Eucalyptus Globulus Plantations Research Articles

Effects of partial defoliation on closed canopy Eucalyptus globulus Labilladière: Growth, biomass allocation and carbohydrates

Herbivory caused by leaf-eating insects continues to be a severe risk to forest trees and forest stands. Besides quantifying the extent of defoliation, the quantification of the trees’ response to the loss of biomass is a challenge to plant ecologists and foresters alike, and an important precondition for the application of appropriate silvicultural measures. While many defoliation studies target small trees as model systems, little is known about the effect of defoliation on larger trees. In the present study, we investigated the effects of 45% removal of leaf area on growth, biomass allocation and carbohydrates of 13m tall, four-year-old, plantation Eucalyptus globulus Labill. in southern Tasmania. Responses were measured in three crown zones (lower, middle, upper) over a period of 11 months. Height increment was unaffected by defoliation, but diameter increment was significantly reduced 155 days after treatment. Defoliation treatment had no effect on stem volume and biomass partitioning compared with the control treatment. Trees responded to defoliation by decreased branch senescence in the lower crown, greater leaf area development in the mid crown and increased specific leaf area. Defoliation reduced concentration of soluble sugars (SS) in foliage by 22% and the pools of SS in the coarse roots by 34%. Decrease in root SS was only observed in 10–15mm diameter class and the rootball. We concluded that this four-year-old E. globulus stands with a closed canopy was able to tolerate a single, partial artificial defoliation event, which is similarly observed with younger trees.

Influence of Eucalyptus globulus plantation growth on water table levels and low flows in a small catchment

Summary In a catchment with a shallow water table, switching land use from fodder maize and pasture to Eucalyptus globulus plantation altered dry season hydrology: the water table fell more rapidly each year, and the concomitant decrease in discharge soon led to the stream drying up every year. During the first 3 years of growth, the rate of fall of the water table, S , remained stable in spite of rapid stand growth, which is attributed to transpiration in the catchment being dominated by the background vegetation during this period. Between the third and sixth years, S increased linearly with foliage biomass W s (calculated with the 3-PG model as a proxy for the transpiration capacity of the stand). Subsequently, the levelling off of W s as the result of canopy cover reaching 100% was reflected by similar behaviour of S . The final values of S , in the range 4.5–4.9 mm day −1 , were just over double the initial values of around 2.2 mm day −1 . The influence of plantation with E. globulus on water reserves and discharge needs to be taken into account by catchment management.

Lignin composition and structure in young versus adult Eucalyptus globulus plants.

Lignin changes during plant growth were investigated in a selected Eucalyptus globulus clone. The lignin composition and structure were studied in situ by a new procedure enabling the acquisition of two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance (2D-NMR) spectra on wood gels formed in the NMR tube as well as by analytical pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. In addition, milled-wood lignins were isolated and analyzed by 2D-NMR, pyrolysis-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, and thioacidolysis. The data indicated that p-hydroxyphenyl and guaiacyl units are deposited at the earlier stages, whereas the woods are enriched in syringyl (S) lignin during late lignification. Wood 2D-NMR showed that β-O-4' and resinol linkages were predominant in the eucalypt lignin, whereas other substructures were present in much lower amounts. Interestingly, open β-1' structures could be detected in the isolated lignins. Phenylcoumarans and cinnamyl end groups were depleted with age, spirodienone abundance increased, and the main substructures (β-O-4' and resinols) were scarcely modified. Thioacidolysis revealed a higher predominance of S units in the ether-linked lignin than in the total lignin and, in agreement with NMR, also indicated that resinols are the most important nonether linkages. Dimer analysis showed that most of the resinol-type structures comprised two S units (syringaresinol), the crossed guaiacyl-S resinol appearing as a minor substructure and pinoresinol being totally absent. Changes in hemicelluloses were also shown by the 2D-NMR spectra of the wood gels without polysaccharide isolation. These include decreases of methyl galacturonosyl, arabinosyl, and galactosyl (anomeric) signals, assigned to pectin and related neutral polysaccharides, and increases of xylosyl (which are approximately 50% acetylated) and 4-O-methylglucuronosyl signals.

