Elevated Levels Of Selenium Research Articles

A Dietary Assessment of Selenium Risk to Aquatic Birds on a Coal Mine Affected Stream in Alberta, Canada

ABSTRACT Selenium is a trace element of concern in the McLeod River basin downstream from two recently-closed coal mines in west-central Alberta, Canada. Aquatic birds breed on streams in the area and may be exposed to excessive amounts of selenium through their diets. In this article, we present the results of a dietary-based assessment of the risk that selenium may pose to two aquatic bird species, the American Dipper (Cinclus mexicanus) and the Harlequin Duck (Histrionicus histrionicus), on one of the coal mine–affected streams, the Gregg River. The study consisted of (1) a literature-based toxicity assessment, (2) simulation of selenium exposure in the diets and eggs of the two species, and (3) a risk assessment that coupled information on toxicity and exposure. Diet and egg selenium concentrations associated with a 20% hatch failure rate were 6.4 and 17 μ g · g−1 dry wt, respectively. Simulated dietary selenium concentrations were about 2.0–2.5 μ g · g−1 higher on the Gregg River than on reference streams for both species. Simulated predicted egg concentrations averaged 2.0 and 1.4 μ g · g−1 higher on the Gregg River than on reference streams for American Dippers and Harlequin Ducks, respectively. When simulated dietary concentrations were considered, hatch failure rates on the Gregg River were predicted to average 12% higher in American Dippers and 8% higher in Harlequin Ducks than at reference streams. Corresponding values were only 3% for both species when predicted egg concentrations were used. Elevated levels of selenium in insects in some of the reference streams were unexpected and raised a question as to whether aquatic birds have evolved a higher tolerance level for dietary selenium in these areas.

Is selenium affecting body condition and reproduction in boreal breeding scaup, scoters, and ring-necked ducks?

Elevated levels of selenium (Se) have been detected in wintering and spring-staging lesser scaup. Here, we compared spring scaup Se and mercury (Hg) levels to those of ring-necked ducks and white-winged scoters, species exhibiting increasing and decreasing boreal populations, respectively. Mercury concentrations were low in all three species. Geometric mean (95%CI) liver Se concentrations were 6.2 (5.5–7.0), 4.6 (4.0–5.4), and 32.6 (28.4–37.3) mg/kg dry weight (dw) in scaup, ringnecks and scoters, respectively. Only scoter livers (66%) were above 33 mg/kg dw Se. Scaup and ringneck Se levels were unrelated to breeding status or lipid and protein levels; breeding scoters and females with greater lipid mass had higher Se than non-breeders. Egg and follicle concentrations in scaup and scoters were normal (mean [95%CI] = 2.3 [1.9–2.6] and 2.4 [2.1–2.7] mg/kg dw, respectively). Overall, we found no support for a relationship between selenium and boreal scaup and scoter declines, and discuss current Se threshold concentrations.

Selenium concentrations in water and plant tissues of a newly formed arid wetland in Las Vegas, Nevada

There is concern that elevated levels of selenium found in the source water of a newly formed wetland park in Las Vegas, Nevada, may have detrimental effects on local wildlife. In this study, we collected and analyzed water samples monthly for a three year period from the inflow and outflow of the system. We also gathered dominant aquatic plants and selected terrestrial plants and analyzed the water and plant tissues (root, shoot, leaf and flower) for selenium by high resolution Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometer. Except for storm events and the introduction of an alternative low selenium content source water during summer low-flow conditions, selenium in the water was relatively stable. The concentration in the outflow tended to be slightly lower than the inflow. Concentrations of selenium in the dominant plant taxa in this wetlands were typical of ecosystems in the western United States and varied by taxa, tissue type, localized conditions (e.g., contact with selenium-laden water), and to a lesser extent, seasons. Selenium in the aquatic plant spiny naiad (Najas marina) was relatively high and may pose an ecological risk to wildlife during the late spring and summer. Additional work is underway investigating aquatic food chain accumulations of selenium as well as mass balance of selenium in the system.

