Emmet Kennedy’s Abbé Sicard’s Deaf Education: Empowering the Mute, 1785–1820 is a slim volume that examines the life and works of Roch-Ambroise Cucurron, Abbé Sicard (1742–1822). Sicard was the director of the Institution Nationale des Sourds-Muets in Paris for thirty years and during that time developed foundational methods for the education of the deaf, publishing numerous works on grammar and education. Just that accomplishment would be sufficient to justify a book-length treatment of his activities, but Sicard was also politically active and an influential member of Parisian academia during the revolutionary period and beyond, so his story has extensive historical ramifications. Sicard entered a teaching order and became a priest as a young man, and although he soon left the order, he remained a priest for the remainder of his life—and a refractory one at that. In 1792 he was arrested but escaped execution during the September Massacres, allegedly because some of the sansculottes recognized that he was the famous teacher of the deaf, and thus indispensable to the state. A year later he was still performing the mass and was arrested again; due in large part to heartfelt letters from his students, he was released. These were the first of many escapes, either lucky or engineered, that saved Sicard through the Terror, the Directory, and the Napoleonic era, until the Restoration period, when he was able to act with less political interference. Throughout the period, Sicard continued to publish his educational treatises and could be found holding positions in the most prestigious academic institutions of the time. Political and educational leaders, as well as men and women from the highest ranks of Europe’s aristocracy, came to Paris to meet with Sicard and visit his school, where he gave them demonstrations of his students’ abilities to communicate through sign language. Many of these leaders then returned to their own states to establish similar schools for the deaf. Sicard was also visited by Thomas Hopkins Gallaudet, one of the founders of deaf education in the United States. The question of the day, and one that still engages practitioners of deaf education presently, is whether sign language is preferable to lip reading and oral communication. Under the influence of Sicard, sign language began to be seen as the preferred method. Although Sicard did not entirely invent the sign language that he taught, he certainly expanded and popularized it; without his influence, deaf education would likely look quite different today.
Read full abstract