Fungal species diversity in juvenile and adult leaves of Eucalyptus globulus from plantations affected by Mycosphaerella leaf disease

In recent years, Mycosphaerella leaf disease (MLD) has become very common in Eucalyptus globulus plantations in Galicia, northwest Spain. The aetiology of MLD is complex and is associated with several species of Mycosphaerella and Teratosphaeria. A survey of the fungal mycobiota associated with juvenile and adult leaves and with leaf litter of the same trees in MLD-affected plantations was made. The goal was to identify pathogens and endophytes, to determine whether the mycobiota of each leaf type differed and whether leaf litter might be a reservoir of MLD inoculum. Fungi belonging to 113 different species were isolated from the leaves of juvenile and adult trees sampled at 10 locations; 81 species occurred in juvenile and 65 in adult leaves. The average number of species obtained from juvenile leaves was significantly greater (P > 0.01) compared to adult leaves. This difference suggested that juvenile leaves are not only more susceptible to a group of pathogens, but to a wide range of fungi. Therefore, a general resistance mechanism might be lacking or be less effective in juvenile than in adult leaves. Several pathogenic species were identified in both leaf types. Leaf litter and living leaf mycobiotas were very different. However, some of the species they shared were MLD pathogens, suggesting that leaf litter could contribute to the inoculum of MLD.

Application of QuickBird and aerial imagery to detect Pinus radiata in remnant vegetation

AbstractThe invasion of Pinus radiata from long‐term established plantations is contributing to the degradation of fragmented and isolated remnants of native vegetation. Within the south‐east of South Australia, the 20 vegetation communities that occur within 500 m of a plantation edge are at risk, including nine state threatened communities. To plan effective mitigation strategies, the current extent and distribution of P. radiata needs to be ascertained. High spatial resolution, multispectral QuickBird imagery and aerial photography were used to classify P. radiata within eucalypt and acacia woodlands, melaleuca shrubland, modified pasture and an Eucalyptus globulus plantation. Unsupervised classification of aerial photography gave the best result showing reasonable conformity with the observed distribution of P. radiata at the site scale. However, the 9.4 ± 13.5 (SD) cover classified in the quadrats sampled for the accuracy assessment exceeded the 1.4 ± 2.4 (SD) P. radiata cover determined from an independent dataset. Only 30.1 ± 37.9% (SD) of trees within the quadrats and 9.40 ± 13.49% (SD) of their foliage cover were classified. Trees detected by partial classification of canopy were positively correlated with both tree height and canopy diameter. Overall, the low detection rates were attributed to insufficient spectral resolution. Using higher resolution imagery, together with an object‐based image analysis or combination of multispectral and airborne digital image classification, restricted to large emergent adult trees using LiDAR analysis, is likely to improve adult P. radiata detection accuracy.

Effects of defoliation by Eucalyptus weevil, Gonipterus scutellatus, and chrysomelid beetles on growth of Eucalyptus globulus in southwestern Australia

Plantations of Eucalyptus globulus in southwestern Australia are defoliated by Eucalyptus weevil, Gonipterus scutellatus, and a complex of chrysomelid and scarab beetles, yet there is no information on the impact of beetle defoliation to tree growth in southwestern Australia. To address this shortcoming, we used insect exclusion trials, to compare growth of insecticide treated (and thus relatively undamaged) trees with untreated (and thus defoliated) trees to determine whether defoliation by G. scutellatus and other beetles reduced the growth and harvest volume of E. globulus trees. Our results showed some evidence of beetle defoliation reducing growth of E. globulus. Mean defoliation levels of the growing tip of untreated trees ranged from 18% to 33% across the duration of the study and were significantly greater than mean defoliation levels of 5–16% on insecticide treated trees. Seasonal peaks in defoliation of 30–80% to the growing tip of untreated trees were recorded between late spring and early autumn. The greatest impact of defoliation on tree growth was evident during the 2.5 year period of insect exclusion, when higher relative growth rates were recorded for insecticide treated trees, which were significantly different from relative growth rates of untreated trees at two of the four plantations. However, our results showed only a limited impact of beetle defoliation on the total volume at harvest. Initially small trees tended to suffer more severe defoliation than initially large trees. Effects of insect exclusion treatment on harvest volume were modified by the initial tree size and the relationship between the initial tree size and levels of defoliation.

