, 4th-grade students raised their oral reading fluency (ORF), as measured by the Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Scale (DIBELS), an average of just over 20 words per minute. The results of this pilot are noteworthy; and upon reflection, the individual attention, physical connection, and human interaction may be the components that contributed to improving students' reading scores. Moreover, when the two 4th-grade teachers reflected on the program, they described children who wanted to come to school on reading buddy day and who valued the connections with their buddies. TABLE 1. Comparison of ORF scores with Reading Buddies and Successmaker Computer Program Intervention Type Beginning ORF Ending ORF for 7 Weeks (words per minute) (words per minute) Change Reading Buddies 80. …
Read full abstract