Distinctive Stimulus Research Articles

Doubt reduction using distinctive stimuli as a treatment for compulsive checking: An exploratory investigation

AbstractThree cases are reported in which checking behaviours were eliminated using a doubt reduction procedure. The procedure involves making a successfully accomplished action (e.g. closing a door) more memorable, by associating it with an artificial and distinctive stimulus. Subsequent doubt relating to the successfully accomplished target behaviour is ameliorated by forming a mental image of the distinctive stimulus. A ‘fading’ component improves the likelihood of maintaining treatment gains after artificial stimuli are withdrawn. It is suggested that the technique's efficacy may be attributable to increased ‘confidence in memory’ mediated by image formation.

Illusory correlation as accentuation of actual intercategory difference: Evidence for the effect with minimal stimulus information

AbstractDistinctiveness‐based illusory correlation effects (ICEs) have been implicated in the formation of negative stereotypes of minorities. In standard experiments subjects are presented with information about a large and small group in which the ratio of desirable to undesirable members is the same. These conditions normally lead to a negative representation of the smaller group. Explanations of this effect suggest it is a product of (a) over‐representing highly distinctive stimuli, (b) sampling from memory, or (c) regression to the mean following information loss. The present research investigated the possibility that the ICE would occur even where no stimulus information linking behaviours to groups was presented—an outcome inconsistent with the first two explanations. Two experiments (Ns = 83, 112) produced ICEs in the absence of this standard stimulus information in a range of conditions. Results in these and previous studies are shown to be consistent with an explanation in terms of the principle of meta‐contrast derived from self‐categorization theory.

Water deprivation-induced oral self-administration of cocaine in the Lewis rat: Evidence for locomotor effects but not reinforcement

Oral cocaine self-administration was studied in water-deprived Lewis rats. Liquid was available to rats only during daily 90-min sessions, in chambers equipped with spouts that delivered precise volumes of liquid following completion of lever-press responses. Blocks of training and testing sessions were alternately carried out during which increasing cocaine concentrations were presented: 0.0, 0.0125, 0.025, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.282, and 0.4 mg/ml. Although high cocaine intakes (23.3–33.0 mg/kg) were obtained, neither avoidance nor preference for cocaine developed. Subsequently, fixed-ratio size was increased, and then distinctive stimulus lights were correlated with each liquid. One rat showed a preference for water following these changes, but two rats continued to show no preference. To determine if the amounts of cocaine self-administered had behavioral effects, locomotor activity tests were run immediately following self-administration sessions. Locomotor activity was substantially higher following cocaine self-administration than following water self-administration. These results demonstrate that the cocaine intakes reached under the present conditions did produce locomotor, but not reinforcing, effects.

Species difference in sensitivity to ethanol's hedonic effects

Recent research suggests that rats and mice differ in their sensitivity to ethanol's rewarding effect in the place conditioning paradigm. However, these species have not previously been examined in a comparable manner. The present study compared genetically heterogeneous rats and mice using an identical place conditioning procedure. Each animal received four pairings of a distinctive tactile floor stimulus with injection of ethanol (1.5 g/kg); a different tactile stimulus was paired with saline injection. Ethanol suppressed activity in rats but elevated activity in mice. As in most previous studies with drug-naive animals, rats showed aversion whereas mice showed preference for the ethanol-paired stimulus. This difference cannot be attributed to differences in housing conditions, apparatus, stimuli, or temporal parameters. Rather, it appears to represent a species difference in initial sensitivity to ethanol's hedonic effects. If one assumes that ethanol is both rewarding and aversive, this outcome might be explained by a species difference in tolerance/sensitization, the timecourse of the biphasic hedonic response to a single ethanol exposure, or selective association. Together with other recent studies from this laboratory, the present findings suggest the mouse may well be the species of choice for studying preferences conditioned by ethanol.

Drug-induced hypothermia and conditioned place aversion.

