Dissimilar Welding Research Articles

Unexpected thermal aging effect on brittle fracture and elemental segregation in modern dissimilar metal weld

A full-scale dissimilar metal weld safe-end mock-up, precisely replicating a critical component of a modern nuclear power plant, was investigated. The brittle fracture behavior, carbide evolution and nanoscale elemental segregation in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of low alloy steel (LAS) were analyzed under both post-weld heat-treated and thermally-aged conditions (400 °C for 15,000 h, equivalent to 90 years of operation) using analytical electron microscopy and atom probe tomography. The observed increase in grain boundary (GB) decohesion and intergranular cracking on the fracture surface and the decrease of fracture toughness are primarily attributed to P and Mn segregation to GBs and the coarsening of carbides upon long-term thermal aging. The direct observations of significant elemental segregation to GBs and the consequent reduction in fracture toughness in the HAZ are unexpected for modern low-phosphorus LASs, highlighting potential concerns for evaluating the structural integrity of modern nuclear power plants.

Improved strength and interfacial microstructure of dissimilar Al/steel weld via combined addition of Zn and Ni

The effect of the combined addition of Zn and Ni on the mechanical properties and microstructures of an intermetallic compound (IMC) layer of dissimilar welds of Al alloy 5052 to low-carbon steel was systematically investigated. A maximum weld strength of 120 MPa was achieved with the combined addition of Zn and Ni, which was 193 % higher than that of the weld produced without the addition of Zn or Ni. The addition of Zn resulted in the formation of soft Fe–Zn IMCs in the IMC layer, which reduced the hardness of the IMC layer. Additionally, the combined addition of Zn and Ni promoted the formation of Fe–Zn IMCs, which further softened the IMC layer. Further softening of the IMC layer, reduction in the thickness of the IMC layer, and suppression of the formation of defects in the IMC layer, achieved by the combined addition of Zn and Ni, drastically improved the weld strength.

Microstructure and cryogenic mechanical properties of dissimilar friction stir welding joints between nitrogen-alloyed CoCrFeMnNi high-entropy alloy and high-manganese austenite steel

The microstructures and cryogenic mechanical properties of dissimilar friction stir welding (FSW) joints between nitrogen-alloyed CoCrFeMnNi high-entropy alloys (HEAs) and Fe–32.1Mn–7.5Cr–0.6Mo–1.2 N steel were investigated. The results reveal that defect-free dissimilar joints can be achieved through FSW. Furthermore, the grains of nitrogen-alloyed CoCrFeMnNi HEAs in the stir zone of the dissimilar joint are significantly more refined than those of Fe–32.1Mn–7.5Cr–0.6Mo–1.2 N steel. Joint efficiency at room and low temperature both exceed 90% of the base metal. Moreover, the cryogenic yield and ultimate strength of the dissimilar joints are higher than those recorded at room temperature. The fracture position is at the heat-affected zone of HEAs under two temperature conditions.

Effect of welding parameters on microstructure and mechanical properties of dissimilar AISI 304/ductile cast iron fusion welded joints

Problems associated with dissimilar fusion welding are mainly originated from the differences in melting points, coefficients of thermal conductivity and thermal expansion, …etc., and carbon content when welding dissimilar ferrous materials. In this study, the problems associated with dissimilar fusion welding of stainless steel AISI304 with ductile cast iron DCI grade A536 were investigated. Using shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) process, various welding parameters were studied to investigate the successful/accepted dissimilar welded joint(s). Welding electrodes and welding techniques were the main studied parameters. Microstructural and mechanical investigations were carried out for welded joints under different welding parameters. Tensile, impact and hardness tests coupled with optical and scanning electron microscopic examinations with EDX analysis were made for metallurgical and mechanical evaluations of welded joints. This extensive study could solve the problem of dissimilar welding between ductile cast iron and 304 stainless steel. The main results showed that joints welded by ENiCrFe-3 electrode in root pass and ENiFe-CI in filling passes were the successful dissimilar welded joints with 422 MPa tensile strength which represents 104% of annealed DCI base metal and without any changes in toughness properties, where toughness at HAZ of DCI was 18 J. High Ni content in weld metal increased the strength, ductility and reduced the weld metal dilution.