The American Dipper as a Bioindicator of Selenium Contamination in a Coal Mine-Affected Stream in West-Central Alberta, Canada

Elevated levels of selenium have been found in water and aquatic biota downstream from two open-pit coal mines in the Rocky Mountain foothills of Alberta. Birds are particularly sensitive to excessive dietary selenium. However, there is relatively little information on selenium accumulation in birds' eggs on fast-flowing mountain streams. We determined levels of selenium in water samples, caddisfly larvae and eggs of American dippers (Cinclus mexicanus) nesting on the Gregg River, downstream from the mines, and on reference streams in the same general vicinity. Selenium levels (mean, 95% confidence limits) in water samples and caddisflies collected from sites near dipper nests on the Gregg River (water: 4.26, 1.90-9.56 microg L(-1); caddisflies: 8.43, 7.51-9.46 microg g dry wt(-1)) were greater than those collected from sites near nests on reference rivers (water: 0.38, 0.21-0.71 microg L(-1); caddisflies: 4.65, 4.35-4.97 microg g dry wt(-1)). The mean (+/- 1SE) selenium level in dipper eggs from the Gregg River (6.3 +/- 0.2 microg g(-1) dry wt) was significantly higher than it was in eggs from reference streams (4.9 +/- 0.2 microg g(-1) dry wt). Concentrations of selenium in eggs were significantly correlated with those in water samples (r = 0.45). The maximum selenium level in eggs from the Gregg River (9.0 microg g(-1)) may have been high enough to warrant concern from an ecotoxicological perspective. The American dipper can serve as a useful bioindicator of selenium contamination in mountainous, lotic ecosystems.

Chemopreventive activity of selenocysteine prodrugs against tobacco‐derived nitrosamine (NNK) induced lung tumors in the A/J mouse

Prodrugs of L-selenocysteine have potential utility in cancer chemoprevention. This study reports the efficacy of three selenazolidine-4(R)-carboxylic acids, (2-unsubstituted, 2-oxo, and 2-methyl derivatives; SCA, OSCA, and MSCA, respectively) against tobacco-related lung tumorigenesis in a mouse model. Seven days after initiation of an AIN-76A diet supplemented with sodium selenite (5 ppm Se), L-selenomethionine (3.75 ppm Se), Se-methyl-L-selenocysteine (3 ppm Se), L-selenocystine (15 ppm Se), SCA (15 ppm Se), OSCA (15 ppm Se), or MSCA (15 ppm Se), mice received 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK; 10 micromol, i.p.). After an additional 16 weeks on the diets, two compounds, OSCA and selenocystine, significantly reduced lung adenoma multiplicity from 7.2 tumors per mouse in the NNK group to 4.5 and 4.6 tumors per mouse, respectively. Neither selenium concentration nor glutathione peroxidase activity in either RBCs or liver served as surrogate indicators of tumor reduction. Hepatic selenium levels were significantly elevated by all selenium-containing compounds except Se-methyl-L-selenocysteine and SCA; RBC selenium levels by all except sodium selenite and MSCA. With the exception of L-selenomethionine, RBC glutathione peroxidase activity was increased along with the elevated selenium levels. Hepatic glutathione peroxidase activity was elevated by all Se-compounds except SCA. The two compounds showing significant tumor reduction (OSCA and selenocystine) were the only two compounds that showed ubiquity of changes, elevating both selenium levels and GPx activity in both liver and RBC.

Risk assessment for the consumption of fish with elevated selenium levels.

This article describes an application of risk assessment for the consumption of fish with elevated selenium levels, from Lake Macquarie, which is in the Hunter region of New South Wales.

