Editing Efficiency Research Articles

A review of virus host factor discovery using CRISPR screening.

The emergence of genome-scale forward genetic screening techniques, such as Haploid Genetic screen and clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) knockout screen has opened new horizons in our understanding of virus infection biology. CRISPR screening has become a popular tool for the discovery of novel host factors for several viruses due to its specificity and efficiency in genome editing. Here, we review how CRISPR screening has revolutionized our understanding of virus-host interactions from scientific and technological viewpoints. A summary of the published screens conducted thus far to uncover virus host factors is presented, highlighting their experimental design and significant findings. We will outline relevant methods for customizing the CRISPR screening process to answer more specific hypotheses and compile a glossary of conducted CRISPR screens to show their design aspects. Furthermore, using flaviviruses and severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) as examples, we hope to offer a broad-based perspective on the capabilities of CRISPR screening to serve as a reference point to guide future unbiased discovery of virus host factors.

CRISPR-Cas9/Cas12a systems for efficient genome editing and large genomic fragment deletions in Aspergillus niger.

CRISPR technology has revolutionized fungal genetic engineering by accelerating the pace and expanding the feasible scope of experiments in this field. Among various CRISPR-Cas systems, Cas9 and Cas12a are widely used in genetic and metabolic engineering. In filamentous fungi, both Cas9 and Cas12a have been utilized as CRISPR nucleases. In this work we first compared efficacies and types of genetic edits for CRISPR-Cas9 and -Cas12a systems at the polyketide synthase (albA) gene locus in Aspergillus niger. By employing a tRNA-based gRNA polycistronic cassette, both Cas9 and Cas12a have demonstrated equally remarkable editing efficacy. Cas12a showed potential superiority over Cas9 protein when one gRNA was used for targeting, achieving an editing efficiency of 86.5% compared to 31.7% for Cas9. Moreover, when employing two gRNAs for targeting, both systems achieved up to 100% editing efficiency for single gene editing. In addition, the CRISPR-Cas9 system has been reported to induce large genomic deletions in various species. However, its use for engineering large chromosomal segments deletions in filamentous fungi still requires optimization. Here, we engineered Cas9 and -Cas12a-induced large genomic fragment deletions by targeting various genomic regions of A. niger ranging from 3.5kb to 40kb. Our findings demonstrate that targeted engineering of large chromosomal segments can be achieved, with deletions of up to 69.1% efficiency. Furthermore, by targeting a secondary metabolite gene cluster, we show that fragments over 100kb can be efficiently and specifically deleted using the CRISPR-Cas9 or -Cas12a system. Overall, in this paper, we present an efficient multi-gRNA genome editing system utilizing Cas9 or Cas12a that enables highly efficient targeted editing of genes and large chromosomal regions in A. niger.

Lipid nanoparticle-mediated base-editing of the Hao1 gene achieves sustainable primary hyperoxaluria type 1 therapy in rats.

Primary hyperoxaluria type 1 (PH1) is a severe hereditary disease, leading to the accumulation of oxalate in multiple organs, particularly the kidney. Hydroxyacid oxidase 1 (HAO1), a pivotal gene involved in oxalate production, is an approved target for the treatment of PH1. In this study, we demonstrated the discovery of several novel therapeutic sites of the Hao1 gene and the efficient editing of Hao1 c.290-2 A in vivo with lipid nanoparticles (LNP) delivered adenine base editing (ABE) mRNA. A single infusion of LNP-ABE resulted in a near-complete knockout of Hao1 in the liver, leading to the sustainable normalization of urinary oxalate (for at least 6 months) and complete rescue of the patho-physiology in PH1 rats. Additionally, a significant correlation between Hao1 editing efficiency and urinary oxalate levels was observed and over 60% Hao1 editing efficiency was required to achieve the normalization of urinary oxalate in PH1 rats. These findings suggest that the LNP-mediated base-editing of Hao1 c.290-2 A is an efficient and safe approach to PH1 therapy, highlighting its potential utility in clinical settings.

Targeting DLBCL by mutation-specific disruption of cancer-driving oncogenes.