Fracture toughness and microstructural analysis of rotary friction welded S355J2 and SS316L steels for critical applications

Dissimilar metal welding is seeing growing adoption across industries to enhance structural functionality and efficiency. Achieving high-quality, defect-free dissimilar weld joints requires a comprehensive understanding of the interrelationships between the welding-induced microstructural changes and the material's performance characteristics, particularly its fracture-related properties. This study investigates the impact of microstructural changes on the fracture toughness of dissimilar welds between structural low-carbon steel (S355J2) and austenitic stainless steel (SS316L) prepared using the Rotary Friction Welding (RFW) technique. Welding preforms were created from respective pipe pup pieces. The evaluation involves microstructural analysis, tensile testing, hardness testing, and fracture toughness testing using compact tension specimens derived from various zones of the weld joints. Results revealed significant microstructural differences across the weld joint. The weld region exhibited stable hardness with a maximum of 208 HV1 in S355J2′s thermo-mechanically affected zone (TMAZ). High tensile strength (Ultimate Tensile Strength 540 MPa, Yield Strength 367 MPa) with failures mainly on the S355J2 side. The fracture toughness (KQ) matched parent metal values, with the RFW weld centre line (WCL) showing superior crack tip opening displacement (CTOD) of 0.35 mm. Fractography generally indicates ductile failure.

The Influence of Microstructure Evolution on the Mechanical and Electrochemical Properties of Dissimilar Welds from Aluminum Alloys Manufactured Via Friction Stir Welding

The present study investigated a new configuration of friction stir welded joints from two aluminum alloys. Dissimilar welds AA6082/AA1350 were examined, whereas, for AA1350, two states were investigated—coarse-grained (CG) and ultrafine-grained (UFG). Changes in the mechanical and electrochemical properties regarding the microstructure evolution across the welds were discussed. The average grain size in the stir zone (SZ) for all materials equaled 4 to 5 µm with a fraction of high-angle grain boundaries of about 77 pct, indicating the occurrence of continuous dynamic recrystallization. Changes in the microhardness across the welds were connected with differences in grain size (AA1350) and dissolution of β″ precipitates in the SZ of AA6082. As a result, the tensile strength of the welds decreased compared to base materials AA6082 and AA1350 UFG; however, there was an increase when compared to the base material AA1350 CG. Electrochemical experiments revealed that pitting corrosion occurred for AA1350, while for AA6082, it was a combination of pitting and intergranular corrosion. The depth of corrosion attack was higher for AA1350, with a maximum value of ~ 70 µm for base materials, while in the SZ, a depth decreased to 50 µm. For the AA6082, the maximum depth was measured in the SZ and did not exceed 30 µm.

Investigations on corrosion rate, mechanical properties and structural homogeneity of interpulse TIG dissimilar weldments

This manuscript aims to investigate the welding characteristics, bead profile, structural integrity and corrosion behavior of low-carbon steel and Monel grade 400 dissimilar joints. The structures were developed using advanced welding technique, gas tungsten constricted arc welding, with Mo-based filler wire. Dissimilar metals after welding have been tested for internal inspection using X-ray radiography and confirmed to be free from all welding defects. Corrosion tests were carried out at various zones of weldment and characterized in a 3.5 wt% NaCl solution at 10 mV/s scan rate. The welding characteristics have been studied by conducting various tests including Vickers hardness, tensile and impact test. To reveal the structural integrity and perform chemical composition analysis of constricted arc weldment, OM/SEM techniques were used. Corrosion rate at steel interface is lower than that at the Monel 400 interface by 9.7% due to the less accumulation of heat. Uniform grain distribution and structural homogeneity were also observed along the weld zone due to constricted arc and controlled heat input.

Microstructural analysis and mechanical characterization of dissimilar welds between nickel-based and steel-based superalloys post-cryogenic treatment using hotwire GTAW

This study explores the dissimilar welding of nickel superalloy 59 with Fe-Ni superalloy 904 L using the Gas Tungsten Arc Welding with Hot Wire technique (HW-GTAW). The HW-GTAW process produced defect-free weldments with complete penetration, as confirmed by macroscopic analysis. Microstructural analysis using FESEM and EDS revealed fine equiaxed and columnar dendrites in the fusion zone and identified a secondary phase enriched with chromium. XRD analysis supported the presence of predominant austenitic phases and indicated the formation of Cr23C6-type carbide. The grain size of the weld joint, determined using the Gaussian method and Scherer formula, was 44.53 nm, slightly smaller than base metals. Microhardness tests revealed values ranging from 226 ± 5 HV 10 to 243 ± 5 HV 10, with the highest values observed in the deep cryogenic treatment (DCT). The Mo in the ERNiCrMo-13 filler and the effects of DCT, which promote grain refinement, are responsible for this increase in hardness. Residual stress measurements revealed a maximum tensile stress of 315 MPa along the longitudinal axis and a maximum compressive stress of 355 MPa along the transverse axis. DCT enhanced the weldment’s tensile strength by up to 12% compared to as-welded samples, with a 6% increase compared to shallow cryogenic-treated (SCT) samples. Charpy impact testing indicated a value of 88 J in the fusion zone, which is 1.2% less than alloy 59 and 9% higher than 904 L. Tensile fracture analysis revealed ductile dimples, while impact fractography showed a mix of ductile dimples and brittle, glassy cleavage facets.