Steel Slag in Acid Mine Drainage Treatment and Control

Steel slags are composed of calcium alumino-silicate oxides. Most slags have a sandy texture, but others have a silty texture and give a fine, powdery feel. Neutralization potentials of steel slags range from 45 to 78%, which make them candidates for neutralizing the acidity in acid mine drainage. Analysis of total metal content in Mingo Junction steel slab shows high concentrations of aluminum, chromium, iron, manganese, and titanium. Upon leaching this slag with water, the leachate had a pH of 11.7 and n alkalinity of 1,450 mg/L as CaCO{sub 3} equivalent. In general, steel slag yielded more alkalinity than equal weights of limestone (500 to 1,500 mg/L compared to 60 to 80 mg/L) during leaching studies. Leaching the slag with water and a weak sulfuric acid solution showed that the metals contained in the slag were not readily leachable since these metals were found at low concentrations in the leachate. When different amounts of slag were mixed with an acid-producing coal refuse and then leached with water, pH values of the leachate varied between 3.5 and 7.3. Slightly elevated levels of selenium, nickel, manganese, and possibly iron were found in leachates of refuse/slag mixtures compared to refuse alone. Due tomore » slag's high availability in some areas and low cost, steel slags show potential as an acid-neutralizing material for coal refuse and acid-producing spoils, and for treating acid mine drainage directly. If slag is to be used as an alkaline amendment, it must be added in sufficient quantities to ensure nonacid conditions now and in the future, since under acid conditions some metals may become available. Steel slag can also be used as a liming material for soils. The most promising use for steel slag is as a source of alkalinity to fresh waters that may subsequently encounter acid mine drainage, such as alkaline leach beds or limestone sand applications to headwater streams.« less

The effect of subclinical selenium toxicosis on pregnant beef cattle.

A field investigation conducted by the South Dakota Animal Disease Research and Diagnostic Laboratory suggested that subclinical selenium toxicosis in pregnant cows may have contributed to an outbreak of aborted/stillborn calves in a high-selenium region of South Dakota. This study was undertaken to evaluate the relationship between abortion and subclinical selenium toxicosis in the dam and to assess the effects of subclinical selenium toxicosis on the bovine immune system. Fifteen pregnant cows were fed diets containing 0.25 (control), 6.0, and 12.0 ppm selenium beginning at 80-110 days gestation. Although selenium toxicosis has been reported to cause abortion, this study failed to reproduce abortions. A single cow in the 12-ppm selenium treatment group gave birth to a weak calf, which subsequently died. This calf had myocardial lesions consistent with those described for selenium toxicosis and had hepatic selenium levels of 9.68 ppm (wet weight). Elevated dietary selenium resulted in the depression of several leukocyte function parameters in pregnant cows. A statistically significant depression in forced antibody response was identified in both selenium-supplemented groups. A significantly diminished mitogenic response to concanavalin A and pokeweed mitogen was also observed in the 12-ppm selenium group. Although a similar pattern of depression was also observed with phytohemagglutinin, differences were not significant. These findings indicate that even in the absence of clinical alkali disease, elevated selenium levels may adversely affect both pregnancy outcome and the bovine immune system.

Distribution and age-related changes of trace elements in kittiwake Rissa tridactyla nestlings from an isolated colony in the German Bight, North Sea

Tissue distribution of five trace elements (Se, Hg, Cd, Zn, Cu) was investigated in soft tissues and feathers of Kittiwake nestlings from the Island of Helgoland, North Sea. The tissue distribution of metals was similar in all age classes. Feathers and down contained highest mercury and zinc concentrations, whereas elevated levels of selenium and cadmium were found in the kidney. The concentrations of cadmium, copper and zinc in liver and kidney were low in hatchlings and increased with age of the nestlings, indicating the importance of the ingestion of contaminated food during chick growth. In the case of mercury, concentrations were high shortly after hatching and decreased when the chicks grew older. This indicates, that egg contamination was more important in chicks than contaminated food items. The total liver burden of all trace elements increased throughout chick development. Significant positive correlations between essential and non-essential elements were found in liver and/or kidney of all age classes. However, only the correlations between zinc and copper levels maintained throughout chick growth. The number of interactions between elements were increasing with progressing chick age. Correlations between cadmium and the essential elements copper and zinc appeared to depend on contaminant levels of cadmium, whereas mercury was correlated to essential elements in low and highly contaminated chicks. It was demonstrated that particularly older chicks (≥ 6 days old) were reliable bioindicators of mercury and cadmium contaminations around Helgoland Island.