Diffuse large B cell lymphomas (DLBCL) are highly aggressive tumors. Their genetic complexity and heterogeneity have hampered the development of novel approaches for precision medicine. Our study aimed to develop a personalized therapy for DLBCL by utilizing the CRISPR/Cas system to induce knockouts (KO) of driver genes, thereby causing cancer cell death while minimizing side effects. We focused on OCI-LY3 cells, modeling DLBCL, and compared them with BJAB cells as controls. Analysis of whole exome sequencing revealed significant mutations in genes like PAX5, CD79B, and MYC in OCI-LY3 cells. CRISPR/Cas9-mediated KO of these genes resulted in reduced cancer cell viability. Subsequent single and dual gRNA targeting of PAX5 mutations inhibited proliferation specifically in OCI-LY3 cells. Moreover, dual gRNA targeting of PAX5 and MYC induced chromosomal rearrangements, reducing cell proliferation substantially. However, targeting single intronic mutations did not affect cell viability, highlighting the importance of disrupting protein function. Targeting multiple mutations simultaneously addresses intra-tumoral heterogeneity, and the transient delivery of CRISPR/Cas9 allows for permanent gene disruption. While challenges such as incomplete editing efficiency and delivery limitations exist, further optimization may enhance therapeutic efficacy. Overall, our findings demonstrate the efficacy of CRISPR/Cas9 in targeting oncogenic mutations, opening avenues for precision medicine in DLBCL treatment.

An efficient CRISPR-Cas12a-mediated MicroRNA knockout strategy in plants.

In recent years, the CRISPR-Cas9 nuclease has been used to knock out MicroRNA (miRNA) genes in plants, greatly promoting the study of miRNA function. However, due to its propensity for generating small insertions and deletions, Cas9 is not well-suited for achieving a complete knockout of miRNA genes. By contrast, CRISPR-Cas12a nuclease generates larger deletions, which could significantly disrupt the secondary structure of pre-miRNA and prevent the production of mature miRNAs. Through the case study of OsMIR390 in rice, we confirmed that Cas12a is a more efficient tool than Cas9 in generating knockout mutants of a miRNA gene. To further demonstrate CRISPR-Cas12a-mediated knockout of miRNA genes in rice, we targeted nine OsMIRNA genes that have different spaciotemporal expression and have not been previously investigated via genetic knockout approaches. With CRISPR-Cas12a, up to 100% genome editing efficiency was observed at these miRNA loci. The resulting larger deletions suggest Cas12a robustly generated null alleles of miRNA genes. Transcriptome profiling of the miRNA mutants, as well as phenotypic analysis of the rice grains revealed the function of these miRNAs in controlling gene expression and regulating grain quality and seed development. This study established CRISPR-Cas12a as an efficient tool for genetic knockout of miRNA genes in plants.

Genome editing efficiency improvement in Japanese Cedar (<i>Cryptomeria japonica </i>D. Don) by Cas9 codon optimization

Genome editing efficiency improvement in Japanese Cedar (<i>Cryptomeria japonica </i>D. Don) by Cas9 codon optimization

PAM-relaxed and temperature-tolerant CRISPR-Mb3Cas12a single transcript unit systems for efficient singular and multiplexed genome editing in rice, maize, and tomato.