Role of Activating Flux in Weld Bead Symmetricity during Dissimilar Metal Joining

Ferritic/martensitic steels and austenitic stainless steels are high‐strength steels, and highly recommended in high‐temperature and high‐pressure application. In general, multimetallics with different Inconel alloys are used for joining. This is quite a complex and time‐consuming procedure. The current work demonstrates the efforts made to weld 8 mm‐thick P91 steel and 316L SS plates in a single pass using activating flux tungsten inert gas (A‐TIG) welding process without any interlayers. The main challenge is to get the symmetric weld bead profile. Flux coating is optimized in terms of flux composition, coating density, and coating pattern to get the full penetration with symmetric appearance. The current work discusses the possible cause and their solution of asymmetricity during dissimilar welding. Differential flux coating density is found to be very effective in controlling the arc column shape, fluid flow, and consequently the bead geometry. High coating density is used in the P91 side compared to 316L side. Symmetric weld profile with full penetration is achieved by applying multicomponent flux (33–38% TiO2, 38–43% SiO2, 13–17% NiO, and 8–10% CuO) during A‐TIG welding.

The influence of adjustable ring-mode laser on the formation of intermetallic compounds and mechanical properties of ultra-thin Al-Cu lap welded joints

Aluminum-copper dissimilar welding is a highly demanded connection process; however, welding defects and the excessive growth of intermetallic compounds (IMCs) cause pose challenges for its application. This study uses an adjustable ring-mode (ARM) laser technology to achieve lap welding of ultra-thin Al-Cu plates. Lap-welding experiments were conducted using three laser modes—fixed core power, fixed ring power, and varying welding speed—to investigate the evolution of material mixing, intermetallic compound distribution, and joint strength under different modes. Our results indicate that the high energy density of the core laser is beneficial for increasing the penetration depths of joints, whereas the large action area of the ring laser is beneficial for improving the stabilities of melt pools. The joint action of the adjustable ring-mode (ARM) laser increased the melting width and depth of the joint, and the mixing of Al and Cu was controlled in the Al-Cu mixed zone at the upper part of the weld, to limit element mixing in the Cu-rich zone of the weld interface and suppress the distribution of intermetallic compounds. In addition, the ring laser induced the aluminum in the upper part of the molten pool to invade from both sides of the interface to the bottom, forming a certain Al invasion depth. This limited the accumulation of intermetallic compounds at the interface, optimized the path of shear fracture propagation, and improved the shear strength of the joint. This study provides a research basis for further exploring the material flow mechanism and optimizing the intermetallic compound distribution during the Al-Cu adjustable ring-mode (ARM) laser dissimilar welding process.

Microstructural characterization and creep deformation response of an Inconel-600/Inconel-625 welded joint obtained by oscillating GMAW process.

This investigation presents the microstructural characterization and creep failure mechanism of a dissimilar weld (DW) of Inconel 600 (IN600) and Inconel 625 (IN625) at a temperature of 675 °C and different stress levels. Optical microscopy (OM), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD), and Vickers microhardness test were used to characterize the welded joint, the creep rupture features, and microstructural characteristics of the DW respectively. The experimental results show that the crept samples consistently broke on the base material of the IN600 side and that the failure was mainly controlled by the plastic deformation of coarser austenitic grains, dynamic recrystallization, and the coalescence and growth of microcracks that resulted from the evolution of the Cr-rich carbides along the grain boundaries that conducted to a transgranular fracture mode.

The formation control and microstructure evolution of macrosegregation in laser offset welding on steel-nickel dissimilar alloy

