Hoomen, Merrikh and Ejlali presents comment on the paper on 'Flow, thermal, and entropy generation characteristics inside a porous channel with viscous dissipation' by S. Mahmud and R.A. Fraser. The paper presents closed form solutions to the velocity and temperature distributions that would be very useful for checking numerical computations. The authors have applied the fluid thermal conductivity kf in all of the equations, that should be replaced by the effective thermal conductivity. They have presented the temperature distribution and the Nusselt number as a function of the Darcy number only, inspite of the fact that Re, Pr, and Ec will affect the temperature profile. The authors have applied a clear-fluid compatible term in the entropy production term that has not been already considered in the thermal energy equation. The reliability of the numerical results is questionable though the authors have applied a previously tested numerical scheme.
Read full abstract