This study examined the relationship between ethanol's thermal and motivational effects in a place conditioning task. In three experiments, male albino rats were exposed to a differential conditioning procedure that paired a distinctive tactile stimulus with ethanol (1.2 or 1.8 g/kg) or lithium chloride (3 meq/kg); a different stimulus was paired with saline. Different groups were exposed to ambient temperatures (Ta) of 5 degrees, 21 degrees or 32 degrees C during each 60-min conditioning trial. Both ethanol and lithium chloride produced hypothermia and conditioned place aversion in rats conditioned at normal Ta. Exposure to high Ta reduced drug-induced hypothermia, increased activity, and decreased conditioned place aversion. Exposure to low Ta did not enhance drug-induced hypothermia or change conditioned place aversion. In general, these findings support the suggestion that the hedonic effects of ethanol and lithium chloride interact with their thermal effects.

Effect of Ro 15-4513 on ethanol-induced conditioned place preference

The benzodiazepine receptor inverse agonist Ro 15-4513 reverses a number of ethanol's effects, including its reinforcing properties as measured through self-administration. The present study examined the effect of this putative ethanol antagonist in a place conditioning design that has been shown to be sensitive to ethanol's rewarding properties in mice. Using an unbiased differential conditioning procedure, DBA/2J mice received, on alternate days, pairings of a distinctive floor stimulus (CS+) with either ethanol (2 g/kg), Ro 15-4513 (3 mg/kg), or a combination of ethanol and Ro 15-4513. On alternate days, a different distinctive floor stimulus (CS−) was paired with vehicle. Under these conditions, ethanol produced a conditioned place preference that was unaffected by Ro 15-4513. Ro 15-4513 alone did not produce either a place preference or aversion. Ro 15-4513 did produce reductions in locomotor activity during conditioning, indicating it was behaviorally active. These results indicate that a dose of Ro 15-4513 that alters general activity does not affect ethanol reward.

Conditioned activation induced by ethanol: role in sensitization and conditioned place preference.

Previous studies of ethanol-induced activation and place preference conditioning have shown that repeated exposure to ethanol produces sensitization to ethanol's locomotor activating effect in mice. This experiment was designed to determine whether the behavioral sensitization to ethanol that occurs during place preference conditioning is due to development of a Pavlovian conditioned activity response. Mice (DBA/2J) in the experimental group (BEFORE) received four pairings of a distinctive floor stimulus with ethanol (2 g/kg, IP); a different floor stimulus was paired with saline (counterbalanced). Mice in two control groups were exposed equally to each floor stimulus and were handled and injected as often as experimental mice. One control group (AFTER) always received ethanol in the home cage 1 h after exposure to the floor stimulus, while the other control group (NO-DRUG) never received ethanol during conditioning. BEFORE group mice showed a significant conditioned place preference, whereas control mice did not. Activity tests after saline or ethanol indicated higher activity levels in BEFORE mice compared to control mice, regardless of floor stimulus. Moreover, BEFORE mice were more active on their CS+ floor than on their CS- floor during saline tests; activity was equally elevated on both floors during ethanol tests. These results support the hypothesis that sensitization to ethanol's activating effect is mediated by Pavlovian conditioning. Further, they suggest that place conditioning established-associative control by two kinds of stimuli; the specific tactile cues serving as CS+ and CS- and the general environmental cues common to both CS+ and CS- trials.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Learning-dependent timing of Pavlovian eyelid responses: differential conditioning using multiple interstimulus intervals.

This study demonstrates that individual animals can concurrently acquire differently timed conditioned eyelid responses using a differential conditioning procedure in which distinctive conditioned stimuli (CSs) are individually paired with an unconditioned stimulus, with each using a different interstimulus interval (ISI). This promotes robust conditioning, and the timing of the conditioned responses is appropriate for the respective ISIs, differs for each CS to the extent that the ISIs are dissimilar, and is apparent in individual trials. This procedure was used to demonstrate that response timing is not a function of associative strength. These data suggest response timing is mediated by an ability to make temporal discriminations during the CS. The within-animals comparisons made possible by this differential conditioning should facilitate lesion and unit recording analyses of the neural basis of response timing.

