Stimuli-responsive elastic metamaterials augment unique subwavelength features and wave manipulation capabilities with a degree of tunability, which enables them to cut across different time scales and frequency regimes. Here, we present an experimental framework for robust local resonance bandgap control enabled by enhanced magneto-mechanical coupling properties of a magnetorheological elastomer, serving as the resonating stiffness of a metamaterial cell. During the curing process, ferromagnetic particles in the elastomeric matrix are aligned under the effect of an external magnetic field. As a result, particle chains with preferred orientation form along the field direction. The resulting anisotropic behavior significantly boosts the sensitivity of the metamaterial’s elastic modulus to the imposed field during operation, which is then exploited to control the dispersive dynamics and experimentally shift the location and width of the resonance-based bandgap along the frequency axis. Finally, numerical simulations are used to project the performance of the magnetically-tunable metamaterial at stronger magnetic fields and increased levels of material anisotropy, as a blueprint for broader implementations of in situ tunable active metamaterials.