Class 2 Type V-A CRISPR-Cas (Cas12a) nucleases are powerful genome editing tools, particularly effective in A/T-rich genomic regions, complementing the widely used CRISPR-Cas9 in plants. To enhance the utility of Cas12a, we investigate three Cas12a orthologs-Mb3Cas12a, PrCas12a, and HkCas12a-in plants. Protospacer adjacent motif (PAM) requirements, editing efficiencies, and editing profiles are compared in rice. Among these orthologs, Mb3Cas12a exhibits high editing efficiency at target sites with a simpler, relaxed TTV PAM which is less restrictive than the canonical TTTV PAM of LbCas12a and AsCas12a. To optimize Mb3Cas12a, we develop an efficient single transcription unit (STU) system by refining the linker between Mb3Cas12a and CRISPR RNA (crRNA), nuclear localization signal (NLS), and direct repeat (DR). This optimized system enables precise genome editing in rice, particularly for fine-tuning target gene expression by editing promoter regions. Further, we introduced Arginine (R) substitutions at Aspartic acid (D) 172, Asparagine (N) 573, and Lysine (K) 579 of Mb3Cas12a, creating two temperature-tolerant variants: Mb3Cas12a-R (D172R) and Mb3Cas12a-RRR (D172R/N573R/K579R). These variants demonstrate significantly improved editing efficiency at lower temperatures (22 °C and 28 °C) in rice cells, with Mb3Cas12a-RRR showing the best performance. We extend this approach by developing efficient Mb3Cas12a-RRR STU systems in maize and tomato, achieving biallelic mutants targeting single or multiple genes in T0 lines cultivated at 28 °C and 25 °C, respectively. This study significantly expands Cas12a's targeting capabilities in plant genome editing, providing valuable tools for future research and practical applications.

Widespread Impact of Natural Genetic Variations in CRISPR-Cas9 Outcomes.

The clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR)-CRISPR-associated protein 9 (Cas9) is a genome editing tool widely used in biological research and clinical therapeutics. Natural human genetic variations, through altering the sequence context of CRISPR-Cas9 target regions, can significantly affect its DNA repair outcomes and ultimately lead to different editing efficiencies. However, these effects have not been systematically studied, even as CRISPR-Cas9 is broadly applied to primary cells and patient samples that harbor such genetic diversity. Here, we present comprehensive investigations of natural genetic variations on CRISPR-Cas9 outcomes across the human genome. The utility of our analysis is illustrated in two case studies, on both preclinical discoveries of CD33 knockout in chimeric antigen receptor-T cell therapy and clinical applications of transthyretin (TTR) inactivation for treating TTR amyloidosis. We further expand our analysis to genome-scale, population-stratified common variants that may lead to gene editing disparity. Our analyses demonstrate pitfalls of failing to account for the widespread genetic variations in Cas9 target selection and how they can be effectively examined and avoided using our method. To facilitate broad access to our analysis, a web platform CROTONdb is developed, which provides predictions for all possible CRISPR-Cas9 target sites in the coding and noncoding regulatory regions, spanning over 5.38 million guide RNA targets and 90.82 million estimated variant effects. We anticipate CROTONdb having broad clinical utilities in gene and cellular therapies.

DTMP-prime: A deep transformer-based model for predicting prime editing efficiency and PegRNA activity

Prime Editors (PEs) are CRISPR-based genome engineering tools with significant potential for rectifying patient mutations. However, their usage requires experimental optimization of the prime editing guide RNA (PegRNA) to achieve high editing efficiency. This paper introduces Deep Transformer-based Model for Predicting Prime Editing Efficiency (DTMP-Prime), a tool specifically designed to predict PegRNA activity and PE efficiency. DTMP-Prime facilitates the design of appropriate PegRNA and ngRNA. A transformer-based model was constructed to scrutinize a wide-ranging set of PE data, enabling the extraction of effective features of PegRNAs and target DNA sequences. The integration of these features with the proposed encoding strategy and DNABERT-based embedding has notably improved the predictive capabilities of DTMP-Prime for off-target sites. Moreover, DTMP-Prime is a promising tool for precisely predicting off-target sites in CRISPR experiments. The integration of a multi-head attention framework has additionally improved the precision and generalizability of DTMP-Prime across various PE models and cell lines. Evaluation results based on the Pearson and Spearman correlation coefficient demonstrate that DTMP-Prime outperforms other state-of-the-art models in predicting the efficiency and outcomes of PE experiments.