Effects of selenium dietary enhancement on hatchery-reared coho salmon, Oncorhynchus kisutch (Walbaum), when compared with wild coho: hepatic enzymes and seawater adaptation evaluated

Hatchery-reared coho salmon, Oncorhynchus kisutch (Walbaum), were fed elevated levels of selenium (as Na2SeO3) to raise eviscerated body burdens to the level measured in wild counterparts. The goal was to find a dietary concentration that would achieve the desired effect without causing damage to growth and normal development. To measure some indices of health, the detoxifying enzymes chosen were hepatic glutathione peroxidase (GSH-Px) and hepatic superoxide dismutase (SOD). Eviscerated body selenium (Se) concentration, GSH-Px and SOD levels were measured during and at the end of the 9 month freshwater feeding trial. Selenium retention and enzyme activity were also measured during 6 months’residence in sea water (SW). Selenium supplements were added to a commercial ration to give final concentrations of 1.1, 8.6, 11.1, 13.6 μg g-1 Se in the four respective diets. The results indicated that a dietary concentration of 8.6 μg g-1 selenium was capable of inducing eviscerated body burdens similar to those found in wild fish. The elevated selenium levels persisted throughout the freshwater (FW) rearing phase, but declined when the fish were fed an unsupplemented ration upon SW entry. Superoxide dismutase levels did not increase above control levels. Glutathione peroxidase levels increased in fish fed the supplemented diets. GSH-Px activity declined in the higher supplemented dietary groups when all groups were reduced to the control group level of 1.1 μg g-1. Cumulative mortality in SW was 20% in fish fed either the 1.1 or the 8.6 μg g-1 Se diets. The 8.6 μg g-1 Se supplemented diets did produce healthy coho, comparable to their wild counterparts.

Selenium uptake by larval Chironomus decorus from a Ruppia maritima-based benthic/detrital substrate

Elevated levels of selenium have led to the contamination of several aquatic ecosystems. Much of the selenium contamination has resulted from agricultural irrigation and drainage of seleniferous soils. Disposal of selenium contaminated drainwater in evaporation ponds has led to selenium bioaccumulation and toxicity in waterfowl and shorebirds using these ponds. Studies have demonstrated that it is a seleno-amino acid that causes the observed toxicity. However, selenate is the dominant form of selenium in agricultural drainwater, and the biotransformation of selenate into seleno-amino acids has been shown to be greatly limited relative to the more reduced selenium species. We hypothesize that it is in the benthic zone, where the reducing environment facilitates conversion of selenate to selenium forms more conducive to biotransformation, that most biotransformation and subsequent bioaccumulation of seleno-amino acids takes place, and that movement of selenium into the benthic-detrital food chain is a key pathway leading to selenium bioaccumulation. This hypothesis was investigated by conducting laboratory benthic-detrital food chain experiments using the common evaporation pond macrophyte Ruppia maritima as the benthic-detrital substrate. Larval Chironomus decorus were reared on the contaminated Ruppia substrate, and the resulting bioaccumulation and toxicity in the larvae were determined.

Prognosis on Managing Trace Elements

Concern over the potentially toxic effects of trace elements in agricultural drainage waters has been aroused by the discovery of selenium poisoning of wildlife at Kesterson Reservoir, California, and was heightened further through discovery of elevated levels of selenium in shallow ground water underlying extensive areas of San Joaquin Valley's west side. Recent investigations by the U.S. Department of the Interior's National Irrigation Water Quality Program (NIWQP) revealed that similar trace‐element problems exist in several other western states including Nevada, Utah, Wyoming, and Colorado, as well as the Tulare Lake Bed and Salton Sea in California. Management options assessed for trace elements discharged from irrigated lands include source control, drain‐water reuse, drain‐water treatment, and removal of contaminants, disposal, and institutional and jurisdictional control measures. A combination of source control and other drainage‐water‐management options has the potential to reduce the toxic‐elem...