Affect and stereotyping: the effect of induced mood on distinctiveness-based illusory correlations.

In 2 studies, the effects of mood on the formation of distinctiveness-based illusory correlations were examined. After exposure to stimuli inducing positive, neutral, or negative mood, Ss read information about behaviors performed by members of 2 groups in an illusory correlation paradigm. In both experiments, only Ss in a neutral mood formed illusory correlations. In addition, Experiment 2 assessed Ss' processing latencies as a means of investigating differential attention to distinctive behaviors. Only Ss in a neutral mood differentially attended to the minority group's infrequent behaviors. Induced mood apparently interfered with the processing necessary to differentially encode distinctive stimuli, undermining the illusory correlation effect.

Punished and Nonpunished Responding in A Multiple Schedule in Humans: A Brief Report

Four male subjects responded on a multiple schedule in which responding was maintained by a random interval 20-sec (RI20) schedule of point presentation. Responding was suppressed in alternating components by an added variable ratio 30 (VR30) schedule of point subtractions. Each component was accompanied by distinctive stimulus lights. Subjects were exposed to the multiple schedule from the initial session. Two subjects experienced four 50-min sessions daily (Experiment 1) and the other two subjects participated in one 50-min session daily (Experiment 2). Once responding in the punished components had stabilized, responding in the nonpunished components continued to increase across sessions. Nonpunished responding did not stabilize even after as many as 36 sessions. These results are discussed in the context of previous studies using animals which employed multiple schedules with punished and nonpunished response contingencies.

Tolerance to behavioral effects of physostigmine under interval schedules of positive or negative reinforcement

The present experiments examined whether the rate and type of events maintaining responding help determine physostigmine's behavioral effects. The first two experiments examined the acute and chronic effects of physostigmine, respectively, on lever pressing of rats under variable-interval schedules of food presentation. The third examined the chronic effects of physostigmine on lever pressing under random-interval schedules of shock avoidance. Three different variable intervals (18, 56, and 180 s) and two different random intervals (20 and 60 s) were studied, each associated with a distinctive stimulus. Baseline rates of responding were directly related to the scheduled rate of food delivery or shock avoidance. Acute administration of 0.154-1.233 mumol/kg (0.1-0.8 mg/kg) physostigmine sulfate produced monotonic decreases in overall response rate under all schedules of food presentation. Acute effects (per cent of control response rate) did not differ systematically under the various interval values. Large doses (i.e., 0.4 or 0.8 mg/kg) suppressed the rate of food delivery as well. When initially administered, 0.967 mumol/kg (0.4 mg/kg) physostigmine salicylate also suppressed avoidance response rates and per cent shocks avoided. Tolerance developed to the effects of this dose of physostigmine salicylate on pellet or shock-avoidance frequency more rapidly than to effects on overall response rate. Tolerance to the latter developed only very gradually and could in the case of shock-avoidance response rates be considered partial at best. Tolerance was not affected by the scheduled rate of food or shock presentation. Blood acetylcholinesterase levels showed no recovery during chronic physostigmine. Tolerance is discussed in terms of the reinforcement-loss hypothesis.

Different effects of short- and long-term treatment with imipramine on the apomorphine- and food-induced place preference conditioning in rats

The effect of imipramine (IMI) on the rewarding properties of pharmacological and natural reinforcers was studied with a place preference paradigm. The pairing of distinctive environmental stimuli with either injection of different doses of apomorphine (APO) or presentation of food to hungry rats resulted in a conditioned preference for those stimuli. The development of APO- and food-induced place preference was prevented by short-term administration of IMI. In contrast, long-term pretreatment with IMI significantly potentiated the APO- and food-induced conditioned effect. In separate experiments aversive properties of IMI by itself were also found, as the conditioned avoidance response to the environmental stimuli paired with administration of single doses of IMI was demonstrated. The results indicate an enhancing effect of the long-term IMI administration on the dopamine-mediated reward functions and the rewarding value of natural reinforcers.