To precisely control the melting of two base metals, laser offset welding is an effective method for managing the interfacial microstructure in dissimilar metal welds. Macrosegregation exhibits a markedly different morphology near the steel-nickel fusion line, which plays an important role in premature creep failure. In this study, it was found that an offset of the laser beam towards the nickel correlated with an increase in macrosegregation. When the laser beam was biased towards the steel, the partially mixed zone (PMZ) and transition zone (TZ) of 9Cr steel were identifiable within the macrosegregation, displaying a distinct solidification mode. Lath martensite and fine austenite formed in the PMZ, with alternating distributions of martensite and austenite observed in the TZ. Conversely, when the laser beam was biased towards the nickel, the unmixed zone (UMZ) of 9Cr steel was observed within the macrosegregation. Nanoindentation tests revealed that the maximum nanohardness in macrosegregation reached 5.90 GPa in the PMZ due to the formation of lath martensite, while the minimum nanohardness was 1.30 GPa in the TZ due to reduced martensite formation. Additionally, the TZ exhibited a significant reduction in resistance to plastic deformation. The various microstructures of macrosegregation were attributed to the solidification process and the dilution rate of 9Cr steel. When the liquidus temperature of WM exceeded 1455℃, a wide TZ formed in the macrosegregation due to adequate mixing. In contrast, when the WM had a significantly lower liquidus temperature than the 9Cr steel, only UMZ and PMZ formed in the macrosegregation due to preferential solidification and insufficient mixing. To minimize macrosegregation and eliminate the softening TZ, a laser beam offset towards the steel between 0.1 mm and 0.2 mm is recommended.

Influence of Process Parameters on Residual Stresses in Dissimilar Friction Stir Welding of Aluminum Alloys

Foreseeing how welded structures will behave requires careful consideration of the residual stresses that the friction stir welding (FSW) process introduces. These residual stresses can cause severe deformation and compromise the ability of friction stir welded structures to bear imposed external loads. This work uses a Sequentially Coupled Thermo-mechanical finite element simulation to quantitatively evaluate the influence of such residual stresses coming from the FSW process. This modelling method examines the thermal and post- weld stress distributions during the friction stir welding of dissimilar AA2024-T3 and AA5086-O alloys. The procedure entails an initial thermal analysis followed by a mechanical analysis to determine the distribution of residual stresses across the entire dissimilarly welded alloys. The study examined how alterations in FSW operational parameters, such as rotational and translational speeds, influence both the thermal conditions and residual stress distribution. The findings highlighted that both temperature and residual stress exhibited higher values on the retreating side of the specimen compared to the intended advancing side. As the tool rotational speed rose, the magnitude of longitudinal residual stress dropped, however it showed an increase with greater tool translational speeds. Moreover, the simulated outcomes demonstrate the substantial impact of welding fixtures on the profiles and magnitudes of residual stresses.

Study on interface diffusion and welding strength of Cu/Sn dissimilar metal electromagnetic pulse welding based on molecular dynamics simulation

The electromagnetic pulse welding (EMPW) method stands out for its rapid welding time, superior precision, and high automation, making it ideal for materials with significant melting point differences, specifically copper and tin, which often struggle to form robust joints. Utilizing molecular dynamics simulations, this study aims to investigate the interface evolution patterns under varying collision velocities and assess the welding strength of joints subjected to distinct tangential velocities. The findings reveal a profound correlation between the diffusion coefficient, system temperature, and the collision velocity during the simulated EMPW vertical collision. Specifically, at a collision velocity of Vz = 500 m/s, the interface tends to be linear, suggesting an unstable bonding state. However, when the collision velocity exceeds 700 m/s, a more intense diffusion of copper and tin atoms is observed, resulting in a wavy interface indicative of enhanced bonding capabilities. Furthermore, the study examines the shear behavior of welded joints subjected to oblique collisions with varying tangential velocities. The analysis reveals a transition in fracture locations from the joint-joint interface to the joint-base material interface and ultimately to the base material itself, as the tangential velocity increases from 50 m/s to 100 m/s and surpasses 200 m/s. This comprehensive evaluation of EMPW process variables provides a theoretical foundation for optimizing the mechanical properties of copper-tin EMPW joints.

Macroscopic and microscopic element distribution in transition zones of GTAW Alloy 52M weld joint and its PWSCC growth behaviour

The microstructure and element distribution in the transition zone (TZ) of Alloy 52M buttering (52Mb) layer near the fusion boundary to the SA508III low alloy steel in a dissimilar metal weld joint with post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is characterized. Two macroscopic TZs in the heat-affected zone have lower Cr and Ni contents than the bulk Alloy 52Mb. The first TZ near the fusion boundary has the lowest Cr and Ni compositions, accompanying the highest Fe content. Cr depletion and Ni enrichment along with slight Fe enrichment at the dendrite boundaries in the TZs, are more significant than those in the bulk Alloy 52Mb. The number and the maximum depth of local oxidation penetrations at the alloy-inner oxide interface based on the oxidation tests, the number and the maximum length of locally interdendritic cracks, as well as the average crack growth rate (CGR) in terms of the stress corrosion cracking (SCC) band based on the SCC tests in the first TZ are higher than those in the second TZ. The average SCC CGR is enhanced by macroscopic element dilution, while local oxidation penetration, as well as locally interdendritic SCC, are thought to be enhanced by both the macroscopic dilution of Cr in the TZs and the microscopic Cr depletion at dendrite boundaries.

