The largest bodies—or dwarf planets—constitute a different class among Kuiper Belt objects and are characterized by bright surfaces and volatile compositions remarkably different from that of smaller trans-Neptunian objects. These compositional differences are also reflected in the visible and near-infrared colors, and variegations across the surface can cause broadband colors to vary with rotational phase. Here we present near-infrared J and H-band observations of the dwarf planet (136199) Eris obtained with the GuideDog camera of the Infrared Telescope Facility. These measurements show that—as suspected from previous J − H measurements—the J − H color of Eris indeed varies with rotational phase. This suggests notable surface heterogenity in chemical composition and/or other material properties despite the otherwise quite homogeneous, high albedo surface, characterized by a very low amplitude visible range light curve. While variations in the grain size of the dominant CH4 may in general be responsible for notable changes in the J − H color, in the current observing geometry of the system it can only partially explain the observed J − H variation.