Optimizing the Procedure for Manufacturing Clinical-grade Genetically Manipulated NK cells for Adoptive Immunotherapy

BackgroundEx vivo expanded natural killer (NK) cells hold significant potential as antitumor effector cells for adoptive immunotherapy. However, producing clinical-grade genetically modified NK cells in sufficient quantities presents a considerable challenge. MethodsWe tested RPMI 1640, KBM581, SCGM, NK MACS, X-VIVO 15, and AIM-V, each supplemented with fetal bovine serum (FBS), human AB serum, human platelet lysate (HPL), or Immune Cell Serum Replacement (SR) combined with feeder cells, to produce cytotoxic NK cells. Subsequent analyses were conducted to assess cell viability, expansion folds, cytotoxicity, immunophenotype, and transcriptome profile of NK cells under certain conditions. Furthermore, transfer plasmids varying in transgene size, promoter elements, backbones and packaging plasmids with different envelopes were used to transduce NK cells and differences in transduction efficiency were compared. Nucleofection was performed every two days from Day 0 to Day 12 to determine the optimal time window for gene editing. ResultsNK cells cultured in KBM581 medium supplemented with SR exhibited the best expansion, achieving over 5000-fold increase within two weeks and exceeding 25,000-fold expansion within three weeks. Additionally, NK cells cultured in KBM581 medium with human AB serum demonstrated the highest cytolytic activities and exhibited higher expression of NKp30, 2B4, PRF1, Granzyme B, and IL2RG. Baboon envelope (BaEV) pseudotyped lentivirus outperformed BaEV-Vesicular Stomatitis Virus type-G (VSVG) hybrid envelope lentivirus, achieving robust NK cell transduction. Additionally, efficient gene knockout efficiency was achieved in NK cells on day 4 to day 6 post feeder cell activation using LONZA DN-100 program, which can strike a balance between editing efficiency and cell expansion. ConclusionsThis research presents a Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP)-compliant protocol utilizing a feeder cell expansion system for the large-scale production of highly cytotoxic Natural Killer (NK) cells. The protocol facilitates genetic modification of these cells, positioning them as promising candidates for universal therapeutic applications in immunotherapy.

Genome Editing Therapy for the Blood: Ex Vivo Success and In Vivo Prospects.

Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) provide the body with a continuous supply of healthy, functional blood cells. In patients with hematopoietic malignancies, immunodeficiencies, lysosomal storage disorders, and hemoglobinopathies, therapeutic genome editing offers hope for corrective intervention, with even modest editing efficiencies likely to provide clinical benefit. Engineered white blood cells, such as T cells, can be applied therapeutically to address monogenic disorders of the immune system, HIV infection, or cancer. The versatility of CRISPR-based tools allows countless new medical interventions for diseases of the blood, and rapid ex vivo success has been demonstrated in hemoglobinopathies via transplantation of the patient's HSCs following genome editing in a laboratory setting. Here we review recent advances in therapeutic genome editing of HSCs and T cells, focusing on the progress in ex vivo contexts, the promise of improved access via invivo delivery, as well as the ongoing preclinical efforts that may enable the transition from ex vivo to invivo administration. We discuss the challenges, limitations, and future prospects of this rapidly developing field, which may one day establish CRISPR as the standard of care for some diseases affecting the blood.

Evaluation of the correlation between nuclear localization levels and genome editing efficiencies of Cas12a fused with nuclear localization signals

Genome editing technology using the CRISPR-Cas system is attracting much attention not only as a promising experimental tool for analysis of genome functions, but also as a novel therapeutic approach for genetic disorders. Among the various types of Cas proteins, Cas12a is expected to be a promising gene editing tool due to its unique properties, including low off-target effects. As Cas proteins are of prokaryotic origin, they need to be fused with appropriate localization signals to perform their function in eukaryotic cells. Cas12a proteins fused with a nuclear localization signal (NLS) have been developed so far, but the relation between the nuclear localization activity and the genome editing efficiency has not been fully elucidated. Here, utilizing two Cas12a orthologs, AsCas12a and LbCas12a, with various number of NLSs derived from various origins, we revealed that the improved nuclear localization resulted in increased genome editing efficiencies when expressed using adenovirus (Ad) vector in cultured cells. However, when they were expressed in mouse liver, the improvement of the nuclear localization activity was not necessarily required to achieve the maximum genome editing efficiency four weeks after Ad vector administration. These data indicated that the optimized NLS modification of Cas12a proteins in in vitro situations differed from that in in vivo.