Spatial localization by infants after rotational and translational shifts

Abstract Localisation of the site of an event after change in egocentric spatial relationship between it and the subject was examined in two experiments with eight-month-old infants. The event always occurred in the one place that was marked by a distinctive visual stimulus. Infants saw the event occur in training trials from two vantage points before being shifted to a third for testing. In the first experiment the effect of rotational shifts was compared with that of translational shifts. Infants looked longer at the site after the former but the pattern of looking was essentially similar in the two conditions. In the second experiment the type of shift differed between training and test trials: Rotational shifts in training trials were followed by translational shifts in test trials and vice versa. In each condition a significant number of infants relocated the site on the first test trial but not on the second. In the third experiment, six-month-old infants were tested in the first of these conditions...

Effects of chlorpromazine on fixed-ratio responding: modification by fixed-interval discriminative stimuli.

Effects of chlorpromazine (1 to 100 mg/kg) were assessed on two pigeons' responding under various modifications of a multiple schedule of food delivery. During a fixed-interval component, the first response after 5 min produced food; during the subsequent, fixed-ratio component, the 30th response produced food. Modifications of the schedule entailed changes in stimulus conditions imposed during the fixed-ratio component that did not systematically alter characteristics of performance under non-drug conditions. In the first phase of the experiment, distinctive visual stimuli were correlated with each schedule component (conventional multiple schedule); chlorpromazine produced small decreases in fixed-ratio responding (20% at 30 mg/kg). When each response during the fixed-ratio component produced the stimulus correlated with the fixed-interval schedule (fixed-interval discriminative stimulus) for 1.2 s, effects of chlorpromazine were not different from those under the conventional multiple schedule. Chlorpromazine produced greater decreases in fixed-ratio responding (55% at 30 mg/kg) when either the first response of each fixed ratio changed the stimulus correlated with the fixed-ratio schedule to the fixed-interval discriminative stimulus for the remainder of the fixed-ratio component, or when the fixed-interval discriminative stimulus was presented independently of responding according to a matched temporal sequence. When the fixed-interval discriminative stimulus was present continuously during the fixed-ratio component (mixed schedule), chlorpromazine produced even more substantial decreases in fixed-ratio responding (greater than 80% at 30 mg/kg). Effects of chlorpromazine on fixed-interval responding were also modified by the schedules of fixed-interval discriminative stimulus presentation. The effects of chlorpromazine were a joint function of the stimuli prevailing during the multiple schedule and the degree to which responding influenced these stimuli.

Cholinergic blockade effects on spatial integration versus cue discrimination performance.

A within-subjects investigation was conducted to determine the effects of central versus peripheral cholinergic blockade in animals tested either on a spatial integration task in which the possibility of rule learning was also available or on a visual discrimination task in which the daily location of food was marked by a distinctive visual stimulus pattern. All testing was conducted on the Maier three-table apparatus. It was found that the only effect of the peripheral cholinergic blockade on the performance of either task group was to produce a decrease in exploratory behavior. In contrast, central cholinergic blockade markedly impaired spatial integration performance; however, it did not impair the ability of animals in rule learning or visual discrimination learning. It was also found that central cholinergic blockade impaired the animal's tendency to enter all tables before reentering a given table during the exploratory phase of the daily session. This finding was interpreted as reflecting an impairment of working memory for spatial information, rather than a general impairment in working memory, and this interpretation was applied to the explanation of the deficit in the spatial integration performance.

Extinguishing conditioned inhibition in flavour-aversion learning: effects of repeated testing and extinction of the excitatory element.