Ocorrência de Ctenarytaina eucalypti (Maskell) (Hemiptera: Psyllidae) e seu inimigo natural Psyllaephagus pilosus Noyes (Hymenoptera: Encyrtidae) em Eucalyptus globulus no Rio Grande do Sul

Eucalyptus are hosts of several psyllid species. Among them, Ctenarytaina eucalypti (Maskell) is considered the most harmful to Eucalyptus globulus plantations. In Brazil, this pest has been observed in the state of Parana, and in 2005, it was found causing damage to plantations of E. globulus in Arroio Grande and Piratini cities, RS. The monophagous endoparasitoid Psyllaephagus pilosus Noyes was also observed parasitizing nymphs of C. eucalypti. This parasitoid has been shown to be highly efficient in controlling this psyllid species, making unnecessary the use of any other control method.

Relations of sugar composition and δ13C in phloem sap to growth and physiological performance of Eucalyptus globulus (Labill)

We characterized differences in carbon isotopic content (delta(13)C) and sugar concentrations in phloem exudates from Eucalyptus globulus (Labill) plantations across a rainfall gradient in south-western Australia. Phloem sap delta(13)C and sugar concentrations varied with season and annual rainfall. Annual bole growth was negatively related to phloem sap delta(13)C during summer, suggesting a water limitation, yet was positively related in winter. We conclude that when water is abundant, variations in carboxylation rates become significant to overall growth. Concentrations of sucrose in phloem sap varied across sites by up to 600 mm, and raffinose by 300 mm. These compounds play significant roles in maintaining osmotic balance and facilitating carbon movement into the phloem, and their relative abundances contribute strongly to overall delta(13)C of phloem sap. Taken together, the delta(13)C and concentrations of specific sugars in phloem sap provide significant insights to functions supporting growth at the tree, site and landscape scale.

Observed and modelled leaf area index in Eucalyptus globulus plantations: tests of optimality and equilibrium hypotheses

This paper reports on variation in leaf area index (L) in five Eucalyptus globulus Labill. plantations in response to application of nitrogen, thinning at age 2 years and variation in climate wetness index (the ratio of rainfall to potential evaporation). Observed L is compared with: (i) L predicted to optimize net primary productivity for a given average annual temperature, annual water use and potential evaporation (L(opt)) and (ii) L calculated as a linear function of climate wetness index (L(eq)). L peaked in fertilized plots at between 4 and 5 years of age or immediately after canopy closure. The value of L from canopy closure to age 8 years was not strongly related to annual rainfall or climate wetness index. At two sites with total soil nitrogen <1.2 mg g(-)(1), L in fertilized plots was about two units greater than in unfertilized plots. This difference persisted until measurements ended in 2004 when the trees were 8 years old. The L of plots thinned to 300 and 600 stems ha(-)(1) at age 2 years recovered quickly and was not significantly different from L in unthinned plots when the trees were 8 years old. L(opt) was a good predictor of the leaf area index of 8-year-old plots of E. globulus when nitrogen and phosphorus were non-limiting (model efficiency (EF) was 0.5). For the same plots, L(eq) underestimated observed L by an average of two units, and the model efficiency was low (-3.25). Data from two nitrogen-limited sites demonstrated that for fertilized plots L(opt) (EF = 0.6) was a much better predictor of L than L(eq) (EF = -3.36). At the same sites, L(eq) (EF = 0.42) was a better model for predicting L of unfertilized plots than L(opt) (-3.59). These results provide evidence that comparing observed L with L(opt) can identify stands limited by factors other than growing climate.

