We appreciate Dr. Waldum's interest in our study1Rindi G. Azzoni C. La Rosa S. et al.ECL cell tumor and poorly differentiated endocrine carcinoma of the stomach: prognostic evaluation by pathological analysis.Gastroenterology. 1999; 116: 532-542Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (324) Google Scholar on gastric ECL cell tumors and poorly differentiated endocrine carcinomas; we would like to point out the following in reply to the questions and comments raised. First, the 258 tumors were diagnosed in 4 different pathology departments that operate as reference centers for gut endocrine tumors. All morphological means presently known to be relevant for such diagnoses, from histopathology to immunohistochemical tests for various hormones and endocrine markers, and electron microscopy in many cases, have been used as specified in the present and previous articles.2Solcia E. Capella C. Fiocca R. et al.Gastric argyrophil carcinoidosis in patients with Zollinger–Ellison syndrome due to type 1 multiple endocrine neoplasia. A newly recognized association.Am J Surg Pathol. 1990; 14: 503-513Crossref PubMed Scopus (204) Google Scholar, 5Rindi G. Bordi C. Rappel S. et al.Gastric carcinoids and neuroendocrine carcinomas: pathogenesis, pathology and behavior.World J Surg. 1996; 20: 168-172Crossref PubMed Scopus (375) Google Scholar, 3Bordi C. Yu J.Y. Baggi M.T. et al.Gastric carcinoids and their precursor lesions. A histological and immunohistochemical study of 23 cases.Cancer. 1991; 67: 663-672Crossref PubMed Scopus (166) Google Scholar, 4Rindi G. Luinetti O. Cornaggia M. et al.Three subtypes of gastric argyrophil carcinoids and the gastric neuroendocrine carcinoma: a clinicopathological study.Gastroenterology. 1993; 104: 994-1006PubMed Google Scholar Pertinent diagnostic criteria, including differential diagnosis between well-differentiated and poorly differentiated endocrine tumors as well as between endocrine and nonendocrine gastric tumors, were also detailed in these articles. In particular, the diagnosis of poorly differentiated endocrine carcinoma was based on diffuse to poorly defined solid structure; severe cellular atypia; poor, scanty, or absent reactivity for hormonal products and endocrine granule markers, such as chromogranins or silver stains; reactivity for cytosolic or small clear vesicles neuroendocrine markers, such as synaptophysin, in a substantial proportion of tumor cells; lack of reactivity for exocrine differentiation markers, such as mucins and pepsinogens; and ultrastructural evidence of a few secretory granules of unquestionable endocrine nature (exocrine secretory granules must be ruled out). Recently, such criteria were accepted by the international WHO group for the histological typing of endocrine tumors.6Solcia E. Klöppel G. Sobin L.H. Histological typing of endocrine tumours. WHO International Histologic Classification of Tumours. Springer, Berlin2004Google Scholar Mixed exocrine-endocrine tumors showing evidence of substantial differentiation in both exocrine and endocrine directions inside the same tumor were excluded from the study. Second, our investigation dealt with the 102 tumors that, after extensive review of all available material by at least 2 of us, were found to fulfill all requirements for careful clinicopathologic evaluation, including prolonged follow-up information and extensive tumor and nontumor tissue sampling. Third, concerning poorly differentiated endocrine carcinoma, Dr. Waldum's concern that iatrogenic hypergastrinemia is a major risk factor for gastric malignancy remains to be substantiated by facts. Available evidence suggests that endogenous hypergastrinemia is a risk factor for the well-differentiated ECL cells carcinoids arising in a background of severe type A chronic atrophic gastritis or combined multiple endocrine neoplasia Zollinger–Ellison syndrome, very few of which proved malignant.1Rindi G. Azzoni C. La Rosa S. et al.ECL cell tumor and poorly differentiated endocrine carcinoma of the stomach: prognostic evaluation by pathological analysis.Gastroenterology. 1999; 116: 532-542Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (324) Google Scholar, 3Bordi C. Yu J.Y. Baggi M.T. et al.Gastric carcinoids and their precursor lesions. A histological and immunohistochemical study of 23 cases.Cancer. 1991; 67: 663-672Crossref PubMed Scopus (166) Google Scholar Presently, no established evidence supports a role for hypergastrinemia, either endogenous or iatrogenic, in the genesis of the frequently malignant sporadic ECL cell carcinoid, most highly malignant poorly differentiated endocrine carcinomas, or common nonendocrine gastric cancers, an issue beyond the scope of our study.
Read full abstract