Three conditioned inhibition experiments using an A+/AX- design are reported in which lithium-mediated excitatory conditioning occurred to distinctive environmental stimuli and inhibitory conditioning to a vinegar flavour. Increased vinegar preferences were observed (i.e., conditioned inhibition) in each experiment, and these preferences extinguished with repeated testing as well as following extinction of the excitatory element. Vinegar preferences could be reinstated through reconditioning of the extinguished excitatory stimulus. These experiments speak to the status of inhibitory responding as a “slave” process to conditioned excitation.

SIGN‐TRACKING WITH AN INTERFOOD CLOCK

Food was presented to pigeons, irrespective of their behavior. The fixed 60-s interfood interval was segmented into ten 6-s periods, each signaled by a distinctive stimulus color, ordered by wavelength. This "interfood clock" reliably generated and maintained successively higher rates of key pecking at stimuli successively closer to food. Under extinction, key pecking ceased. When the standard stimulus sequence was changed to a different sequence for each bird, accelerated responding again emerged and was sustained under each of the new color sequences. However, responding was neither maintained nor acquired when each successive interfood interval provided a different random sequence of the ten stimuli. Thus, the interfood clock generated and maintained sign-tracking under stimulus control, and the resulting behavior was attributable neither to stimulus generalization nor to a simple temporal gradient.

Sedation and the stimulus properties of antihistamines

A group of six rats was trained to discriminate the effects of diphenhydramine (10 mg/kg; 30 min pretreatment time) and saline in a two-lever choice task using a fixed ratio schedule of water reinforcement. Stimulus control was assumed to be present when 80% or more of the first ten responses were appropriate for the treatment condition on each of five consecutive days. Diphenhydramine established stimulus control in each of the subjects. The mean number of sessions prior to the onset of criterion performance was 26 (standard error = 7). A secncond group of six rats was similarly trained with chlorpheniramine (10 mg/kg; 30 min pretreatment time) and saline. Four of the group reached criterion performance in a mean of 56 sessions (SE=7). The diphenhydramine stimulus generalized completely to promethazine, azatidine, and chlorpheniramine. In rats trained with chlorpheniramine, only promethazine and azatidine substituted completely while diphenhydramine yielded intermediate results, i.e., significantly different from both training conditions. It is concluded that the relative propensity of antihistamines to induce sedation in humans is not correlated with distinctive stimulus properties in the rat.

The use of intramaze stimuli in the attenuation of the problem-solving deficit of septal animals

An attempt was made to ameliorate the deficit in performance shown by septal rats on the Maier three-table task by using either a distinctive visual stimulus insert as a discriminative cue to the route to the daily locus of the food table (Experiment 1) or distinctive visual inserts merely to mark the spatial location of each table and the runway leading to that table from the choice point (Experiment 2). When a single stimulus insert consistently identified the food table and the runway to it, regardless of its location in the room, then septals did not differ from shams, and both septals and shams performed better than comparable animals not given the exploratory experience. When the stimulus inserts merely identified the spatial location of each table and its corresponding runway, then septals still were impaired relative to normals. More importantly, the fact that normals could perform successfully in Experiment 2 only when they had received a prior exploratory experience indicated that highlighting the spatial location of each table and its runway with a distinctive intramaze stimulus marker does not alter the qualitative character of the three-table task as one requiring spatial integration.

Stimulus configuration and valence-enhanced pecking by neonatal chicks

Valence-enhanced pecking occurs when hatchling chicks preferentially peck at releasing stimuli that have been assigned increased releasing power or valence. Enhanced valence is assigned by another releasing stimulus—here a “pecking” arrow. Pecking movements by the arrow have two separate effects: the stimulation or release of pecking by chicks and releasing valence enhancement, that is, pecking directed to particular stimuli. Exposure of chicks to the moving arrow yields pecking significantly increased over that accruing to a stationary arrow. A distinctive stimulus placed on the floor at the tip of the arrow, or, most effective, attached to the tip of the moving arrow, produces enhanced valence: pecking by observing chicks that is selectively increased to matching stimuli.