Impact of harvest residues, fertilisers and N-fixing plants on growth and nutritional status of young Eucalyptus globulus plantations, under Mediterranean conditions

Growth and nutritional status of young plants of Eucalyptus were assessed in a field trial, under different scenarios of harvest residue management and nutrient availability. Treatments were as follows: incorporation of harvest residues into the soil by harrowing (I); I with N fertiliser application (IF); I with leguminous, Lupinus luteus L., seeding (IL); removal of harvest residues (R); R with N fertiliser application (RF); R with leguminous seeding (RL); distribution of harvest residues on the soil surface (S); S with N fertiliser application (SF). Treatments were replicated four times in four blocks with a fully randomised design. Tree growth (height and diameter at breast height) was measured and understory biomass destructively recorded. Tree nutritional status was assessed by foliar analysis (N, Ca, Mg, P, K and leaf area). Significant differences in growth between I, R and S treatments were only detected at early stage. Intercropping with Lupinus decreased tree growth during the early phase, but after 5 years growth was similar to that measured in the I and R treatments. Application of fertiliser enhanced tree growth especially when harvest residues were retained on the soil surface. Combining incorporation of harvest residues with fertiliser application (IF) was the best option to increase tree growth, which was significantly greater than in the R and S. Initially, leaf N was positively affected by the leguminous (RL and IL), but, after the first fertiliser application (1 year after planting), greater N was observed in the IF, RF and SF, the difference decreasing gradually over the following years.

Application of the 3PG forest growth model to a Eucalyptus globulus plantation in Northwest Spain

This paper presents an assessment of the ability of the 3PG process-based model to simulate height (h) and diameter at breast height (DBH) growth in three plots located in a Eucalyptus globulus plantation on the Atlantic coast of Galicia (Northwest Spain). The obtained results show how this model estimates adequately height (h) and DBH growth, and determination coefficients (R 2) between observed data and data predicted by the model are always higher than 0.97, root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.45–1.05 cm in DBH and 0.46–0.85 in h, and a model efficiency (EF) close to 1 (0.98–0.99). In order to improve the results predicted by the model, we propose modifying the nS and fullCanAge parameter values given by default so as to adjust growth rates in the plantation to the weather conditions in the site. The ability of the model to discriminate growth rates in the three plots must be noted, even when plots are located in the same plantation and they only show differences in aspects related to site factors. Given the obtained results in the three plots used in this study, its simplicity and the small number of parameters needed as input data, the 3PG model stands out as a very useful tool for forest plantation management.

Evaluation of a process-based ecosystem model for long-term biomass and stand development of Eucalyptus globulus plantations

Versatile process-oriented ecosystem models are discussed as promising tools for the analyses of ecosystem services beyond wood yield, such as catchment water yield, sequestration of carbon and greenhouse gas balances. However, long-term yield simulation is often regarded as a weakness of such versatile models. In this context, we present a multiple response evaluation of the modular, process-based forest growth model MoBiLE-PDT based on mensurational data from 38 permanent sample plots in commercial Eucalyptus globulus plantations in Australia followed from establishment to 8 years of stand age. MoBiLE-PDT is based on the PnET-N-DNDC model and considers nitrogen availability and drought stress dynamically in dependence on tree and stand properties as well as on climate and deposition. New tree dimensions are calculated directly from carbon allocated to sapwood and mortality is derived from stand density. Towards the end of the rotation, model efficiency E was 0.58 for stand volume (m3 ha−1) and 0.54 for aboveground biomass (t C ha−1). In a comparison with similar forest growth models evaluated against the same data only one had a better model efficiency, whereas MoBiLE-PDT was the most versatile model for the analyses of ecosystem services. Due to its modular structure, further model extensions for more ecological applications are easily possible.

