Electron spin resonance (ESR) spectroscopy was used for characterizing the products obtained by prolonged autoxidation of simple dihydric phenols (hydroquinone, catechol, and 4-methylcatechol) in the presence of copper(II) ions. Room temperature ESR spectra revealed that both paramagnetic copper(II) ions and organic radicals are present in obtained autoxidation products similarly to the humic acid complexed copper(II) ions. The ratio of organic radical signal intensity to the copper(II) ion signal intensity suggests that the smallest amount of copper(II) ions is incorporated in the hydroquinone autoxidation product while the highest amount of copper(II) ions is incorporated in the autoxidation product of catechol. Satisfactory computer simulations of experimental ESR spectra were obtained by considering only one type of copper(II) ion binding site for hydroquinone autoxidation product and two distinct types of copper(II) ion binding sites for catechol and 4-methylcatechol autoxidation products. Parameters obtained by the computer simulation of ESR spectra indicated prevalent ionic bonding of copper(II) ions in polymeric matrices with tetrahedral distortion at copper(II) ion binding sites and negligible exchange interactions between them. Products obtained by the hydroquinone and catechol autoxidation have more similar characteristics in comparison to the product obtained by the 4-methylcatechol autoxidation where more expressed ionic bonding of copper(II) ions, and smaller tetrahedral distortion are present. Due to the dipolar interactions of oxygen-centered organic radicals in autoxidation products with paramagnetic copper(II) ions, their ESR linewidths are larger and g-values smaller in comparison to the values found in humic acids from various soil types.