Investigation on microstructure and mechanical properties of the dissimilar lap welding of Al alloy to steel with different filler materials and laser powers

Investigation on microstructure and mechanical properties of the dissimilar lap welding of Al alloy to steel with different filler materials and laser powers

Comparative Studies on Mechanical Properties and Microstructural Changes of AA5052 and AA6082 Dissimilar Weldments Developed by TIG, MIG, and FSW Techniques

Comparative Studies on Mechanical Properties and Microstructural Changes of AA5052 and AA6082 Dissimilar Weldments Developed by TIG, MIG, and FSW Techniques

Hastelloy C276/AISI SS304 dissimilar metal welding: A comparative review of the effective application of laser and Micro-GTAW

Hastelloy C276, known for its high temperature strength and corrosion resistance, is essential in the manufacture of medical devices and aerospace components. This study developed a micro-controlled GTA welding technology capable of precisely welding 0.4 mm thick dissimilar metals, Hastelloy C276 and SS304. This technology utilizes advanced digital signal processing (DSP) to control the arc time with precision up to 1/100 of a second and improves the welding quality through spot stitch and cold-welding functions. Moreover, the use of 300A inverter-type GTA welding equipment and 2 kW fiber laser welding equipment in this study improved the precision of the welding process. The effectiveness of this technology has been validated through macro-inspections and heat-affected zone (HAZ) analysis. The new welding technique demonstrates the potential to overcome existing welding limitations on thin Hastelloy C276 plates by integrating digital signal processing and rapid response control mechanisms.

Assessing the Performance of a Dual-Speed Tool When Friction Stir Welding Cast Mg AZ91 with Wrought Al 6082.

A novel dual-speed tool for which the shoulder and pin rotation speeds are separately established was utilized to friction stir weld cast magnesium AZ91 with wrought aluminum 6082-T6. To assess the performance and efficacy of the dual-speed tool, baseline dissimilar welds were also fabricated using a conventional FSW tool. Optical microscopy characterized the weld microstructures, and a numerical simulation enhanced the understanding of the temperature and material flow behaviors. For both tool types, regions of the welds contained significant amounts of the AZ91 primary eutectic phase, Al12Mg17, indicating that weld zone temperatures exceeded the solidus temperature of α-Mg (470 °C). Liquation, therefore, occurred during processing with subsequent eutectic formation upon cooling below the primary eutectic temperature (437 °C). The brittle character of the eutectic phase promoted cracking in the fusion zone, and the "process window" for quality welds was narrow. For the conventional tool, offsetting to the aluminum side (advancing side) mitigated eutectic formation and improved weld quality. For the dual-speed tool, experimental trials demonstrated that separate rotation speeds for the shoulder and pin could mitigate eutectic formation and produce quality welds without an offset at relatively higher weld speeds than the conventional tool. Exploration of various weld parameters coupled with the simulation identified the bounds of a process window based on the percentage of weld cross-section exceeding the eutectic temperature and on the material flow rate at the tool trailing edge. For the dual-speed tool, a minimum flow rate of 26.0 cm3/s and a maximum percentage of the weld cross-section above the eutectic temperature of 35% produced a defect-free weld.

Failure Analysis of Dissimilar Metal Welds between Ferritic Heat Resistant Steels and Austenitic Stainless Steels in Power Plant

This study analysed the failure of dissimilar metal welds (DMWs) between ferritic heat resistant steels and austenitic stainless steels and investigated its influencing factors by means of numerical simulation, microstructure characterization and mechanical property test. Under the long-term high-temperature service condition in practical power plant, the DMW failure mode was along the interface between nickel-based weld metal (WM) and ferritic heat resistant steel, and the failure mechanism was stress/strain concentration, microstructure degradation and oxidation coupling acting on the interface. The numerical simulation results show that interface stress/strain concentration was due to the differences in coefficient of thermal expansion and creep strength, and the degree of stress/strain concentration was related to service time. The ferrite band formed at the WM/ferritic steel interface was prone to cracking, attracting the fracture along the interface. The interface crack allowed oxidation to develop along the WM/ferritic steel interface. During long-term service, the interface stress/strain concentration, microstructure and oxidation all evolved, which synergistically promoted interface failure of DMW. However, only under the long-term service of low stress conditions could trigger the interface failure of DMW. Meanwhile, long-term service would reduce the mechanical strength and plasticity of DMW.