AFLP analysis of somaclonal variations in Eucalyptus globulus

DNA variations of forty-eight Eucalyptus globulus plants, regenerated by successive culture from seven different explants were assessed by AFLP analysis using 18 primer combinations. At least one variation showed 66.7 % of the analyzed plants, and the numbers of polymorphic bands per plant ranged from 1 to 22. The proportion of polymorphic fragments did not correlate with the numbers of the regenerated plants. However, the more times of successive culture were done the more of polymorphic bands were found within the groups. On average, between 97.39 and 99.88 % of all fragments were shared within the same group. AMOVA analysis showed 39.33 % of the variation was found among the accessions that originated from different calli while 60.67 % was from same calli.

Managing productivity and drought risk in Eucalyptus globulus plantations in south-western Australia

More than 2.5 million ha of Eucalyptus globulus are now planted across the globe including approximately 500 000 ha in southern Australia. In this region average annual rainfall has declined since 1960 and this trend is predicted to continue in the coming decades. E. globulus is a premium species for paper manufacture and grows well under moderate seasonal water stress. The traits that underpin this rapid early growth also make the species vulnerable to prolonged water stress. We established nitrogen rate and nitrogen-by-stocking experiments in five 2-year-old E. globulus plantations along a climatic gradient in south-western Australia. We measured volume growth, predawn leaf water potential and leaf area index over 7 years or until the plantations were 9 years old. These data were used to explore the relationship between growth and water stress, to understand the mechanistic basis for the relationship and to identify best-bet management strategies for E. globulus plantations in southern Australia. Nearly all of the variation in volume growth rate between sites could be explained by a combination of climate wetness index and soil depth. There was a significant growth response to nitrogen at two low rainfall and one high rainfall site. There was no growth response to nitrogen on sites where total soil nitrogen in the top 0.1 m of soil was more than 1.9 mg g −1 and a very rapid increase in relative growth response below this threshold. The observed growth response to nitrogen was associated with an increase in water stress and on at least one site increased mortality. Matching the supply of nutrients to demand will maximise the growth at any site but this may increase the risk of drought death at water-limited sites. This will be exacerbated if forecasted changes in the climate of southern Australia are realised. Thinning to 600 stems ha −1 significantly reduced the level of water stress experienced by E. globulus in Western Australia without significantly affecting end of rotation stand volume compared to unthinned stands. These results indicate that for a range of sites in south-western Australia a final stocking density of 600 stems ha −1 coupled with application of fertiliser to maximise growth will minimise risk without sacrificing any of the site potential.

Process-based modelling of the severity and impact of foliar pest attack on eucalypt plantation productivity under current and future climates

We examined the impacts of a defoliating pest, Mycosphaerella leaf disease (MLD), on rotation-length Eucalyptus globulus plantation productivity under current and future climates by using the ecoclimatic species niche model CLIMEX to generate severity, frequency and seasonality scenarios for MLD for specific E. globulus sites. These scenarios were used as inputs to the process-based forest productivity model CABALA. Climate projections from two global climate models were used to drive CABALA with either no or full acclimation of photosynthesis to elevated atmospheric CO 2 assumed. In addition we varied water and nitrogen availability to examine the impacts of different severities of MLD on plantation productivity across environmental gradients. We predicted that, under current climatic conditions, rotation-length reductions in V associated with MLD damage would be no greater than 12%, with an across-site average of 6%. There was considerable between-site variation in predictions that reflected variation in site productivity. Under future climates, we predicted that MLD may reduce rotation length V by as much as 42%, although the reduction averaged across all sites was 11%. The predicted impact of MLD on V was greatest at lower productivity sites. The importance of N and water availability in recovery following MLD attack was highlighted. Uncertainty in model predictions revolved around the climate models used and assumptions of degree of photosynthetic acclimation to elevated CO 2. Large differences in predicted impact of MLD were associated with this uncertainty. Our results suggest that the effects of defoliation due to pests on plantation productivity should not be ignored when considering future management of forest plantations. The approach developed here provides managers with a tool to appraise risk and examine possible impacts of management interventions designed to reduce or manage risk.