Editing of homologous globin genes by nickase-deficient base editor mitigates large intergenic deletions in HSPCs

Recent studies have shown that base editing, even with single strand breaks, could result in large deletions of the interstitial regions while targeting homologous regions. Several therapeutically relevant genes such as HBG, HBB, CCR5, CD33 etc have homologous sites and is prone for large deletion with base editing. Although the deletion frequency and indels observed are very less than what is obtained with Cas9, it could still diminish the therapeutic efficacy. We sought to evaluate if these deletions could be overcome while maintaining the editing efficiency by the use of dCas9 fusion of ABE8e in place of nickaseCas9. Using gRNAs targeting the gamma globin promoter and the beta globin exon, we evaluated the editing outcome and frequency of large deletion using nABE8e and dABE8e in human HSPCs. We show that dABE8e can edit efficiently while abolishing the formation of large interstitial deletions. Further this approach enabled efficient multiplexed base editing on complementary strands without generating insertions and deletions. Taken together removal of nickase activity improves the precision of base editing thus making it a safer approach for therapeutic genome editing.

Epitope prime editing shields hematopoietic cells from CD123 immunotherapy for acute myeloid leukemia

Acute myeloid leukemia (AML) is a malignant cancer characterized by abnormal differentiation of hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs). While chimeric antigen receptor T (CAR-T) cell immunotherapies target AML cells, they often induce severe on-target/off-tumor toxicity by attacking normal cells expressing the same antigen. Here, we used base editors (BEs) and a prime editor (PE) to modify the epitope of CD123 on HSPCs, protecting healthy cells from CAR-T-induced cytotoxicity while maintaining their normal function. Although BE effectively edits epitopes, complex bystander products are a concern. To enhance precision, we optimized prime editing, increasing the editing efficiency from 5.9% to 78.9% in HSPCs. Epitope-modified cells were resistant to CAR-T lysis while retaining normal differentiation and function. Furthermore, BE- or PE-edited HSPCs infused into humanized mice endowed myeloid lineages with selective resistance to CAR-T immunotherapy, demonstrating a proof-of-concept strategy for treating relapsed AML.

An efficient multiplex approach to CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing in citrus

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing requires high efficiency to be routinely implemented, especially in species which are laborious and slow to transform. This requirement intensifies further when targeting multiple genes simultaneously, which is required for genetic screening or more complex genome engineering. Species in the Citrus genus fall into this category. Here we describe a series of experiments with the collective aim of improving multiplex gene editing in the Carrizo citrange cultivar using tRNA-based sgRNA arrays. We evaluate a range of promoters for their efficacy in such experiments and achieve significant improvements by optimizing the expression of both the Cas9 endonuclease and the sgRNA array. In the case of the former we find the UBQ10 or RPS5a promoters from Arabidopsis driving the zCas9i endonuclease variant useful for achieving high levels of editing. The choice of promoter expressing the sgRNA array also had a large impact on gene editing efficiency across multiple targets. In this respect Pol III promoters perform especially well, but we also demonstrate that the UBQ10 and ES8Z promoters from Arabidopsis are robust alternatives. Ultimately, this study provides a quantitative insight into CRISPR/Cas9 vector design that has practical application in the simultaneous editing of multiple genes in Citrus, and potentially other eudicot plant species.

Herbicide-resistant plants produced by precision adenine base editing in plastid DNA.

CRISPR-free, protein-only cytosine base editors (CBEs) or adenine base editors, composed of DNA-binding proteins such as zinc finger proteins or transcription activator-like effectors (TALEs) and nucleobase cytosine or adenine deaminases, respectively, enable organellar DNA editing in cultured cells, animals and plants1-4. TALE-linked double-stranded DNA deaminase toxin A (DddAtox)-derived CBEs (DdCBEs) and TALE-linked adenine deaminases (TALEDs) install C-to-T and A-to-G single-nucleotide conversions, respectively, in mitochondria and chloroplasts5-9. Interestingly, whereas TALEDs exclusively induce A-to-G conversions without C-to-T conversions in mammalian mitochondrial DNA10, they often install unwanted C-to-T edits in addition to intended A-to-G edits in plastid DNA7,9,11,12. Here we show that uracil DNA glycosylase (UDG)-fused TALEDs (UDG-TALEDs) minimize C-to-T conversions without reducing the A-to-G editing efficiency and install a mutation in the chloroplast psbA gene that encodes a single-amino-acid substitution (S264G), which confers herbicide resistance in the resulting plants.

