198 PHOENIX that involve giants, and the author combines his preferred methods and interpretative interests (intertextuality, narratology, geopoetics, metapoetics, etc.) with great aplomb. Amongst other things, he argues that in the PH comparisons and similes involving giants are confined to the characterization of heroes and heroines of the older generation, and that they often highlight narrative turning points. An example of this phenomenon is the Aloadae simile at PH 1.515–522, which is intertextually indebted to Il. 5.385–391 and which, through the association of the Aloadae with Mount Pelion, serves to equate Achilles (whose parents got married at the same place, and whose famous ash-spear was made from wood therefrom) with a hybrid giant. Hence this simile “contributes to the reinforcement of Achilles’ ambivalence” (“trägt zur Verstärkung der Ambivalenz des Achilleus bei,” 206). This chapter offers many fine and detailed close readings of several passages from the PH, and it is a significant contribution to the study of the PH for two reasons: first, it considerably advances our understanding of how Quintus uses comparisons and similes, and secondly, it also provides us with new insights into the Hesiodic side of the PH. No scholar has ever looked systematically at the “Hesiodicity” of this epic, although the famous sphragis at PH 12.306–313 acknowledges Hesiod as an intertextual model on an equal footing with Homer. Thus Bärtschi’s chapter constitutes an important step towards such as study—a study that still needs to be written. Bärtschi writes for the most part in a clear and lucid academic style, and the book has been well copy-edited; only a handful of typos remain. The same generally positive verdict goes for the translations of the Greek text passages discussed; I only noticed occasional minor infelicities (e.g., ken . . . Änajen at Hes. Theog. 837: this aorist is ingressive, thus it should have been translated as “hätte die Herrschaft errungen” [vel sim.], not as “hätte geherrscht,” 50). To summarize, this is an excellent study with a clear focus, a high level of methodological reflection and philological accuracy, rigorous close readings of text passages, and plausible results. Therefore it deserves a broad, international readership. For those who like conclusions with puns, one could say: the author’s efforts were gigantic, and the outcome is epic. University of Oslo Silvio BÈ ar A Companion to Ancient Epigram. Edited by Christer Henriks en. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Blackwell (Blackwell Companions to the Ancient World). 2019. Pp. 736. The aim of this edited volume is to provide a comprehensive overview of Greek and Latin epigram, from its inscriptional beginnings to the end of antiquity, as well as of the genre’s reception in Byzantium and in the Western literary tradition. The task is formidable, since epigram not only has the longest history of all Western literary genres, but is also a poetic form which can accommodate a stupendous variety of voices, sentiments, registers, and topics—from the sigh of a despondent lover to the tribute to a defiant act of heroism that resounds in eternity. Furthermore, ever since the first Greek inscriptional epigrams were compiled into single- or multi-author book collections (such as the elusive Sylloge Simonidea and Philochorus’ Attic Epigrams), the epigram has led a double life, as a literary form which invites sequential reading, and as an inscription on an object which demands to be interpreted in its material context and, in some cases, in the context of other epigrams on the same object or in the vicinity. The genre poses some of the most complex and vigorously discussed questions in classics: the origins of literacy, BOOK REVIEWS/COMPTES RENDUS 199 the early impact of Homeric epics, the role of the inscribed text in ritual performance, the modes of reading and viewing, the relationship of performative and book poetry, the materiality of text, the origin and composition of the poetic book, the status of the author, and the evolution of the poetic “I,” among many others. To further complicate the picture, the study of epigram is constantly reinvigorated by sensational papyrological discoveries and the steady publication of new poems on stone. Hardly any other field in...
Read full abstract