Impacts of Eucalyptus globulus plantations on Atlantic streams: changes in invertebrate density and shredder traits

Eucalyptus globulus plantations are spreading in the northern areas of the Iberian Peninsula, substituting natural deciduous riparian vegetation. Whereas laboratory studies with leaf litter of this species have found detri- mental effects on detritivorous species, fi eld studies did not support a strong negative effect. Hence, we compared taxon richness, density and biomass of macroinvertebrate assemblages inhabiting streams fl owing through eucalypt plantations with those fl owing through native oak forest. Moreover, we compared traits of leaf eating macroinver- tebrates (shredders) between the two types of streams. Streams fl owing through eucalypt plantations had lower taxon richness, density and biomass of total invertebrates (and particularly of shredders) compared to those fl owing through native forests. Large shredder taxa, such as Echinogammarus spp. & Limnephilidae, showed a signifi cant negative response (in terms of abundance and biomass) to eucalypt cover whereas smaller taxa displayed similar distribution patterns in both habitat types. The grazer Habroleptoides sp. was the only taxon displaying higher den- sities in eucalypt sites, which might be explained by the reduction of competition/predation by other large shred- ders. Shredders at eucalypt sites showed the following traits: small maximum body size, short life cycles, few re- production cycles per year, active dispersal, and ability to feed on food of lower quality. The shredder assemblages in the eucalypt sites shared similarities with those typical of locations where production is limited due to acidity or oligotrophy of the waters. One stream drained both native and eucalypt forest, but the density and biomass of shredders in the eucalypt (downstream) site was very similar to those found in native streams. This result supports the idea that transport of native organic matter from upstream parts of the basin can maintain native invertebrate assemblages in downstream parts where the land use has been changed.

Transpiration along an age series of Eucalyptus globulus plantations in southeastern Australia

Many of the world's Eucalyptus plantations are grown on short rotations of 15 years or less, which often covers the most rapid phase of stand development and peaks in growth rates and leaf areas. Since transpiration is related to stand leaf area these short rotations that make use of rapid early growth rates, may also maximise plantation water use, which has implications for predicting their water requirements and impacts on catchment hydrology. This study examined the transpiration, leaf area and growth rates of Eucalyptus globulus Labill. plantations aged 2–8 years. Transpiration ( E), estimated using the heat pulse technique, increased from 0.4 mm day −1 at age 2 years to a peak of about 1.6–1.9 mm day −1 in stands aged 5–7 years. This was associated with similar trends for stand leaf area index (LAI) and periodic annual increments of aboveground biomass, which both peaked at about age 4–6 years resulting in a linear relationship between E and LAI. While stand sapwood areas were continuing to increase at age 8 years, E was already declining due to reductions in sap velocity, from 13.5 cm h −1 at age 2 years to 6.3 cm h −1 at age 8 years and reduced sapwood area growth rates. Trees compensated for this reduction in sap velocity with declines in the leaf area ( A L) to sapwood area ( A S) relationship ( A L :A S) with age. There was also a reduction in growth efficiency (aboveground biomass increment per LAI) with age. However, reductions in WUE were small after age 4 years, which explained the linear relationship between E and LAI. If E continues to decline successive short rotation lengths may not only make use of rapid early growth rates but could also increase plantation water use compared to longer rotations over the same period of time.