Increasing intracellular dNTP levels improves prime editing efficiency.

In primary cell types, intracellular deoxynucleotide triphosphate (dNTP) levels are tightly regulated in a cell cycle-dependent manner. We report that prime editing efficiency is increased by mutations that improve the enzymatic properties of Moloney murine leukemia virus reverse transcriptase and treatments that increase intracellular dNTP levels. In combination, these modifications produce substantial increases in precise editing rates.

Recent advances of CRISPR-based genome editing for enhancing staple crops.

An increasing population, climate change, and diminishing natural resources present severe threats to global food security, with traditional breeding and genetic engineering methods often falling short in addressing these rapidly evolving challenges. CRISPR/Cas systems have emerged as revolutionary tools for precise genetic modifications in crops, offering significant advancements in resilience, yield, and nutritional value, particularly in staple crops like rice and maize. This review highlights the transformative potential of CRISPR/Cas technology, emphasizing recent innovations such as prime and base editing, and the development of novel CRISPR-associated proteins, which have significantly improved the specificity, efficiency, and scope of genome editing in agriculture. These advancements enable targeted genetic modifications that enhance tolerance to abiotic stresses as well as biotic stresses. Additionally, CRISPR/Cas plays a crucial role in improving crop yield and quality by enhancing photosynthetic efficiency, nutrient uptake, and resistance to lodging, while also improving taste, texture, shelf life, and nutritional content through biofortification. Despite challenges such as off-target effects, the need for more efficient delivery methods, and ethical and regulatory concerns, the review underscores the importance of CRISPR/Cas in addressing global food security and sustainability challenges. It calls for continued research and integration of CRISPR with other emerging technologies like nanotechnology, synthetic biology, and machine learning to fully realize its potential in developing resilient, productive, and sustainable agricultural systems.

Tailoring a CRISPR/Cas-based Epigenome Editor for Programmable Chromatin Acylation and Decreased Cytotoxicity.

Engineering histone acylation states can inform mechanistic epigenetics and catalyze therapeutic epigenome editing opportunities. Here, we developed engineered lysine acyltransferases that enable the programmable deposition of acetylation and longer-chain acylations. We show that targeting an engineered lysine crotonyltransferase results in weak levels of endogenous enhancer activation yet retains potency when targeted to promoters. We further identify a single mutation within the catalytic core of human p300 that preserves enzymatic activity while substantially reducing cytotoxicity, enabling improved viral delivery. We leveraged these capabilities to perform single-cell CRISPR activation screening and map enhancers to the genes they regulate in situ. We also discover acylation-specific interactions and find that recruitment of p300, regardless of catalytic activity, to prime editing sites can improve editing efficiency. These new programmable epigenome editing tools and insights expand our ability to understand the mechanistic role of lysine acylation in epigenetic and cellular processes and perform functional genomic screens.

Hyperactive Nickase Activity Improves Adenine Base Editing.

Base editing technologies enable programmable single-nucleotide changes in target DNA without double-stranded DNA breaks. Adenine base editors (ABEs) allow precise conversion of adenine (A) to guanine (G). However, limited availability of optimized deaminases as well as their variable efficiencies across different target sequences can limit the ability of ABEs to achieve effective adenine editing. Here, we explored the use of a TurboCas9 nickase in an ABE to improve its genome editing activity. The resulting TurboABE exhibits amplified editing efficiency on a variety of adenine target sites without increasing off-target editing in DNA and RNA. An interesting feature of TurboABE is its ability to significantly improve the editing frequency at bases with normally inefficient editing rates in the editing window of each target DNA. Development of improved ABEs provides new possibilities for precise genetic modification of genes in living cells.