Abstract Although various studies advocate for the integration of information and communication technologies in education, the forced digitization caused by the pandemic has yielded contradictory results on student learning. Conversely, research has shown that when students manage ICT, they achieve better learning outcomes but when teacher-centered approaches are employed, their effects on learning tend to be negative. Has the pandemic crisis served to promote or hinder the integration of ICT in classrooms? Have the uses of ICT changed? This article focuses on whether changes after the mandatory use of ICT in classrooms during the pandemic have favored the integration of digital technologies in classrooms. The analysis of these results has not only practical implications but also theoretical, since they allow us to test the influence of different variables on the change in teaching conceptions and practices. 731 primary and secondary Spanish teachers responded to a questionnaire investigating the frequency with which they used ICT in their classrooms, the type of use they made, and the learning outcomes they promoted. The results showed that teachers reported a higher use of ICT than in previous periods. Also, similar to studies before and during the pandemic, these results indicated a higher frequency of teacher-centered activities, mainly oriented towards the transmission of verbal content. However, this effect seems to have been moderated after the pandemic. There were, however, different teacher profiles reflecting different styles in the educational use of ICT. A critical variable for making student-centered use of ICT seems to be the frequency of use. Those teachers more familiar with ICT tended to make more complex and varied uses, suggesting that their inclusion in teacher training should be an essential step to promote the integration of ICT in classrooms.
Read full abstract