Evaluation of forest operations in Spanish eucalypt plantations under a life cycle assessment perspective

The forest is an essential natural resource providing multiple benefits to people. However, forests face several environmental problems created by modern industrial society such as acidification, eutrophication and global warming. This study investigated the environmental loads associated with the Spanish forest sector, where this activity plays an important role in socioeconomic development. A Eucalyptus globulus plantation located in north-western Spain was considered as a case study. Forest operations were divided into three subsystems: silvicultural operations, logging operations and secondary hauling. The results showed that logging operations consume more energy than any other part of the wood supply chain, with a remarkable contribution in the potential impact categories of global warming, acidification and photochemical oxidant formation. Transportation of timber from forest landing to industrial sites (secondary hauling) is the second most important energy user. Silvicultural operations made an important contribution to eutrophication, mainly due to phosphorus-based fertilizer application. This study will enable improved Iberian life cycle assessment studies of wood products in the absence of detailed studies for this region.

Drought deaths in Eucalyptus globulus (Labill.) plantations in relation to soils, geomorphology and climate

The occurrence of tree deaths in young, 3 to 6 year old Eucalyptus globulus plantations established on farmland in south-western Australia was found to be strongly related to factors indicative of poor soil water storage capacity. Seven years after planting tree survival was significantly less on soils 2 m deep (22% vs 70%). This is due to the limited ability of some soils to store a sufficient proportion of the annual rainfall within the root-zone to meet the plant water demand in a region with a recurrent annual summer drought. There are practical difficulties in routinely surveying soils to depths in excess of 2 m over broad areas, to predict the likelihood of tree death. On the granitic basement rocks of south-west Western Australia, the occurrence of ferricrete gravels provides a useful surrogate indicator for the presence of deeper soils. In this region the distribution of soil depth and soil fertility has a geomorphic basis, being related to previous patterns of deep weathering and regolith stripping. Soils have developed on various horizons of deeply weathered profiles, formed from granites and gneisses. These materials have been stripped to a variable extent by erosion, leading to a range of soil depths. The original weathered profiles, which correspond to the soils with ferricrete gravels, comprise the deepest soil/regolith materials (~30-50 m deep); whereas along drainage lines the regolith has been completely stripped, the soils are shallow and plantations are most susceptible to drought. Knowledge of the relationship between soil depth and plantation performance allows regional indications of drought risk to be developed from regional soil mapping and the production of more efficient sampling designs for site assessment.

A comparison of four process-based models and a statistical regression model to predict growth of Eucalyptus globulus plantations

In forest management and ecological research, consideration of the impacts and risks of climate change or management optimisation is complex. Computer models have long been applied as tools for these tasks. Process-based forest growth models claim to overcome the limitations of empirical statistical models, but the capacity of different process-based models and modelling approaches have rarely been compared directly. This study evaluates stepwise multiple regression models in comparison to four process-based modelling approaches (3-PG, 3-PG+, CABALA and Forest-DNDC) for greenfield predictions of Eucalyptus globulus plantation growth from 2 to 8 years after planting throughout southern Australia. The stepwise multiple regression models could not simulate plantation growth to a satisfactory level of precision over the entire simulation period, although 2 years after planting model efficiency was 0.46, greater than for any of the process-based models. The variables that were statistically important to predict early plantation growth were mean minimum temperature, stocking rate and the amount of applied N fertiliser. For plantations between 4 and 8 years of age, coefficients of model efficiency were between −0.55 and −0.99. Only process-based models provided the flexibility to realistically predict the impacts of the different growth conditions throughout of the simulation period. Amongst the process-based models, Forest-DNDC achieved the greatest model efficiency (0.28) at 2 years after planting and was the most consistent performing model (0.20–0.30), whereas CABALA achieved the greates model efficiency (0.70) after 8 years of plantation growth. Both 3-PG models performed best for 6-year-old plantations, but throughout the simulation period their predictive precision was strongly dependent on estimating site fertility. For 3-PG+, a statistical approach to estimate site fertility resulted in a model efficiency of 0.28 at 6 years after planting, whereas a subjective estimation of site fertility for 3-PG resulted in a model efficiency of 0.58. In general, the process-based models had difficulties in simulating very young plantations at less then 4 years after planting, plantations with high tree mortality rates and plantation response to extreme silvicultural management operations.