Natural Establishment and Selenium Accumulation of Herbaceous Plant Species in Soils with Elevated Concentrations of Selenium and Salinity under Irrigation and Tillage Practices

The effects of irrigation and tillage practices were studied on species richness, biomass, and selenium accumulation of naturally established herbaceous plants in soils with elevated levels of selenium (Se) and salinity at Kesterson Reservoir, Merced County, California. The four different irrigation-tillage practice combinations were (1) no irrigation, no tillage; (2) irrigation, no tillage; (3) no irrigation, tillage; and (4) irrigation, tillage. The fields were allowed to become colonized naturally by herbaceous plant species. For the Mediterranean climate in the study site, irrigation was conducted biweekly through the summer months, and tillage was done in 3-month intervals. Biomass and Se accumulation of Atriplex patula L, Bassia hyssopifolia Kuntze, Rev. Gen. P1., Melilotus indica (L.) All., and Solola kali L. were substantially affected by irrigation. The degree and direction of the effects were found to be species dependent. The field plots which were tilled at 3-month intervals remained bare throughout the experiment. The total soil Se concentrations in the top 15 cm soil horizon were found to be in the range of 40 to 70 mg kg−1 dry wt. Soil Se concentrations below 25 cm soil depth were much lower and within a range of 2 to 4mg kg−1. Less than 110th of the total soil Se inventory in the top soil horizon was water extractable, and the distribution of the Se inventory did not change significantly over the period of 1990 and 1991 despite the irrigation and tillage practices suggesting that a large portion of the Se inventory was not remobilized. The water-extractable soil Se concentration was found to be significantly lower in soils with the greatest biomass production suggesting an effective bioextraction of soil selenium by the native herbaceous plants.

Metabolic deposition of selenium and cadmium into the hair and other tissues of the guinea pig

To better understand the significance of hair trace-element measurements and their relationships with the trace-element levels in body organs and fluids, a series of controlled animal experiments were conducted in which several trace elements were periodically measured during a 90-day chronic exposure to selenium and cadmium. Chronic selenium exposure appeared to be reflected by elevated selenium levels in the hair, kidneys, and liver. Chronic cadmium exposure, although reflected by kidney and liver elevation, appeared not to be reflected by corresponding increases in its concentration in the hair.

Metabolism of selenium in a selenium-dependent bacterium

A selenium-dependent Bacillus sp. is able to grow well up to 3% sodium selenite-containing media. The bacterium completely failed to grow on media devoid of selenium. The presence of selenium in the growth media increased the bacterial contents of proteins, carbohydrates, and lipids. The highest quantities of amino acids were detected at 2% sodium selenite-containing media. The bacterium metabolized selenite into several protein selenoamino acids such as selenomethionine and selenocysteine/selenocystine, as well as nonprotein selenoamino acids, such as selenocystathionine. Several phosphoamino acids were detected in the presence of elevated levels of selenium. The synthesized protein seems not to be affected by the presence of selenium.

Bioaccumulation of Selenium in Aquatic Ecosystems

ABSTRACT Elevated levels of selenium have resulted in the degradation of several ecosystems and have been linked to reproductive impairment in important fish and waterfowl populations in several lakes and reservoirs, indicating the need for a better understanding of the bioaccumulation of selenium by aquatic organisms. Because space limitations prevent an exhaustive review, this paper focuses on the processes and mechanisms of bioconcentration and biomagnification. Comparative uptake and accumulation of selenite, selenate, and selenomethionine are examined, as well as the relative importance of waterborne and foodborne exposure. The observed toxicity of selenium in lakes and reservoirs is briefly discussed. Finally, this information is summarized, pointing out key trends in the uptake and accumulation of selenium. Perhaps the most important information generated by this review involves comparative metabolism of selenite and selenate; selenite is readily reduced and metabolized, while reduction and metabol...

Selenium and human health implications in California's San Joaquin Valley.

An evaluation was conducted on the human health impacts of elevated levels of selenium in the Kesterson National Wildlife Refuge and its surroundings in Merced County, California. Investigative activities of various agencies were summarized and assessed. Agricultural waste water not intended for human use showed elevated selenium concentrations of up to 1400 ppb. Levels of selenium in fish (up to 96 ppm, wet weight), aquatic birds (up to 130 ppm in liver, dry weight), and waterfowl (up to 5.3 ppm flesh, wet weight) were unsafe for unrestricted human consumption. Data on selenium in drinking water (less than 10 ppb), animals (mean values: beef liver 0.3-0.35 ppm, wet weight; milk, 0.01-0.02 ppm), and air (particulate, 14.8 ng/m3; gaseous, less than 1080 ng/m3) did not suggest a high level of exposure. Selenium concentrations in soil were highly variable and suggested a potential source of high exposure. Selenium values in blood and urine of workers were within normal range. A community health survey did not show any trend of adverse health effects in the local population.

