Reviewed by: The Trials of Thomas Morton: An Anglican Lawyer, His Puritan Foes, and the Battle for a New England by Peter C. Mancall Matt Cohen (bio) The Trials of Thomas Morton: An Anglican Lawyer, His Puritan Foes, and the Battle for a New England peter c. mancall Yale University Press, 2019 278 pp. Thomas Morton is one of the most notorious figures in early colonial American literature. Repeatedly deported from New England for crimes ranging from arms-dealing with the region's Native people to [End Page 931] undermining the authority of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, Morton is equally famous for his revels around a Maypole at the place he christened Ma-re Mount. Excerpts from his incomparable 1637 New English Canaan—with its harsh criticism of the Pilgrims and some of the earliest Western-style poetry known to have been composed in English North America—are widely taught in college classrooms. Yet comparatively little is known about the life of this provocateur, sympathizer with Native people, and baroque literary craftsman. It is not for lack of curiosity or scholarly elbow-grease, as Peter Mancall shows in his compelling biography The Trials of Thomas Morton. Morton's checkered career has attracted the attention of many a scholar and antiquarian. Most recently, Jack Dempsey's biography of the troublesome lawyer and critical edition of New English Canaan built on the rich trove of Charles Francis Adams Jr.'s 1883 edition. Interest in Morton has even run high into the ranks of US leadership. John Adams was so gripped by the story of Ma-re Mount and its lord of misrule that he wrote a history of the place, "Scraps of the History of Mount Wollaston, with Notes," which has remained unpublished to this day. Charles Francis Jr. based his edition on the copy of New English Canaan owned by his more famous Adams fore-bears; Mt. Wollaston (Ma-re Mount, and to the Pilgrims, "Merrymount") was on the family property. The Trials of Thomas Morton is a page-turner of the best kind. The titular trials were of three sorts: the literal trials that marked Morton's tumultuous legal life; the metaphorical ones he endured in a wandering existence between England and America; and the literary and historiographical ones that have ensued in the centuries since his death around 1647 in Acomenticus (today York, Maine). Mancall has new findings to offer about all three, and he weaves them seamlessly into his account, while humbly acknowledging the many gaps and contradictions that remain in our knowledge of Morton's life. The book moves chronologically, beginning with Morton's birth in England's West Country around 1575. Almost nothing is known of his early years, so Mancall gives us a sketch of the two "homelands" with which Morton is associated, in England old and new. We get a sense of the imperial mood in the country of his birth and of the lifeways and cosmology of the Natives of the northeastern woodlands to which he emigrated. Mancall's detailed account of Morton's relationship with Alice Miller, the Swallowfield widow he married after serving as solicitor in the [End Page 932] settlement of her husband's estate, is particularly striking. One gets the picture of a family torn apart by greed, with a new head of the household who more or less fit right in. Still, given the stakes—substantial English land holdings—Morton's abandonment of the Miller clan remains something of an enigma. Mancall's account of Morton's collaborations with Sir Ferdinando Gorges, veteran and member of the Council for New England, is equally rich and well contextualized. The council's scheme was, in effect, to suborn the charters of the colonies already established in New England, including Plymouth and eventually Massachusetts Bay, and thus to take control of governance, the disposition of land, and the flow of trade. "Morton posed a danger," he writes, "because he worked to undermine the legitimacy of the legal claim that gave colonists the authority from their monarch to establish and maintain villages on the homelands of others" (208). Those others play an important role in Mancall's account of the tensions between...