Selenium in aquatic organisms from subsurface agricultural drainage water, San Joaquin Valley, California.

Concentrations of total selenium were high in 1983 in water, sediment, organic detritus, aquatic plants and invertebrates, and mosquitofish (Gambusia affinis) from Kesterson Reservoir (San Joaquin Valley, California) and the San Luis Drain. Selenium concentrations in biota from the Reservoir and Drain (referred to here collectively as “Kesterson”) exceeded 300 (μg/g dry weight in some samples of algae, submerged rooted plants, chironomids, and mosquitofish, and were as high as 440 μg/g dry weight in decomposing detritus. Overall, selenium concentrations in samples from Kesterson averaged about 100-fold higher than those from the Volta Wildlife Area (here termed “Volta”), a nearby site that does not receive subsurface drainage water. Selenium concentrations generally increased from water to sediment to plants to animals. Spatial (geographic) patterns were observed for selenium concentrations in samples from Kesterson, but not in those from Volta. Higher concentrations were usually measured in samples from the San Luis Drain than from the evaporation ponds that comprise Kesterson Reservoir. At Kesterson, concentrations were usually higher in August than in May. The elevated levels of selenium measured in forage organisms from Kesterson are probably toxic to sensitive consumer animals, and may explain recent observations of dead and deformed embryos in eggs of aquatic birds that nest at the Reservoir. The effects of the selenium on fish living in subsurface agricultural drainage water are still poorly understood.

Selenium contamination of the grasslands, a major California waterfowl area

In a recent study at Kesterson Reservoir in California, selenium was shown to cause mortality and deformities in embryos of aquatic birds. The present study was conducted to determine if selenium or other contaminants in agricultural drainwater used for marsh management were likely to cause similar adverse effects in the nearby Grasslands area. Selenium concentrations were elevated ( < 15 ppm, dry-weight) in livers of some birds of all species collected from the Grasslands. Mean selenium concentrations in all species sampled in the South Grasslands were significantly higher ( P < 0.05) than those from the “control site”, the Volta Wildlife Area. Mean selenium levels in black-necked stilts ( Himantopus mexicanus) from the South Grasslands (35.6 ppm) were similar ( P > 0.05) to levels in stilts from Kesterson (46.4 ppm), but means for American avocets ( Recurvirostra americana) from the South Grasslands (67.3 ppm) were higher ( P < 0.05) than those from Kesterson (28.4 ppm). Bird eggs and fish from the Grasslands also contained elevated levels of selenium. Concentrations of eight heavy metals in fish generally reflected those patterns previously found in water entering the study areas. Of the organochlorines detected in fish, only DDE occurred at concentrations potentially harmful to birds (6.1 and 3.0 ppm, wet weight, at two South Grassland sites). The effect on avian health or reproduction of the other contaminants, singly or in combination, could not be determined. However, selenium levels were apparently sufficiently elevated in 1984 to have caused adverse effects on avian reproduction in the South Grasslands.

Embryonic mortality and abnormalities of aquatic birds: Apparent impacts of selenium from irrigation drainwater

Severe reproductive impacts were found in aquatic birds nesting on irrigation drainwater ponds in the San Joaquin Valley of California. Of 347 nests studied to late incubation or to hatching, 40.6% had at least one dead embryo and 19.6% had at least one embryo or chick with an obvious external anomaly. The deformities were often multiple and included missing or abnormal eyes, beaks, wings, legs and feet. Brain, heart, liver and skeletal anomalies were also present. Mean selenium concentrations in plants, invertebrates, and fish from the ponds were 22–175 ppm (dry weight), about 12 to 130 times those found at a nearby control area. Bird eggs (2.2–110 ppm) and livers (19–130 ppm) also contained elevated levels of selenium. Aquatic birds may experience similar problems in other areas where selenium occurs at elevated levels.